7 ms·
I do laugh at the image of society at large switching from cars to bikes. At the moment biking is dominated by young fit and generally healthy people. That ma
by sandworm101 11y ago
I do laugh at the image of society at large switching from cars to bikes. At the moment biking is dominated by young fit and generally healthy people. That may be silicon valley but it isn't the general population. I see lots of young parents going to work by bike, but do they take their kids to school on bikes? Does grandma get to the doctor on a tricycle?
And what about the growing number of people who need to be brought places, who cannot drive themselves? There are a great many people with special needs/requirements who will never be able to move themselves safely by bike or any other vehicle. They and their carers should not be cut out of city planning, nor should they be confined to special communities.
- icebraining 11y agoI see lots of young parents going to work by bike, but do they take their kids to school on bikes? In bike-friendly places, yes. http://www.workcycles.nl/workcycles-bakfietsen-images/bakfiets.nl-images-08/cargobike-long-ornj-3kids-420.jpg http://www.workcycles.nl/workcycles-bakfietsen-images/bakfie... And what about the growing number of people who need to be brought places, who cannot drive themselves? There are a great many people with special needs/requirements who will never be able to move themselves safely by bike or any other vehicle. They and their carers should not be cut out of city planning, nor should they be confined to special communities. Do you think people in Copenhagen who can't drive themselves are confined to special communities? Do you think they don't have roads and cars? If anything, less cars on the roads makes it easier and safer for them to move around.
- sandworm101 11y agoNo, but Copenhagen is a tiny little place and still has lots of private cars. Either they aren't living in the bike-only core, or they have use of a car. A total switch to bikes, away from private motor vehicles by all, is a very different scenario than current copenhagen.
- icebraining 11y agoA total switch to bikes, away from private motor vehicles by all, is a very different scenario than current copenhagen. And it's also a scenario that no one is proposing.
- lambda 11y agoThis is not about replacing cars with bikes, but making biking a viable alternative, such that it is actually possible to get from point A to point B by bike without taking a substantial risk of being killed by substantially faster car traffic. No one actually expects to replace all cars with bikes. But replacing 20% of them would substantially cut down on congestion and emissions; and avoiding further growth in automotive traffic is likewise important. And yes, I do see parents taking their kids to school by bike; in fact, my father used to do it with my younger brother some 25 years ago, and just yesterday I passed one of my neighbors heading up our very steep hill with her child on the back of her cargo bike. There isn't a zero-sum game to be played between cars and bikes. Improving bike infrastructure can lead to reduced congestion for cars, fewer bad interactions between drivers and cyclists, etc.
- superuser2 11y ago>but making biking a viable alternative I think the (well-founded) concern is that this expenditure of political capital means mass transit may not get the attention it deserves. Public transit can be ridden by anyone; bicycles are only useful to the able-bodied.
- jkyle 11y agoBikes also alleviate congestion on public transit and roads.
- sandworm101 11y agoThat is situation-dependant. I have seen slow bikes cause backups on roads. I've also seen heavily-used bridge lanes turned into empty bike lanes. Even when fully used, the carrying capacity (people moved / time) of a bike lane can be far less than a lane dedicated to buses or even cars. (It depends on slope and traffic speed.)
- jrock08 11y ago> That is situation-dependant. So let's do it where it makes sense > I have seen slow bikes cause backups on roads. Build bike lanes. > I've also seen heavily-used bridge lanes turned into empty bike lanes. Why didn't bikers feel safe on these lanes? Why weren't they used, or are they used, you just don't see it because you aren't looking during the right hours? > Even when fully used, the carrying capacity (people moved / time) of a bike lane can be far less than a lane dedicated to buses or even cars. (It depends on slope and traffic speed.) I've never been in a bike traffic jam, but I've been in more than my fair share of car traffic jams in high density areas. This is because cars take up more space per person than bikes, bikes are a very viable alternative to single person random access transport over short to medium distances while busses are not if the routes don't line up well. Obviously, for traveling 50 miles, there isn't a substitute for a car, but the point of this is to make urban areas bike and pedestrian friendly for the people that live in those areas, not necessarily to make it easier to drive through them. http://www.seattlebikeblog.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/12/2nd-Ave-Gif-2.gif http://www.seattlebikeblog.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/12/2n...
- TulliusCicero 11y ago> At the moment biking is dominated by young fit and generally healthy people. This is because our infrastructure sucks, so only young and fit people feel confident enough to bike around. In cities with high biking rates, that's not the case. Biking around for leisure is actually a stereotypical 'old person thing' in the Netherlands. > I see lots of young parents going to work by bike, but do they take their kids to school on bikes? Does grandma get to the doctor on a tricycle? If you go to a place with better infrastructure like Denmark, this is, in fact, exactly what you see. I visited Copenhagen this last summer and pretty much everyone there got around on bikes. I saw something similar, albeit to a somewhat lesser extent, in Munich and Lübeck, which aren't as good at biking as Copenhagen but still have lots of protected bike lanes. I already take my son to daycare on my bike in Sunnyvale, but I'm a relatively confident rider. Confident enough to continue doing so even after we got hit by a car yesterday morning. Here's a comment about biking in the bay area from a Dutch guy on the somethingawful forums: > I think the expectations thing is a big problem, especially combined with bikers being (having to be) more obnoxious in the US. When I just arrived, I was shocked with how much all the bikers broke the rules (skipped lights, biked on the curbs etc.) and just were general assholes in traffic. Two weeks later I was one of them. People in the US think lots of things are impossible on a bike, when really they're only impossible when the infrastructure is bad. Which, to be fair, is true almost everywhere in the US. If we made it good instead, those things would become possible.
- sandworm101 11y agoIt's more than the infrastructure, especially when it comes to schools. North America has a culture of selecting a child's schools from amongst many in a wide area. Not everyone sends their kids to a school a mile down the road, nor do all of their kids attend the same school at once. The getting hit is a problem. I don't know of any long-term riders in my city who haven't had violent confrontations with cars. There is even a movement towards fitbits not for fitness but to use as evidence after the inevitable accident, evidence of how long it takes to recover.
- TulliusCicero 11y ago> It's more than the infrastructure, especially when it comes to schools. North America has a culture of selecting a child's schools from amongst many in a wide area. Not everyone sends their kids to a school a mile down the road, Most people send their kids to public schools that are at least somewhat close by. A lot of what you're describing occurs when they select their housing: they explicitly pick an area that has good schools. > nor do all of their kids attend the same school at once. Well, most people don't have that many kids these days, plus with sufficiently good infrastructure, kids as young as 8 can bike themselves to school. > The getting hit is a problem. I don't know of any long-term riders in my city who haven't had violent confrontations with cars. There is even a movement towards fitbits not for fitness but to use as evidence after the inevitable accident, evidence of how long it takes to recover. Yeah, I'm thinking about getting a helmet cam. Would help for evidence, and I've also heard anecdotes that if drivers see the camera they drive more cautiously.
- kuschku 11y agoAgain, what Copenhagen seems to have realized – what you haven’t, yet – is that neither type of transportation solves all cases. That’s why we need a healthy mix of cars, bikes, transit, etc. And which is why none of the mentioned European cities actually wants to ban cars – but instead use cars as supplement to a transportation system based on walking, biking and transit.
- TulliusCicero 11y agoAlso, the idea is not to switch ALL driving to biking. That would be silly. The idea is to support and encourage biking where it makes sense. If you're doing short or medium-distance trips where you have limited cargo, biking can work very well, better than cars, both for the individual and for society at large. But only if we build our transportation infrastructure such that biking isn't dangerous.
- sandworm101 11y agoBut if the promotion of biking comes at the expensive of those who cannot bike (via transit/driving taxes etc) then the situation may occur where the disabled and elderly are in fact financing the biking lifestyle of the able-bodied. We are nowhere near this now, but if say 75% of people started commuting via bike the other 25 might wind up paying for the infrastructure. So there is both an infrastructure and taxbase problem to deal with before society at large can take up biking.
- TulliusCicero 11y agoI don't disagree, but even the bike capitals of the world of Amsterdam and Copenhagen don't have bike rates that high. They're more in the 33-50% range depending on which area you're looking at. I agree that we also need strong transit. I wish we could get a real subway around these parts. I'd also like to reiterate that in these bike-friendly countries, many elderly actually still bike. In fact, instead of looking at it as something that doesn't account for their hypothetical bad health, you can look at biking as something that supports their health being good as long as possible. Part of why America is so fat is likely because of how car-dominant we are.
- jrock08 11y agoMost local road infrastructure is already largely covered by general fund taxes, so if anything bikers should be able to use the roads they've already paid for. http://taxfoundation.org/article/gasoline-taxes-and-tolls-pay-only-third-state-local-road-spending http://taxfoundation.org/article/gasoline-taxes-and-tolls-pa...
- jkyle 11y ago> At the moment biking is dominated by young fit and generally healthy people. That's a cultural difference, not a physical limitation. Cultures change. > I see lots of young parents going to work by bike, but do they take their kids to school on bikes? I see this quite a bit. I plan on taking my daughter to school on my bike. I bike to work every day. I'm neither young, nor particularly fit. I see a very fair representation of 60+ commuters on my route. > Does grandma get to the doctor on a tricycle? I doubt many sick people ride too much. Fortunately, this use case is relatively rare. The overwhelming majority on the road are on the way to work, school, or run errands, not doctor visits. > And what about the growing number of people who need to be brought places, who cannot drive themselves? They would be very grateful that the roads are not congested with people making a 5 or 10m commute to work. > There are a great many people with special needs/requirements who will never be able to move themselves safely by bike or any other vehicle. They and their carers should not be cut out of city planning, nor should they be confined to special communities. I'm not sure where you're going with this line of reasoning. There's a growing number of people who cannot drive due to failing eye sight or injury. Does this mean we should eliminate all funding for roads all together? Is there some city design policy you're advocating? It seems like you're somehow equivocating the creation of more options for short distance travel with elimination of highways all together. More commuter options, e.g. bike, train, bus, etc. Only serve to alleviate congestion and make existing travel options more efficient.
- brc 11y agoYes we ride our kids to school often. They love it. The school recently also built a skateboard/scooter shelter for those who ride them to school. I rode to school for most of my childhood, up until graduation. At the time it involved riding on the main road through town, which I odd for about ten years. All without a helmet as well. There were three major crashes in that time, and perhaps a couple of minor ones I have forgotten. People these days are far too risk averse but forget the risks of growing up as a candy-ass softie who is afraid of putting in a little exertion. The difference is that, if you refuse to walk or ride anywhere, you're pretty much guaranteeing that you'll end up with obesity/heart/diabetes problems later in life.
- brlewis 11y agoWhat population dominates biking depends where you are. I share my mixed train/bike commute mostly with middle-aged commuters, but that's just the demographic of where I live (Boston North Shore).
- tokai 11y ago>Does grandma get to the doctor on a tricycle? Yes they do actually.[0] Disabled and weak elderly can get allocated tri- or quadbikes by the Ministry of Social Affairs in Denmark. [0] http://www.hmi-basen.dk/blobs/orig/45500.jpg http://www.hmi-basen.dk/blobs/orig/45500.jpg
- jules 11y agoActually, here in the netherlands most children bike to school by age 5, and continue to bike until they are no longer able to. My grandmother biked until 80, she never had a drivers license. Before age 5 children sit on their parents' bikes. Handicapped people do use tricycles. I know a guy who lost one of his legs, and he rides on a bike with 3 wheels. There are also bikes that are powered by your arms instead of legs for people who cannot use any of their legs. But what I see in the linked article in the photo as an example of a good bike lane, no way in hell parents are going to let their 5 year olds bike there. It's a death trap from moving cars on the left and car doors on the right. The road is massive (at least 5x wider than the average road here), so there is plenty of space there for proper infrastructure.
- provemewrong 11y ago> At the moment biking is dominated by young fit and generally healthy people. That may be silicon valley but it isn't the general population. I see lots of young parents going to work by bike, but do they take their kids to school on bikes? Does grandma get to the doctor on a tricycle? Where I live kids, young adults and old people are the most prevelant cyclists. Grandmas who have riddden bikes their whole lives, they don't own a car, and it takes less effort and is faster than walking. They're not particulary fit, usually overweight and they ride easy and slow as hell. You don't need to be young athelete to cycle. And kids cycle to school on their own. Obviously there are exceptions, nobody's suggesting banning cars altogether, but the average old person can cycle just fine and so can a school aged kid.