4 ms·
Let's extrapolate the argument to the second order. Mobile gaming, for example, has bad Unit Economics. Games like Candy Crush Saga and Game of War spend absur
by minimaxir 11y ago
Let's extrapolate the argument to the second order.
Mobile gaming, for example, has bad Unit Economics. Games like Candy Crush Saga and Game of War spend absurd amounts of money in acquisition.
...which is Facebook and Twitter's primary revenue stream.
There is a possibility of a domino effect.
- sjg007 11y agoHmm.. I think they have whales that drive revenue.
- highCs 11y ago> Games like Candy Crush Saga and Game of War spend absurd amounts of money in acquisition. I think this is wrong. These games have strong invite-friend mechanisms and have high retention. That's why they are popular in the first place. No source at hand though.
- minimaxir 11y agoThat's how it used to be years ago. The economics have changed; due to the increased competition in that marketplace and the extreme aversion of users to paying for things, freemium games must use social engineering to survive. Whales only play one game at a time.
- highCs 11y agoI see, that's interesting.
- corysama 11y agoYep. "A service launching this week will tell you that Machine Zone is currently spending somewhere around $12 per user with AdColony, InMobi, and Unity Ads, up to $20 per user with Vungle, and between $2 and $30 per user with Chartboost." http://venturebeat.com/2015/08/12/this-service-tells-you-what-supercell-machine-zone-and-other-big-publishers-spend-on-user-acquisition/ http://venturebeat.com/2015/08/12/this-service-tells-you-wha... GoW has very low retention. Users who stick around in GoW are the kind of people who like to spend a lot of money to feel empowered. But, finding and keeping those people is very expensive because it involves churning through a whole lot of users who aren't like that.
- lemevi 11y agoHow do candy crush and game of war drive twitter's revenue? You mean app install ads? App install ads aren't limited to businesses with bad economics.
- austenallred 11y ago> Games like Candy Crush Saga and Game of War spend absurd amounts of money in acquisition. Yes, because they know on average every person that starts using the app makes them $1.50. So they spend a lot of money acquiring users at $1 each. That's not a failure of unit economics.
- minimaxir 11y agoIf those numbers were the case, then that definitely would be correct. But cost to obtain the average user is $3, nearly double from what it was last year. http://venturebeat.com/2015/04/30/it-costs-more-than-3-to-acquire-a-mobile-user-now-fiksu-finds/ http://venturebeat.com/2015/04/30/it-costs-more-than-3-to-ac... I strongly doubt the average user spends $3, given that the current freemium environment is hedging by offering freemium perks for free periodically to get user retention. Which makes them less likely to actually spend money.
- austenallred 11y agoI know for a fact those aren't the numbers for Candy Crush. That's from an arbitrary index. You can hardly conclude the cost of install for a specific app from those numbers.
- malisper 11y agoCandy Crush brought in $1.5 Billion dollars in revenue in 2013[0]. In 2014 it had 93 million users[1]. That means Candy Crush brings in at least $16 / user / year. I'm guessing they don't really care what the cost per acquisition is when they are making that much per user. [0] http://bgr.com/2014/02/18/how-much-money-does-candy-crush-make/ http://bgr.com/2014/02/18/how-much-money-does-candy-crush-ma... [1] http://www.gamespot.com/articles/93-million-people-play-candy-crush-saga-daily-do-you/1100-6417819/ http://www.gamespot.com/articles/93-million-people-play-cand...
- minimaxir 11y agoHuh, I thought CCS revenue was an order of magnitude lower. My mistake. In that case, the numbers make more sense.
- csmajorfive 11y agoSpending a lot on user acquisition does not mean your unit economics are bad. And your assertion about Facebook and Twitter is wrong.
- aetherson 11y agoAre you suggesting that CCS and GoW have negative unit profit? That seems surprising to me. They probably have somewhat slim profit margins per user, but that's because they have a large market and great scalability. I don't think the original essay means "hey, your gross unit margin is only 10%, but your market size is 500,000 units at $5 per month." I think it means, "Hey, your gross unit margin is -20% and with a lot of luck you might increase it to -5%."
- cortesoft 11y agoI remember this from the very early days of Facebook apps. I worked for a company in 2007 that made one, and we bought users by advertising with other facebook apps. The problem was this was the ONLY revenue model for facebook apps; getting other facebook apps to advertise with you. There was no actual external revenue source.