9 ms·
The New Bond Market: Bigger, Riskier and More Fragile Than Ever
- danharaj 11y agoIt seems financialization is coming to its peak. What new tricks will capitalism come up with to continue 'growing' at an exponential rate?
- pkaye 11y agoThey are not 'tricks'... they are financial 'innovations.'
- cryoshon 11y agoPretty funny how those innovations don't actually add any value. Pretty funny how we funnel our society's money directly to/through these places.
- hueving 11y ago>Pretty funny how those innovations don't actually add any value. They made buying houses a possibility without a huge mountain of cash.
- Nicholas_C 11y agoDo you own a house, car, or anything else with a note on it? Do you work for a company or government entity that has to finance projects? The value,loans, bonds, and other debt instruments add is absolutely massive.
- jazzyk 11y agoYou are talking about credit - financing infrastructure, tooling, other investments. Yes, the value is definitely there. The problem is, most of the recent "innovations" do not add any value to the economy. What value did Credit Default Swaps (CDS) ever bring to the economy? How does high-frequency trading (HFT) benefit the society?
- nemo44x 11y agoYou're right in that some instruments don't really add value. They're a bet. Credit default swaps for mortgages didn't even exist really until some smart speculators noticed that the bond market for mortgages was unstable (and full of deceit) and only needed a bit of default to create a cascading waterfall of default which nearly took down the entire financial system. Honestly, CDR's were a good idea but it made no sense for the same banks to sell them that were also baking the mortgages. It would be like selling insurance on your own car. If you crash you are out a car and have to pay someone else! It would have made sense for banks to hedge their mortgages by buying CDR's from other investors. But then, that would have affected their bottom lines and they just plain got greedy. HFT is debatable as many claim it creates liquidity. I'm not sure I buy that but I also wouldn't confuse HFT with financial instruments. For instance, packaging mortgages into rated bonds of various risk tranches in the 1970's was a brilliant innovation which enable more people to qualify for loans as their risk was distributed and sliced up among many parties. Of course, that system broke down after being abused - but the initial concept still survives and is remarkable. Other instruments like derivatives allow for affordable hedges, the ability to buy and sell at a future price you want or collect premium on that offer. They aren't just for speculators.
- tosseraccount 11y agoDoesn't all growth have an exponent?
- jdmichal 11y agoYour comment was meant to be witty, but is actually just uninformed. Exponential growth is a well-defined mathematical concept [0] and distinct from other formulas of growth. And, to specifically address your comment, the exponent in exponential growth is time, so no you cannot just dismiss it as being "some exponent". [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exponential_growth#Basic_formula https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exponential_growth#Basic_formu...
- tosseraccount 11y agoPhysics is not financial economics.
- jdmichal 11y agoI truly do not understand your argument. First, nothing in my comment alludes to physics, except for maybe the involvement of time, which I can assure you is very much a concept in financial economics. Second, financial economics is in no way unfamiliar with exponential growth. For instance, the compounding interest formula: p-next = p-start * (1 - rate) ^ time
- tosseraccount 11y agoI'm not sure I get yours. Are you saying there is "nonexponential growth" ?
- jdmichal 11y agoOf course there is non-exponential growth. Easiest counter-example is linear growth, or perhaps in the real world a steady paycheck: p-next = p-start + growth-amount * t
- nugget 11y agoSome people don't seem to understand that there is a ceiling on macro economic debt financing as a driver of economic growth. Once someone or some company has pulled forward all their future consumption and earnings with zirp-level interest bond issuances, credit cards and mortgage notes, there's not much more they (or the economy) can do.
- dovereconomics 11y agoYou're confounding Capitalism with pure Keynesianism, which you'd probably revere.
- danharaj 11y agoNot at all. Also, Keynesian economics and Capitalism do not belong to the same category. How could I confound them? That would be very silly of me.
- dovereconomics 11y agoGenuine capitalism doesn't have a government controlling money supply, which is behind your 'exponential growth'. Instead of growing an economy, the truest capitalist is focused on freeing an economy If you wanna name the socialistic Keynesian experience 'Capitalism', that's your call. I can't do it.
- danharaj 11y agoYou don't use words the same way everyone else does. The most charitable thing I could say is that your take on Keynesian economic policy and 'genuine capitalism' is heterodox and stems from a non-mainstream ideology. There is no serious economist who would call Keynes a socialist, or socialistic, whatever that means, and the definition of capitalism does not proscribe government control of the money supply.
- chiaro 11y agoCapitalism is just a system where the owners of capital are the marginal claimants of revenues. Everything beyond that is ideology.
- chollida1 11y agoThis is all you need to take away from the article... > Bond mutual and exchange-traded funds now own 17% of all corporate bonds, up from 9% in 2008, according to the ICI. In periods of market stress, more-concentrated mutual-fund ownership tends to mean larger price drops, the IMF said last year. It used to be the case that stocks, bonds and other commodities like gold has inverse correlations. Or in other terms, when stocks were down, bonds and gold were up.... This lead to the Efficient Frontier from Markowitz where you would choose a risk level you were comfortable with and then build a portfolio of "uncorrelated assets" to get you optimum return for your risk level. http://www.investopedia.com/terms/e/efficientfrontier.asp http://www.investopedia.com/terms/e/efficientfrontier.asp The issue now a days is that this no longer makes much sense as when things go wrong everything is correlated almost to a degree of 1. Or in other terms, when the shit hits the fan, everything (Gold, stocks and bonds) all go down together. TL/DR the old advice about investing in both bonds, stocks and gold for diversivication of risk is at best much less pronounced than it used to be and at worst just bad advice as they are now positively correlated.
- tinkerrr 11y ago> It used to be the case that stocks, bonds and other commodities like gold has inverse correlations Where are you getting this information, on which the whole comment is based? It has always been very volatile and stocks and bonds have almost never been "uncorrelated assets". They change sign very frequently. Here's a research report from PIMCO [1] that shows the change in sign of the correlation to be 29 times in the past 90-odd years. https://media.pimco.com/Documents/PIMCO_Quantitative_Research_Stock_Bond_Correlation_Oct2013.pdf https://media.pimco.com/Documents/PIMCO_Quantitative_Researc...
- toomuchtodo 11y agoI found several resources online confirming OPs statement when I googled "stocks bonds inverse correlation". Also, while only anecdotal, my father had told me that rule as well, and he spent about a decade in the pit trading commodities on the CME in Chicago (hogs, corn, soy, with some t-bills for good measure).
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- JackFr 11y ago> Bond mutual and exchange-traded funds now own 17% of all corporate bonds, up from 9% in 2008, according to the ICI. Purely an unintended consequence of the Volcker Rule. Banks were penalized for holding corporate bonds, and needed to sell them somewhere.
- kokey 11y agoare people worried about bond market liquidity?
- vegabook 11y agoyes. The constant threat of a big dominating presence of the authorities in the market, causes two-way flows to decline. You cannot rely on your macro skill set anymore to analyze the market direction, as anything you do is subject to policy maker event risk. Therefore faster money (read, speculators), who are the major providers of liquidity, stay away. It doesn't help that banks' risk taking, historically a big source of liquidity too, has been curtailed by regulation, but that is not the only story. It's also about the drunken elephant stomping all over the market known as QE/zero rates policy. So paradoxically, as the stock of bonds is ballooning, the liquidity is shrinking. It was always the fact of course that the front end of the yield curve had policy event risk in it, but then you also had the shape of the curve which the market could use to intimidate the policy maker (too steep = a signal that the market was unhappy with policy). Today, the Feds have decided not only to guide the short end, but also to put the rest of the curve where they want it, and that's the underlying source of the problem. Basically, the market is rigged. Nobody likes to bet in a rigged market.
- bradfa 11y agoWhy isn't the fact that lots of baby boomers are getting older and retiring or getting close to retiring any part of this story? If bonds are the safer choice for retirement investments (compared to stocks, while cash makes no interest/dividends or gains in value, these are the only 3 choices), then clearly lots of older people who are retiring are going to be buying into bond funds. Hence, huge upswing in bonds held by ETFs and mutual funds, since that's mostly what working-class people have access to through their employers or in their other reduced tax retirement accounts.
- fitzwatermellow 11y ago"Let's keep this really simple. Since the financial crisis, how much more dollar-denominated debt is out there in the world." That was Rick Santelli on CNBC an hour ago. Here's the video: http://video.cnbc.com/gallery/?video=3000422916 http://video.cnbc.com/gallery/?video=3000422916 As the global economy slows, borrowers will cease to earn enough to service their debts. And the amounts are astronomical: $57T new debt at 17% debt-to-GDP ratios. Link to McKinsey GI report on "Debt and (not much) deleveraging": http://www.mckinsey.com/insights/economic_studies/debt_and_not_much_deleveraging http://www.mckinsey.com/insights/economic_studies/debt_and_n...
- mapgrep 11y ago> In the U.S., household, corporate and government debt amounted to 239% of gross domestic product in 2014, the Bank for International Settlements estimates, compared with 218% in 2007. I am not an economist, but it seems to me that if you're going to write an article suggesting that the bond market is "intimidating," "vulnerable as never before," and "increasingly subject to volatility," you would not want to conflate personal credit card debt, junk bonds, and other private debt instruments with what is widely considered the single safest investment in the world, a bulwark of stability in the wake of the economic crisis of 2008 — U.S. Treasury bonds. Given the spike (now receding) in the U.S. budget deficit since 2000, it seems likely a big portion of this supposedly alarming bond growth is in Treasuries, no?
- jazzyk 11y agoThe only "bulwark of stability" is cold, hard cash. The US government may not default, but that does not mean you will not lose money. If you bought US bonds at a high price/low yield (like right now :-)) chances are you won;t be able to sell before maturity because the price will go down, and if you hold them to maturity, the inflation will eat the measly return US bonds offer right now.
- jgalt212 11y ago> Bond mutual and exchange-traded funds now own 17% of all corporate bonds, up from 9% in 2008, according to the ICI. In periods of market stress, more-concentrated mutual-fund ownership tends to mean larger price drops, the IMF said last year. This is way better than 17% of all corp bonds being controlled by hedge funds. Being levered money, HF selling would be way more disruptive to the marketplace than mutual fund selling.