4 ms·
Show HN: A Lisp compiler and environment in Go
- current_call 11y agoWouldn't it be easier to just work in the reverse direction? https://github.com/zkat/chanl https://github.com/zkat/chanl
- steveklabnik 11y agoIt might be easier, but showing both directions is still very cool.
- howeyc 11y agoInteresting, looks almost like how you'd write Go using S-expressions. Seems like you have access to the stdlib from the examples. I wonder if you could use other Go libraries. I also wonder if you can use co-routines or channels. This[1] allows you to write something resembling Scheme R5RS but with some Go extras like channels/co-routines, but no access to Go's stdlib. [1] https://github.com/kedebug/LispEx https://github.com/kedebug/LispEx
- eatonphil 11y agoYou should be able to reach any Go library, in fact. Aside from the Prelude, the Gsp Stdlib[0] is in fact just bindings to the Go stdlib that casts every value from interface{} into the required type. You can make bindings to any other library in this manner. I do not know why Go-routines would not work, though I have not tried yet. Another difference from the lisp you brought up (and the one I'm more familiar with, glisp[1]) is that Gsp is compiled as opposed to interpreted. This would ostensibly have speed features. I am interested to test how this fares compared to these other Go Lisps and Clojure. [0] https://github.com/gsp-lang/stdlib https://github.com/gsp-lang/stdlib [1] https://github.com/zhemao/glisp https://github.com/zhemao/glisp
- jgalt212 11y agoAlong these lines, do people here think porting Clojure to use the Go VM a worthwhile endeavor? Or, to the contrary, if one just wants to avoid the JVM, would it just be better to write Clojurescript? That being said, having one binary to distribute and install is a very strong argument for Go VM languages.
- wtetzner 11y agoI wasn't aware there was a Go VM.
- kimi 11y agoThat's what I thought. Clojure is a "parasitic" language, meaning that it is meant to work with a host, so it should not be too hard to make it work with a Go environment. Plus, the fact that there is a very well working ClojureScript means that any "hard" deps on the JVM's original implementation should be gone. Clojure is a sweet language to work in, but you just cannot create a small executable out of it.
- e12e 11y agoIt may be a naive quesiton, but what does "prelude" mean in this context? I get that I can use this to emit go code from gisp, and compile that. But the example under the heading "using the prelude" doesn't really tell me anything. Looking at the code, it appears to define a lot of basic lisp stuff -- but without all that, how does gsp work in the first place? Is it simply the difference of wrapping things up so that they... work?: diff <(gsp hello.gsp) <(gisp hello.gsp) 4,7c4,5 < "github.com/gsp-lang/stdlib/fmt" < "github.com/gsp-lang/gsp/core" < "github.com/gsp-lang/stdlib/prelude" < "github.com/gsp-lang/stdlib/net/http" --- > "/fmt" > "/net/http" 18,19d15 < < var _ = prelude.Len As far as I can tell, gisp doesn't produce go code that can be compiled. But what good is the go code gisp produces? Can/should it be saved to file and imported into another go program?
- eatonphil 11y agoI'm not sure what gisp you are running. The gsp program adds some imports by default (including the prelude). On the other hand, jcla1's gisp definitely does not include these files unless you do so manually in the .gsp file.
- e12e 11y agoAs far as I know, that's "regular gisp (rm $(command -v gisp); go get -u github.com/jcla1/gisp), and the full hello.go it produces is: cat hello.gsp (ns main "/fmt" "/net/http") (def hello (fn [w r] (fmt/fprintf w "hello") ())) (def main (fn [] (http/handle-func "/" hello) (http/listen-and-serve ":8080" nil))) gisp hello.gsp package main import ( "/fmt" "/net/http" ) func hello(w, r core.Any) core.Any { fmt.Fprintf(w, "hello") return nil } func main() { http.HandleFunc("/", hello) http.ListenAndServe(":8080", nil) } (Which go won't compile due to errors with imports, missing core.Any etc). I realize hn isn't the best place to discuss issues, but if anyone have played with gisp, and could shed some light (eg: maybe gisp is go 1.4 only?) that'd be great. Incidentlially gsp/gspc seems to work as intended. Maybe I'm misunderstanding the purpose of gisp?
- deadprogram 11y agoThis looks very interesting...