5 ms·
> When I was taught math (and it really wasn't that long ago), we were never allowed to use calculators, and we did sheet after sheet after sheet of additions,
by DanBC 11y ago
> When I was taught math (and it really wasn't that long ago), we were never allowed to use calculators, and we did sheet after sheet after sheet of additions, subtractions, multiplications, divisions, polynomial expansions, equation simplifications,
A child can do sheet after sheet of calculations and co-incidentally get the right answer, without having any understanding of what they're doing.
They can manipulate these symbols because they've memorised a routine. But because they lack understanding they stumble when they move onto something more advanced - they need to forget what they thought they knew, re-learn it properly, and learn the new thing.
I agree that the first example is a confusing example to use, and that there doesn't seem to be much difference.
- nmrm2 11y agoYou'd be absolutely astounded at the number of vector calculus students at highly regarded universities who: * identify a rote procedure to apply when a problem of a particular form is seen * execute the rote procedure * come up with "<equation here> / 0" * ... and then turn the thing in anyways.
- jerf 11y agoTo me, this is the real problem. I see little reason to believe that Common Core fixes it. But then, I have a bit of an unusual perspective on the problem. My position isn't that the old curriculum is good and this new one is bad. They're all pretty darned bad. Common Core has some neat bits in it, but it's still polishing a turd; Lockhart's Lament still applies to it in full force.
- nmrm2 11y agoCommon Core is an improvement. But things won't get much better until teaching pays a competitive salary.
- tempestn 11y agoThat, or very slowly as iterative improvements to education eventually produce better-educated teachers.
- nmrm2 11y agoI am one of little faith. At the high school level, there's really only so much that can be done without the instructor understanding the end-game. It's just fundamentally difficult for an algebra teacher to effectively teach algebra is they haven't really groked any group or ring theory or linear algegra. And it's really hard for a Calc I instructor to teach effectively without having really mastered some elementary analysis. Especially the second one. I'm not sure what a calc I teacher is supposed to say if a student has any foundational questions, which any bright student probably will.
- DanBC 11y ago> You'd be absolutely astounded No, I wouldn't! Take much easier examples: Percentages. Ask someone what 10% of 230 is, and most people can give you the right answer. They might not understand what's going on, but they can type the right buttons on a calculator. Now ask them to find what 37 is as a percentage of 390 and an alarming number of people will struggle. Or ask them "This TV now costs $240. It's had a %10 discount applied. How much did it cost before the discount?" It's alarming because so much information is presented as percentages.
- userbinator 11y agoA child can do sheet after sheet of calculations and co-incidentally get the right answer, without having any understanding of what they're doing I think the intent of those is to let the implication of what multiplication really is sink in as they do those calculations repeatedly - as they start to notice patterns in the numbers. But because they lack understanding they stumble when they move onto something more advanced On the contrary, if they memorise the tables they can multiply quickly without much thought, which becomes useful later on when they move onto more advanced concepts. The alternative is to "understand" multiplication; but not having done it much, fumble around and be error-prone when solving a more advanced problem actually requires the use of multiplication as part of its solution. It's distracting to the thought process and inefficient to have to exert effort to recall "how to multiply" (and possibly "how to add", but hopefully not "how to count" too...) when one's focus should actually be on a higher-level concept. I worked with some first-year CS students and the number of them who had difficulty with a single digit by single digit multiplication (e.g. 7 x 8) makes me think mental arithmetic is one of those skills that really needs to be drilled into heads. Understanding the concept is good, but being able to effortlessly put that into practice is even better.
- kasey_junk 11y ago> Understanding the concept is good, but being able to effortlessly put that into practice is even better. Except we have tons of evidence that multiplication drills do not get lots of people to that effortless level. I was a product of the old multiplication system and I think it's humorous that you chose 7x8 as an example, as its one I can never remember. I always have to calculate it using the actual underlying math. And guess what, that's always served me perfectly well even in a highly technical profession.
- DanBC 11y agohttp://mathmistakes.org/subtraction-algorithms/ http://mathmistakes.org/subtraction-algorithms/ Here's a sheet of subtraction. What can we tell of the student's understanding from this sheet? Take something simple like number placement - can we tell if the student understands there's a unit column and a tens column? Here's a video of a girl with a pile of counters. She's asked to separate them into piles of tens, and asked to count the left overs. Then she's asked how many she has, and how she'd find out. She counts each counter individually. She's asked to write the number, and she correctly writes the tens and units in the right place. So there's some understanding, but she's not able to transfer it from one area (writing the number) to another (counting the counters). http://mathmistakes.org/mistake-hall-of-fame-cena/ http://mathmistakes.org/mistake-hall-of-fame-cena/