13 ms·
This seems like a poor fit for VR motion simulation - actual movement through space is generally unnecessary, you just need to gimbal the platform to simulate a
by jameshart 11y ago
This seems like a poor fit for VR motion simulation - actual movement through space is generally unnecessary, you just need to gimbal the platform to simulate accelerations. Actual linear acceleration is of limited value in simulation because you can't maintain that acceleration indefinitely - you run out of room and have to apply an opposite acceleration, which can conflict with the simulation needs.
On the other hand this looks more useful for something like movie making, to throw actors around in front of a greenscreen.
- udev 11y agoI agree that rotation should be enough for VR purposes, and linear translation of the subject is not strictly necessary. Any acceleration up to g = 9.81 m / s^2 can be easily simulated, and it can be maintained indefinitely. All you need to do is to rotate the subject so that the perceived acceleration is aligned with g, or keep it at an angle, to get a fraction of g. Interestingly, for VR you don't need to simulate velocity, as it cannot be perceived by the body. Flight simulators have been using this approach for decades now, and it works really well: http://arabiansupplychain.com//pictures/300x200/CAE-simulator.jpg http://arabiansupplychain.com//pictures/300x200/CAE-simulato... But this system looks to have the advantage of being able to simulate accelerations above g. PS: Is gimbal a verb now?
- darkmighty 11y agoNot up to 1g acceleration, exactly 1g aceleration only (if the platform only rotates), with varying direction.
- jessriedel 11y agoYou can't do brief periods of weightlessness with rotations on a gimbal, or periods of larger than 1 g.
- darkmighty 11y agoGimbals are limited to ||acceleration||=1g. I guess there are some elements you miss from that, like when a roller coaster starts to fall (you experience <1g), or when a car takes off (you experience >1g). Here you can provide a bit of both and also gimbal action. There's also rotation effects (which I don't know if are felt) that can be mitigated too and better jerk simulation (not only acceleration, but variation of acceleration). Actually if your whole simulation has ||aceleration||>1g you should be able to do it perfectly (save for jerk/rotation effects) with some large centrifuge: the rate of rotation of the large centrifuge dictates the "perceived gravity" and gimbals dictate the "perceived direction". In this sense it would be perfect if you could get a centrifuge with a gimbaled end in a 0g environment. Hey NASA, I have this one little idea for the ISS... :)
- ghgr 11y agoI've been working with full motion simulators for the past two years (I even rode that simulator last week at MPI) and I must say that this is plain wrong. This is actually a great fit for VR simulation (see below): > Actual linear acceleration is of limited value in simulation because... Linear acceleration is immensely useful for sudden accelerations. Image a sudden linear acceleration (e.g. a racing car accelerating). You cannot recreate this acceleration by suddenly rotating. The angular accelerations would ruin the experience. Rather, you make a linear movement, and THEN you rotate the simulator (if you need to sustain the acceleration). > you run out of room and have to apply an opposite acceleration, which can conflict with the simulation needs. wrong again. If you move the simulator at slow speed, you can actually come back to the optimal position and the subject does not notice it (washout filter [1]) [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motion_simulator#Implementation_using_washout_filters https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motion_simulator#Implementatio...
- goshx 11y agoWould adding rotation to the seat allow for sustaining the acceleration?
- lucb1e 11y agoThe way I understand what he said (see quote below), yes it would. > you make a linear movement, and THEN you rotate the simulator (if you need to sustain the acceleration). I have zero experience with this though, I'm merely interpreting and copying what ghgr said.
- darkmighty 11y agoThat's right, and this system seems perfectly capable of that.
- ljk 11y ago> Rather, you make a linear movement, and THEN you rotate the simulator (if you need to sustain the acceleration). Am I understanding this wrong or are you saying long accelerations can be achieved by accelerating, turn, accelerating, .... etc? Wouldn't the person wearing VR headset feel the turn?
- sllabres 11y agoNASA seems to think different. http://www.aviationsystemsdivision.arc.nasa.gov/facilities/vms/index.shtml http://www.aviationsystemsdivision.arc.nasa.gov/facilities/v... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fhu_UldlP_E https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fhu_UldlP_E (in motion...)
- Animats 11y agoYes, NASA Ames has had their huge Vertical Motion Simulator for many years. That has about 20 meters of travel in each axis. It used to have a Space Shuttle cockpit mounted; now it's mostly used with a helicopter cockpit. NASA's is a much heavier system, because it has to lug the whole cockpit around.
- jameshart 11y agoFor flight, the problem is that the only acceleration that really matters is variation in vertical acceleration. Linear acceleration can briefly simulate that, but it can't be sustained. That's a fundamental problem that can only be dealt with by creating that kind of massive vertical acceleration environment - even that will be limited in terms of how long it can simulate sustained > or < 1g. You can create sustained accelerations by spinning something round on the end of an arm, but there's always that pesky downward gravity vector that keeps getting added to everything, unless you build your simulator in orbit.