4 ms·
Given the limited understanding of neuroscience and the problems of Markram's vision, the whole affair had the earmarks of a doomed project. One can see simila
by joe_the_user 11y ago
Given the limited understanding of neuroscience and the problems of Markram's vision, the whole affair had the earmarks of a doomed project.
One can see similar problems in smaller effort by Palm Founder Jeff Hawkin's efforts to jump-start algorithmically oriented neuroscience research with his book On Intelligence and his company Numenta.
With all the failures pretty visible now, I'd like to say I think there's some validity in seeing if one can extract a broad vision out of all the disparate threads of neuroscience research.
There have been events in the history of science when outsiders walked in and saw a forest instead of a lot of trees - see Craig Venter, Alfred Wegener and others (and there have been many more cranks who claimed to the same of course). Making some effort to see if that kind of approach can gel is worth some effort in the study of the brain, a field whose complexity is so huge that gradual, iterative research could continue in places for a thousand years and not answer basic questions.
- plonh 11y agoIt is interesting that after Numenta's flop we have Google Brain and the academic neural net community deploying amazing successes.
- p1esk 11y agoActually, Numenta is doing well. They keep working towards understanding how a human neocortex works. It took academic neural net community more than 50 years to achieve "amazing successes". Compared to that timeline, Numenta is moving pretty fast.
- astazangasta 11y agoThese two things have nothing to do with each other. Deep learning, despite the use of the world "neural", has nothing to do with neuroscience, and mapping the human brain is not the same as making an artificial neural network.