8 ms·
Oyster is shutting down
- heyalexchoi 11y agoso... you're pivoting?
- minimaxir 11y agoThey were acquihired by Google. http://recode.net/2015/09/21/oyster-books-shuts-down-team-heads-to-google/ http://recode.net/2015/09/21/oyster-books-shuts-down-team-he...
- topherjaynes 11y agoman, that makes me even sadder.
- minimaxir 11y agoIt's worth noting that Oyster raised a total of $17M as of last year: https://www.crunchbase.com/organization/oysterbooks-com https://www.crunchbase.com/organization/oysterbooks-com Runway has its limits.
- macspoofing 11y agoWow. What'd they burn it on?
- sappapp 11y agoI love this app. Sad to see it go.
- naz 11y agoAnother one for Our Incredible Journey: http://ourincrediblejourney.tumblr.com/ http://ourincrediblejourney.tumblr.com/
- kra34 11y agoIt would be nice if somebody built a Product Hunt list for these since their UI is much nicer than tumblr - "A curated list of exits!"
- ececconi 11y agoKindle unlimited. Also, I don't think there's as big of a market as they thought for people who wanted to pay one fee for all you can read.
- dangoldin 11y agoI tried Oyster and ended up canceling after discovering that the books I wanted weren't available. The case is the same with Kindle unlimited. The problem is that publishers make sure that the high demand books just aren't available via an "all you can read" plan so these end up with the scraps.
- cbhl 11y agoThe alternative is a brick-and-mortar library system, where high demand books have six-month-long waitlists. But at least those high demand books are available.
- levifig 11y agoOyster was interesting but not a really interesting option: while the app was gorgeous, it didn't allow you to import books. I'm sure most people would rather consolidate their ebook purchases, and Amazon or Apple are better options for that. I still miss Readmill, though… a LOT!! :(
- dangoldin 11y agoSame here. Wish I had Readmill again.
- carsongross 11y agoCredit freeze incomin', fellas. SHIELD WALL! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TTYz439cA5w https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TTYz439cA5w
- zzzmarcus 11y agoOyster was something that Google Play or Amazon Kindle Unlimited will almost certainly never be. The beautiful design and focus on details was just the surface. It felt like a company run by people that are passionate about reading and surfacing great books in engaging ways. There were no competing interests--it was about the books and while they weren't perfect, that passion was evident in everything they did. I, for one, will really miss them.
- untog 11y agoGiven that Google acqui-hired them to work on Play Books, it's something Google Play certainly could be.
- cwyers 11y agoKindle Unlimited has a killer feature Oyster never had -- Kindles. Reading books on phones is awful. Reading them on Kindles is the closest screens can come to reading on books.
- rahimnathwani 11y ago"Kindle Unlimited has a killer feature Oyster never had -- Kindles." That, and an enormous selection. "Reading books on phones is awful." It depends on the phone. Many people are perfectly happy reading for hours on a phone screen, particularly if they can choose the foreground/background colours (e.g. white on black for someone with an AMOLED screen). "Reading them on Kindles is the closest screens can come to reading on books." Well, in terms of display, it's the closest screens have_come, but it's unlikely to be the closest screens can come. But, the thing which makes reading on a Kindle Paperwhite a pain for me, is that I can't flip through the book. Page turns are slower than on a paper book. I can't use my fingers to mark two different parts of the book, and move rapidly back and forth. Oh, and why can't I view images inline with the text?
- cwyers 11y ago> It depends on the phone. I think it depends on the person more than the phone. I've used many different smartphones and tablets, not one of them is comfortable for reading a book-length text on. I know there are people who disagree. But everyone who doesn't disagree isn't a customer for Oyster.
- ipsin 11y agoTaken without any external context, this release is nonsensical, probably because they don't bother to say why they're shutting down or what the new opportunity is. "Looking forward, we feel this is best seized by taking on new opportunities to fully realize our vision for ebooks." By... shutting down? I would have appreciated a bit of plain-speaking here.
- welly 11y agoGoogle have snapped up a bunch of their staff http://www.engadget.com/2015/09/21/oyster-shutting-down/ http://www.engadget.com/2015/09/21/oyster-shutting-down/
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- georgemcbay 11y agoTotally speculating here but I'd assume the company was basically out of runway and couldn't find a reasonable out so negotiated the team to google to work on something else. Option A: company/product dies, team is scattered. Option B: company/product dies, team remains together. Investors fucked either way but with B at least team that works well together gets to continue to do so. In a nutshell that's what happened when I was at chumby. Sadly the company we shifted to was terrible so there was a mass exodus anyway over the following year.
- misiti3780 11y agoit seems like a lot of money to burn through though - right?
- georgemcbay 11y agoYes, it seems like a lot of money to burn through, but as someone who only casually watches the overall startup market I've sort of lost the ability to be surprised when a startup burns through a ridiculous amount of money in a very short time, so it still seems like a plausible thing to me, though I'll reiterate I have no actual knowledge of what happened in this case.
- joelrunyon 11y agoA shutdown notice with a photo of the team holding an "Oyster" flag on a boat. Does anyone else find this amusing?
- vinceyuan 11y agoIs it fair to Oyster's investors? According to Engadget and Recode [1], "a portion" of Oyster's staff (including its CEO and co-founders) are jumping ship for Google's Play Books division. In short, this is an indirect acquisition -- Google is snapping up the core of the company without buying all of its assets. [1] http://www.engadget.com/2015/09/21/oyster-shutting-down/ http://www.engadget.com/2015/09/21/oyster-shutting-down/
- macspoofing 11y ago>Is it fair to Oyster's investors? The alternative is ... what? -- Actually it looks like Google will pay back investors some or all of their investment.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoAnd even more importantly, who cares? An acquihire is always a risk, as much as failure. Investors should (I imagine) be building that into their risk model.
- seizethecheese 11y agoAn acquihire is the implied alternative. I'm not sure why companies would ever acquihire when they could do this with the appropriate signing bonus.
- manigandham 11y agoBecause there are assets other than just the people. Code, network relationships, reputation, service contracts, company partnerships, IP, etc. There can also be non-competes, NDAs, security clearances, stock vesting and a multitude of other agreements to factor in.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoNon competes are unenforceable in California.
- kp25 11y agoThe Title "Oyster - Indirect Acquistion by Google" is apt compared to "Oyster is shutting down" !!
- sabrinaleblanc 11y agoSo I'm not clear on this, was the employment agreement done before or after Oysterbooks officially announced that it was shutting down? BC that makes a difference...I find it odd that Google declined to comment to comment. Anyhow, great idea and really sad that it didn't work out.
- CPLX 11y ago> With that, we will be taking steps to sunset the existing Oyster service over the next several months. If you have a company with a product and the product is being discontinued is it really so hard to just say that in English? The word "sunset" isn't even a verb.
- nstart 11y agoCan someone explain the math here? 2012 they received 3M in seed funding. 2014 they received 14M USD. The picture on that boat shows 26 (?) people. So let's assume 26 people were always in the company just for kicks. Between 2012 October and 2015 September they ran out of 17M USD. That's a burn rate of 5.67M USD per year. For 26 employees, if we stupidly assumed no other costs, that nearly 218k USD salary per year. Obviously that's not right. Let's assume they paid an average of 100k USD per year to each employee. That's 2.6M USD burnt for salaries. Which means that infrastructure, ad spend, and administrative costs and taxes (?) came to just over 3M USD per year. And that's assuming they received ZERO money while they were running. Which is of course a load of tosh. I'm unaware of the US market's costs in running a business but those numbers seem abnormal. Am I missing something here or does this seem plausible?
- cbhl 11y agoI've heard that when you factor in office space, desks, computers, benefits, etc.; the cost of hiring an employee to the company is roughly 2x their gross salary. (As for income tax, at that bracket, it's something like 40-50%?)
- eots 11y agoIsn't income tax included in the gross salary?
- ghshephard 11y agoSomebody needs to revisit the numbers for capital costs of technology. When a new employee in 1995 cost $50,000, and their Compaq LTE-5300 Laptop, Docking station was $3000 - cost of computer was an issue (Particularly as you needed a lot of service / repair to keep it running, configured) - And you were lucky to get 2 years of service. In 2015, a new employee costs $150,000, and their computer still costs $3000 (or less) - and now lasts at least 2 years, and in many cases, can be stretched out to three years. In Redwood City, industrial/quasi commercial space in 2007 was going for $1.50/sq/foot - figure * 200 per employee = $3600/year for office space. Desk, chairs, cubes, etc.. cost around $1500/employee delivered/installed (Always buy used. Add an extra $600 if you want Aeron Chairs). I would be interested in seeing if anybody has a soup-nuts assessment for all of the office costs for an employee in 2015 in the valley.
- tiffanyh 11y agoI never understood Oyster business model. My 81 year old father figured out years ago how to connect is Kindle to his local public library. He literally checks out nearly any book, all FOR FREE and reads it on his kindle. Maybe this is a US centric thing and Oyster was targeting international users. But local libraries have been offering this service of digitally checking out books (even current books) for free for nearly 10 years. Don't get me wrong. I never like reading about businesses shutting down because that implies people will be losing their job. I just never understood this business to begin with, maybe someone could shed some light on what I'm missing
- lucisferre 11y agoActually, if I remember correctly, when Oyster came out I couldn't use it because I wasn't in the US.
- Splines 11y agoI'm lucky to live in a county with a good library system that supports this model, but what about the rest of the country? Are they all served as well as me? $10/mo doesn't seem too outrageous if you have no other alternatives. If you are a heavy reader then this makes sense vs. buying from Amazon or another retailer. I suppose it comes down to strength of library - for $10/mo, can you match other book seller's content? I took a look for a few books I've been reading recently - it seems about a 50% match. Personally, not for me.
- philtar 11y ago> My 81 year old father figured out years ago how to connect is Kindle to his local public library. I am a full time professional software developer and I do a lot of technology things on the side and have a technology side business. It took me forever to connect a kindle to my library, and when I did, most of the books I wanted weren't available.
- qq66 11y agoAn example of "beginner's luck," which is often the tendency of experts to overthink things when just trying the most basic thing often works. :)
- Nickersf 11y agoI have never heard of this product until it became discontinued - which sucks. To me the statement reads like an adult explaining the horrors of war to a 5 year old who glorified war without knowing the reality. Was it really necessary to wrap a simple notice of closure/costumer apology up in such an overly tame and submissive manner? Why not something concise: "We sincerely apologize to our loyal customers, and potential future customers that within x amount of time product y will be discontinued for various reasons, which we are currently not at liberty of discussing in a public forum. Thank you very much for your patronage and support. Foremost we are ensuring that our existing customers receive the most professional and respectful treatment. Sincerely - company z team." Less bullshit, more realshit.
- aqwwe 11y ago1-year-old post: https://www.reddit.com/r/Piracy/comments/2dpmma/is_there_a_popcorn_time_for_ebooks/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Piracy/comments/2dpmma/is_there_a_p...
- bryanlarsen 11y agoThis post has been on the front page for 9 hours and yet no mention of their most direct competitor, Scribd? Not a good sign for Scribd, that's for sure. Both Scribd and Oyster had a much wider selection of books from major publishers than Kindle Unlimited. They both had 3 of the big 5 publishers on board. Myself, I love Scribd, and I suggest you give it a try too. I haven't tried Oyster because it wasn't available in my country.
- PhantomGremlin 11y agoIt's too bad that Pud couldn't keep Fucked Company going. Back in the previous boom/bust it kept us informed as dotcoms blew up left and right. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fuckedcompany.com https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fuckedcompany.com