6 ms·
That is what diaspora tried to do. It has not gone well.
by cortesoft 11y ago
That is what diaspora tried to do. It has not gone well.
- aws_ls 11y agoThat's why I think, it takes Facebook (the current monopoly) to do the right thing. If they open the other required things will automatically happen. G+ will become an attractive option once again, for people who like that interface. And HN types will implement their own 'social' protocol, and self host.
- Synaesthesia 11y agoFab ook are not gonna do the right thing. They're gonna try to maximize their profits.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- narrowrail 11y agoWhile I sympathize with the gist of your sentiments: What's in it for FB? Nobody (outside of an HN-type crowd) wants to self-host anything, nor do they know what that means. The 30 yr old+ folks without any technical knowledge think FB is great and see no reason anything should change. You are basically calling for FB to reduce their monopoly to satisfy 0.01% of their addressable market. I believe the force that will reduce the significance of FB will come from outside of FB (and there is no shortage of people trying and failing to do that).
- pjbrunet 11y agoI wouldn't assume 30+ folks don't care. We have been online since the 90s (at least) and we've seen some bad shit in our lifetime. An interesting survey would be: Are you "creeped out" by Facebook? Try that survey on Facebook (if it doesn't get blocked) and see how that goes ;-)
- axanoeychron 11y agoPeople might not always agree with you dude and that is okay. Overuse of the wink smiley is patronising.
- pjbrunet 11y agoWhat's your point? And I've been using the wink smiley for 30 years. You're the first to say something about it.
- wfn 11y agoHmm do you have any references to stories/explanations what did not go well - anything beyond critical mass (lack thereof) / network effects issues?
- catshirt 11y agothe issue of course, is that they conflated protocol with experience. when someone does this right- the technology will be indistinguishable from Facebook for the typical user.
- copsarebastards 11y agoDiaspora was written by a bunch of college students who were unqualified to be implementing the security protocols necessary. Given that one of the biggest reasons people want to move off Facebook is security, that's a no-go. The fact that Diaspora failed at implementing this idea doesn't mean that the idea is bad.
- jseliger 11y agoGiven that one of the biggest reasons people want to move off Facebook is security, that's a no-go I'm not convinced that anyone apart from readers of Hacker News and Reddit wants to move off Facebook. Discussions about the problems of FB on HN remind me of 2000s-era Slashdot discussions of why Linux is better than Windows and is poised to takeover the desktop: A popular subject for a tiny, passionate minority that has little relevance relative to the huge number of everyday users out there. (BTW, I'm not a big FB user and am sympathetic to discussions of its problems, but I'm also aware that apart from a small number of nerds no one cares.)
- detaro 11y agoI'd say it was a no-go because they used privacy and security as their main advertising/fund-raising argument, attracting especially the crowd caring about these things.
- e12e 11y agoI have friends that either didn't join, or moved off facebook - people that are far from the typical hn demographic.
- pjbrunet 11y ago"A popular subject for a tiny, passionate minority that has little relevance relative to the huge number of everyday users out there." Linux did take over Windows. You realize Android is Linux, right? That's 80% of the mobile market right here https://twitter.com/BIIntelligence/status/605748823709859840/photo/1 https://twitter.com/BIIntelligence/status/605748823709859840... And now Microsoft is building Android apps. So that tiny, passionate minority was right ;-)
- rakoo 11y agoNo, diaspora started as a replacement for Facebook: instead of everybody being on Facebook, everybody would be on the same Diaspora node. Federation came much much later.
- simoncion 11y agoDiaspora did a few things wrong. Two of them were: * Their federation protocol was (still is?) very poorly documented. This made alternate implementations difficult. * A user cannot move his data from one Diaspora server to another. (This might have changed in the last six to twelve months, but I doubt it.) This sort of moots the benefit of decentralization; what good is it if I can pick from any one of a sea of hosts, but must stick with that host for the rest of forever, even if they turn evil?