10 ms·
Adblockers: The Only Way Out
- LoSboccacc 11y agoQuite optimistic views there. Most content doesn't have a real monetary value beyond generating views. There won't be an acceptable ads consortium, advertisers will only get more ruthless or die.
- elipsey 11y agoIt really does seem like a race to the bottom at this point, but it's a releif to see that we're starting to move past calling people theives for ad blocking. Except for the scolding, this situation reminds of the days shortly before everyone had popup blocking built in to browsers; for normal people the internet is broken, and for us, it's hard to realize how awful it is until we use grandma's computer, and get a horrifying reminder of how the other half lives. If someone's business model relies on exploiting security flaws on the client, they shouldn't expect to trade on that forever.
- cpeterso 11y agoI don't use an ad blocker (because I want to experience the web that most users do), but it feels like the annoying ad problem has gotten much, much worse in just the last 1–2 months.
- Goronmon 11y ago...it's hard to realize how awful it is until we use grandma's computer, and get a horrifying reminder of how the other half lives. I don't run an ad-blocker and I don't run into too many problems. I avoid sites that annoy me with ads, it's pretty simple. I actually have the reverse outlook that you have. I feel like most people over-exagerrate the ad problem to more easily justify running an ad-blocker.
- BeefySwain 11y agoIf you honestly believe that then you should try to associate with more technically illiterate. The web is a metaphorical minefield of malware. The average internet user can't download chrome without installing two or three pieces of adware along the way.
- chasing 11y ago> Most content doesn't have a real monetary value beyond generating views. There won't be an acceptable ads consortium, advertisers will only get more ruthless or die. Let's hope that sort of content dies. I mean: 10 Reasons I Hope That Kind of Content Dies -- #6 Will Blow Your Mind!!
- VLM 11y agoIts interesting that my local newspaper is primarily a social network for people I don't care about. A concert review by someone I don't care about, a theater review by someone I don't care about, a probably paid restaurant review by someone I don't care about. They do a heavy business in reselling a Reuters feed, corporate press releases, and government press releases, but I don't need any of that, or I get it from the source. Its quite possible "news" as a filler product is obsolete.
- LoSboccacc 11y agoOne day I'll just talk viral the whole day and see what happen next.
- omouse 11y agoThat's a good thing. There are a lot of things in life that constitute "make work". There's armies of writers and researchers out there who are working on creating filler content. They shouldn't be working on that junk. Advertisers don't need to be tracking damn near everything because much of the time that data and analysis is completely ignored. I think ads are the clearest sign that our society has generated a lot of make-work to keep people busy. Depressing.
- LoSboccacc 11y agocase in point https://citytog.wordpress.com/2015/09/29/iphone-users-beware-of-new-text-message-exploit/ https://citytog.wordpress.com/2015/09/29/iphone-users-beware... advertisers sending promotions trough iphone exploits
- zaphar 11y agoThe actual title is "Adblockers: The only way out" which communicates a very different intent than the current title for this submission.
- colinprince 11y agochanged, thanks!
- masterleep 11y agoIf publishers start to really notice ad blockers, they are just going to proxy everything through their web servers.
- wvenable 11y agoThat won't help; ad blockers can block ads on the same domain as the content.
- schneitj 11y agoHow does it tell the ads and content apart? Short of having some sort of flagging system with a user base, I don't think there is a technical way to do this.
- Spivak 11y agoOne would have to serve a different document structure to each request so that static filters stop working, but then ad blockers would start using heuristics to determine which elements on the page are likely to be ads and so the cycle continues.
- hugh4 11y agoBut there's a BUY degree of A mixing that they NEW can't cope with AUDI surely.
- jdp23 11y agofnord
- douche 11y agoIncreasingly, I'm finding myself using Stylish to nuke page elements that are irritating or terrible. Unless they make the ad content indistinguishable from the real content, they can't force me to look at their ads (or the parts of their sites that I find useless, distracting, or aggravating).
- vollmond 11y ago
- chias 11y agoUnless the advertising landscape changes drastically from what it is today, I will never not use an ad-blocker, and I reject the notion that it is somehow unethical: for over a decade and a half the online advertising industry has been exploiting every technical loophole or shenanigan it has been able to find in order to degrade my experience, security, privacy for the sake of their bottom line; the comparatively recently the phenomenon of ad-blockers -- a technical measure on the other side of the fence -- has the industry up in arms with cries that they're unethical. Really? If your business model relies on technical tricks whose ethics are in a very dark-grey area, you do not get to play the ethics card when I use a technical trick to protect myself from you. Yes there are "nice" ads and content creators that need to monetize, and it's sad that they get caught in the crossfire. But I'm not willing to sacrifice my security and privacy for the benefit of those. It's like saying "yeah uncle Bob gets drunk and beats us but his buddy is a really nice guy just trying to get by". Sorry Bob, you're not welcome in my home.
- kbenson 11y agoThe argument isn't that it's unethical to not watch ads, it's that it's unethical to not watch the ads but still take what they offer in exchange. Any industry would be up in arms with people walking away with their goods without paying. It's really not that different than the MPAA or RIAA, especially in that since we don't like them, we feel justified in behavior that normally we wouldn't take. Does the RIAA being a shitty organization mean that we should steal (music) from their constituents, or that we should boycott them? Does the MPAA doing shitty things mean we should steal movies from them, or that we should boycott them? How is viewing content without seeing ads any different? Two wrongs don't make a right. Now, to clarify, I'm not expecting anyone to stop using ad-blockers. That's stupid, there are very real reasons why they are useful, but acting like there's no ethical problem with the current situation, IMO, is ridiculous. The first step to fixing the problem in a sustainable way is acknowledging the problem in it's entirety, and that includes our part. Otherwise whichever side convinces enough politicians first gets a temporary advantage, until it sways the other way, or we finally get better legislation. Why not aim for a good compromise from the beginning, so everyone wins? > It's like saying "yeah uncle Bob gets drunk and beats us but his buddy is a really nice guy just trying to get by". Sorry Bob, you're not welcome in my home. Yet you keep using his summer home for vacation. Perhaps cutting off contact would send a clearer signal?
- omouse 11y agoAds are a very bad hack to the problem of getting people to spread news of a product through word-of-mouth. Things like the AeroPress get lots of sales and I've only seen them sitting on a shelf in a coffee shop, being talked about online, etc. The ads I see for New Relic, PagerDuty, PyCharm, etc. are relevant to me but they are not actionable. They would be relevant and actionable if I am consciously looking for these products as part of a report that will kick-start the procurement process. All the books I've bought in the last year were based on recommendations from blogs and podcasts. We're at peak ads on the internet.
- linkydinkandyou 11y agoI block ads for one reason--they can and have been used to deliver malicious content, quite frequently too, even on otherwise reputable sites who are using a third-party ad provider. It's not worth the risk.
- mdip 11y agoI'm not surprised by the low number (9%) who felt a little bit of guilt installing ad blocking technology. If you feel guilty, you probably aren't using a blocker, hence the low number. I feel no guilt, personally. I began using an ad blocker after receiving a nasty bit of Flash based malware via an ad served by one of the major ad networks (I can't recall who, but I want to say it was via MSN at the time). That was it for me. The moment viewing ads on otherwise-safe sites became a threat, I started blocking without guilt. Because it was an advertising network, it wasn't just as simple as saying "I'll block ads on site xyz"
- coldpie 11y agoI feel guilty that the content I enjoy isn't receiving any funds from me to continue making that content, but I'm not convinced ads are the correct solution to that problem.
- cwyers 11y agoI was with the article up until "This will clearly favor micro-payment systems." No, no it won't. People have been predicting micropayment for decades now. To call the attempts "failures" would be kind. Patronage (like Patreon, for instance) and bundling are much better bets.
- vitd 11y agoI use lots of micropayment systems - Netflix, Apple Music, Spotify, etc. Seems like they're on the rise right now.
- jwe 11y agoI might be wrong but I don't think those are services that can be characterised as micropayment like e.g. Flattr is (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Micropayment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Micropayment for more).
- cwyers 11y agoRight, those are macropayments -- pay once, and you have access to all content covered by the service for the month. That's bundling, and it reduces the friction/cognitive load required to decide if each microtransaction is worth it -- every song/movie/etc. is "free" after the initial payment, so you don't spend time worrying about whether or not this particular song is worth 0.05 cents or whatever, you decide that Spotify as a whole is worth the subscription fee and then you consume as much music as you want without further worry. (The OTHER common thread to all those examples is that none of those actually make enough money to pay for the absolute cost of the content they offer -- with the exception of some Netflix originals and Spotify-exclusive tracks and what have you, the vast majority of the content on those subscription services is licensed to those platforms at some MARGINAL cost, and the cost of actually making that content has already been paid for by theatrical showings, TV rights fees, album sales, etc. They're not really sustainable models as they exist right now once theaters, TV channels and album sales start to die out, which is where the sort of content that is being talked about here already is at -- content that needs to cover the ABSOLUTE cost of creation through online revenues.)
- symlinkk 11y agoHonestly I think the increased use of adblockers is pushing us towards a situation where we will get our content from a "walled garden" like Apple News, Google Play Newsstand, or, in the near future, some sort of Facebook integrated news reader.
- alhenaworks 11y ago>some sort of facebook integrated news reader. The main feed already acts like this, only the news stories are those false sensationalist articles being shared by people that believe them.
- Animats 11y ago"all ecosystem components ... will need to congregate and come up with acceptable ad formats..." That's the ad industry's fantasy - that they can come up with "acceptable ad formats" which will be allowed through ad blockers. This comes from the AdBlock sellout - you can now pay to get through AdBlock. But AdBlock isn't the only game in town. Ad servers can fight back. HTTP 2 will probably be used as a tool to fight ad blocking. When it all comes in through one pipe, it's harder to identify ads. We'll probably see ad insertion at the CDN level, with the ad stream integrated with the content stream into one HTTP 2 bundle. Cloudflare may already be doing this.[1] Then we'll need better ad blockers. Current ad blockers are rather dumb. They mostly use some huge file of regular expressions to recognize ads. Those files are maintained by humans, and they're always a behind changes in ad formats. Systems that automatically recognize ads, regardless of format, are needed. Ad blockers of the future must work more like machine-learning spam filters. [1] https://www.cloudflare.com/apps/infolinks https://www.cloudflare.com/apps/infolinks
- logfromblammo 11y agoAdvertisers will never be able to overcome the fact that humans have free will. With sufficient mental training, any person can add an ad blocker to their own brain. The mind of such a person instantly disengages the instant it detects an unsolicited sales pitch. Having conceived the end goal, we now imagine such tools as may be helpful to achieve it. Perhaps it is useful to build a tool that blocks the most intrusive and annoying advertisement on Earth from the senses of the human whose internal ad-blocker is not yet perfected. Expand the tool such that progressively less annoying ads are blocked for those with progressively less perfect anti-ad discipline. Continue until the tool allows one with no training whatsoever to have the same ad-free existence as the adblock monk. Once the person has chosen to not attend to unwanted ads, there is no countermeasure any advertiser can take. The human is the ultimate arbiter over the thoughts that enter its own brain. Whatever cannot be blocked can be ignored. It is the desire to ignore that leads to the blocking. The traditional method to alter the desires of the consumer--advertising--is not likely to affect a desire that specifically targets advertising. You can't get people to pay attention to ads again by advertising for the practice of advertising. All you can do is stop the bleeding, by immediately curtailing all practices that led people to start tuning out ads in the first place. At this point, if you want me to attend to ads, you will have to pay me, directly. I will open one end of a channel that leads to me. If the cash stops coming through, I'll close it. If the cash that comes through is insufficient to compensate for the peace of mind I would otherwise have by closing it, I'll close it. I will then take that cash, and spend it on whatever it is that I would like to be ad-supported. Maybe I will spend a little on something that was advertised. Maybe not. An advertiser might ask, "what guarantee do we have that you will actually pay attention to the advertising we push through that channel?" And my answer is that no advertiser ever had any such guarantee in the entire history of mankind. Even my own spouse peppers a seemingly unending stream of words with frequent "are you listening?" pings. If my own spouse cannot trust that I am paying attention at all times, no advertiser stands a chance. And as I find those pings to be annoying, anyone else that asks the same thing is likely to be told, "I was, but now I no longer will be." Advertisers are just going to have to accept that most of what they do is a waste of money and effort. They are broadcasting seeds with a low germination rate, with no way to test beforehand which ones will ever sprout. If you don't throw them all out there, all the sterile seeds along with the fertile, nothing will ever grow.
- freddref 11y agoI block ads because I don't like the idea of ads. I'm tired of the constant attempts to persuade me this way or that. I want my attention span back. Plus, the vast majority of content on the web just isn't worth putting up with ads for. I don't even read the content any more, the comments are much more informative and entertaining. ;)
- ffn 11y agoIn my opinion, the "news" / "blog" agencies have already innovated on this by just blending content with advertising with notoriously click-baity articles like "top 12 ways your cat wants you dead" where every single bullet point is a cleverly worded advertising for cat neutering, cat food, or whatever. I suspect Facebook already does something similar via automating the hundreds of millions of dead accounts in their system. My suspicions were triggered because a decade ago when FB was still fresh, I created a page for my dog (now passed away), and very recently, it shared a "funny" video. So either my dog is using facebook from beyond the grave, or fb has automated his account.
- benchtobedside 11y agoOr perhaps this dog in question was using an easily brute-forceable password, and control now rests with one of the many huge botnets in operation.
- Litost 11y agoI'm thinking aloud and obviously taking a negative purist view here, but does anyone else wonder, if in 20-30 years, if civilisation has actually advanced any, if we'll look back at ads in the same way we now seem to be treating tobacco, sugar, alchol etc. etc. ie a poison, but in this case of the mind rather than the body [1] [2]? I mean all that mind bogglingly dark patterny/cynical gameplay we engage in everytime we watch one. And there's also all the negative, misery inducing, pressure when you realise, even if you sold the house and spent it all on plastic surgery you wouldn't be anywhere near as attractive or thin as the size zero model they've just tried to use to sell you the gadget you probably don't need, that you probably can't afford that was likely made by some "exploited" person from resources that probably aren't sustainable and then shipped halfway round the world. And then you go and buy it anyway and hate yourself for being gullible and buying something you probably can't afford... just so you can support some guy who's just doing his job but secretly hates himself for engaging in a zero-sum game with the rest of mankind and persuading you to buy something you... every time he sits down at his desk so he can buy his kids new ipads for christmas when they'd arguably be better off without anyway [3]. Another nash equilibrium in a world crying out for socially optimal solutions [4] or just an another inevitable inefficiency of capitalism [5]. I mean what ever happened to the Just In Time philosophy. We've ran with it on the supply side so stuff is cheaper than it should be, but every day i get bombarded by tens of emails from companies investing a lot of effort in trying to kiddology me into buying stuff which i thankfully just filter away (as i do with the rest of it - ad-blockers, don't watch live tv or listen to radio stations with ads, don't buy into the whole sky pay for stuff and then also have to watch ads). It's almost like a stupid tax. At the end of the day I'm just not going to buy your <unnecessary> thing so stop wasting my time/sanity/electricity/bandwidth and yours. It's not as though, for example, if i want to buy a new tent (which so far i've done about every 5 years) or do a canvas (probably twice a year) i can't just wait ten minutes for the next millets sale or photobox offer (i mean when does photobox not have a sale on for something they just keep increasing the base price of anyway). And anyway i'd probably be better going somewhere that had spent slightly less on their kiddology so their quality sucked less. I entirely get why people do it, the "good" of the website/service/... i provide hopefully outweighs the "evil" of the mechanisms i go to try and support it, but if you didn't "need" the money, would anyone go anywhere near an ad-broker? I can't help but think if we factored money out of this whole equation, this whole pyramid of snafu would collapse and we can move onto a slightly more healthy, enlightened society? Is this the best we can do? Would basic income help [6]? Or do i have to wait for likely societal collapse to a lower energy level to render this whole thing moot (see Tainter)? </more ranty than i intended> [1] https://www.flickr.com/photos/litost/15113770968/ https://www.flickr.com/photos/litost/15113770968/ [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JhjCrL40JIM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JhjCrL40JIM [3] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oGab38pKscw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oGab38pKscw [4] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jILgxeNBK_8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jILgxeNBK_8 [5] https://libcom.org/library/inefficiency-capitalism-brian-oliver-sheppard https://libcom.org/library/inefficiency-capitalism-brian-oli... [6] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Basic_income https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Basic_income
- qq66 11y agoOn the flip side of this, I ran a startup that absolutely could not have existed without targeted Web advertising. Our first product was an add-in for collaborating on PowerPoint presentations, and we were able to economically target ads towards people who were actually searching for "PowerPoint collaboration" or similar keywords. I don't see how we could have found those people, or they could have found us, in a more effective or direct way.
- stegosaurus 11y agoIs there some sort of odd 'bubble' thing going on here? Is there anyone out there who doesn't work at an advertising company that cares about this? Are people on HN simply playing devil's advocate? I don't know anyone who cares for advertising or for the relevant business models one jot. Considering it 'unethical' to block ads is simply laughable. I don't want them to exist at all! When I browse the web I don't want random blobs of capitalism shoved down my throat at every opportunity. I don't want an SUV. I don't even want to know such a thing exists. The 'paying for content' angle is so far off the mark it makes me feel as if I have some sort of mental illness. I can't even think of the words to describe how the statement isn't even 'wrong', it's just nonsense. Allowing Mega Big Corp to bombard my brain so that an artist can eat is a broken paradigm. What gives them the right? Lots of people like Mega Big Corp, so I should be battered into submission until I fall in line too? They have 'money'? I don't want 'money' on my Internet. It wasn't like this, before. I don't care about how 'obtrusive' your advertising is. I don't care what colour it is, whether it's animated, what font you use. I don't want it. Just like when I take a walk in the forest I don't want cars. I don't care how 'unethical' you feel me blocking adverts is, either. Use your men with guns; and forcibly lock me in a box. Prevent me from doing it. Then we'll see who's 'unethical'. edit: WRT 'not going to the sites'; it's just not a realistic option, is it? The equivalent for TV would be not watching it. The equivalent for living in a city (ex. London bus ads, tube ads, billboards on roads, etc) would be not living in a city. If you don't want to consume advertising there is no choice left. It's either block ads, try to cognitively block ads, or simply don't interact with society/culture any more. (I actually do try to limit myself to ad-free sites, not out of an ethical compulsion, but because often they're just better in general; e.g. HN, Wikipedia, forums/mailing lists, etc)