7 ms·
I believe that mobile browser will beat apps, like it did on desktop. Mobile browsers were unusable, sites were not mobile-friendly, devices were slow with tiny
by vbezhenar 11y ago
I believe that mobile browser will beat apps, like it did on desktop. Mobile browsers were unusable, sites were not mobile-friendly, devices were slow with tiny screens. Now those factors change and browsing websites on modern smartphone is much more usable. And it's likely that we will see shift from mobile apps to mobile websites in the near future.
- danmaz74 11y agoAs a developer and consumer, I think that browsers are better for most use cases, where user interaction is simple enough and web technologies are more than up to the task. But this technical consideration could be trumped by business considerations: making people pay for "mere websites" is more difficult than making them pay for apps, and if ad blocking really becomes mainstream, this could be enough reason for producers of even simple content to prefer apps - where they can have their free version with ads without having to worry about blockers.
- michaelpinto 11y agoYou know I wonder if in the long term if blocking ads may improve the open web experience vs. native apps which may become cluttered with ads?
- danmaz74 11y agoThat... or maybe it could remove all professional content from the open web, and make it some kind of ghetto for those who can't pay for apps. I honestly don't know.
- michaelpinto 11y agoYou just described most of what I see on 4chan and Facebook. But in a sense what you're saying has happened to a degree with paywalls. The really good content at say the New York Times, Financial Times and the like is behind paywalls at this point while low quality stuff like Huffington Post is free.
- danmaz74 11y ago> The really good content at say the New York Times, Financial Times and the like is behind paywalls For now, it's "soft" paywalls - they're still indexable by Google, and visible if you come from there. I'm afraid that, in the near future, they could really become accessible only to those who can pay. And the quality of the free internet would instantly drop many notches.
- michaelpinto 11y agoThat's my fear as well, although I've seen a decline in the market over the past few years. After the banner ad crash of '08 it became harder for indie bloggers to make a living. And another problem I see these days is that not only are banner ads paying badly, but money has flooded into the field to back winner-takes-all ventures like Vox or Buzzfeed. So it's hard for the little guy to even get pizza money at this point.
- danmaz74 11y agoWell, we can only hope for the better...
- tluyben2 11y agoAt least for most usable apps with ads there is the in-app option to switch them off. I don't mind that for an app that is good ; on the other hand, I would've paid for that app as well in the first place.
- bottled_poe 11y ago>like it did on desktop It's pretty great that this happened. I'm so sick of using these pesky desktop applications. Just remind me, which web apps can I use for the following? -Audio production -3D animation -Video editing -CAD design -Writing/debugging software
- dbrabera 11y agoThose are all very specialised types of apps for content creation. If those are the only examples that came to your mind, you pretty much proved the point.
- bottled_poe 11y agoSo, you really believe that nobody, other than the use cases above, use native software? I only listed the software categories which I personally use...
- IIAOPSW 11y agoNo. He proved that only a specialized minority need specialized applications. For a majority of users the computer starts and ends with the web browser. The same thing will happen on mobile
- Drakim 11y agoI think he is exaggerating, but he does have a point. How many uses native applications for reading email today? More and more are also moving to the web for office applications. Some areas are completely swallowed. In the 90s it wouldn't have been strange to have a native application for the weather, or to browse a digital encyclopedia. Those areas are now only on the web.
- anon1385 11y ago>How many uses native applications for reading email today? Most people with a phone?
- pjmlp 11y agoI am not helping it, even though I sometimes work as web dev. On my devices, including desktop, web is for reading and watching movies. If there is an application for what I am trying to do, it will be used instead.
- neuronic 11y agoYou have a point. The mobile-browsing experience on my 3.5 year old Galaxy Nexus is horrible. This is completely different on an iPhone 6, Galaxy S6, Nexus 6...
- tdkl 11y ago> I believe that mobile browser will beat apps, like it did on desktop. So now I have to "upgrade" my browser (which is basically almost a VM) that uses 1GB of RAM to run that To-do app over a series of tubes which are metered and analysed. We've really done some progress here yeah.
- tluyben2 11y agoI try to find an app for things I regularly (daily) use. Some things have excellent apps which far surpass the web experience for me (like Reddit, Linkedin, Inbox, Skype) while others are crap (all HN apps I tried, including the paid ones, Hipchat (what a piece of...), almost all airline apps). But when the experience of the app surpasses the web, it does so by such a stretch that when I start the web version on my desktop I close it again and take out my iPad. For me a company definitely only takes it's customers serious if they have smooth native apps as well as a smooth responsive web experience.
- ryannevius 11y agoNot sure if you have an Android device...but have you tried the Yarn app (Hacker News)? It's the only HN app that is usable for me. _This comment sent using Yarn for HN_
- tluyben2 11y agoI have both Android & iOS; I just don't use Android too much but thank you for the recommendation, I will install it.
- cft 11y agoDesktop apps for an average user were always a wild west with potential viruses: there was never a curated app store with reviews, which I believe is an advantage for an average user. Additionally a large class of top phone apps is messaging, which has always been apps even on desktop: Instagram, WhatsApp, Facebook, Snapchat, Skype etc. Also, why would I use maps.google.com on my phone instead of one click Google Maps app? Seems like torture to me.