3 ms·
Still waiting for an HR blog where they checked the people they didn't hire against those they did.
by lordnacho 11y ago
Still waiting for an HR blog where they checked the people they didn't hire against those they did.
- ryandrake 11y agoYep. Nearly every 'article' about how to hire suffers from selection bias. Here's what I'd like to see: Find some super-talented folks who are critical to the success of whatever they're currently working on. Have them name names of companies that turned them down in the past. Then interview HR from those companies to find out what they did that filtered those people out of their organization. This kind of study would probably be impossible for a number of reasons, legal and otherwise, but I bet it would be a fun and informative read.
- vonmoltke 11y agoThe big problem with this idea is that many will assume, rightly or wrongly, that in spite of someone's success at $COMPANY_X that they still would have been bad for $COMPANY_Y. I am personally of the opinion that a good engineer is a good engineer, and a bad engineer is a bad engineer. Organization and culture can amplify or attenuate the "goodness" or "badness", but cannot make a good engineer bad or vice versa. I also think way too much emphasis is put on culture fit, however it gets defined.
- devonkim 11y agoThe problem is that people do change. I was an outright terrible employee for years and mediocre in engineering skills and am now fine as an employee but despite knowing the general means to not be a bad engineer am probably just middling or below for various reasons not related to capability as much as personal circumstances. The job market changes over time as well.
- jameshart 11y agoSpecial case of the general class of 'business advice' writing. Any book that says 'here's how you build a great company' or 'here's how you close deals' or 'here's how to manage people' will be chock full of examples of how following the advice works, and how failing to follow the advice doesn't. But there's never any reflection on cases where following the advice didn't work.