6 ms·
Free parking isn’t free: Parking mandates hurt America’s cities (2013)
- x5n1 11y agoThis is soon to be a non-issue thanks to automated cars. I hate parking companies like Impark, and I can't wait until 10 years passes to see them die a quick death when their services are no longer needed. It will free up a lot of space that I guess will be turned into more commercial buildings.
- dalke 11y agoAt 4am, when most people are sleeping and few need a car, what do all of the unused cars do? Won't they park somewhere, and if so, who do you think will run the parking facility?
- seanmcdirmid 11y agoThey can go a long way to park (industrial districts). They can also park more efficiently (by lining up). The taxis in Beijing have their little hang outs where they park at 4am in the morning. Parking is notoriously hard in our city, but at 4am, the roads are deserted and they spill into a few second lanes without the police caring (and they are all gone by 6 as peak time is starting). Not a problem compared to the wild parking habits of private personal cars.
- dalke 11y agoCertainly. That lowers the cost. It doesn't drive the cost to zero. Someone owns the land. Someone maintains the road surface. If there are 1 million self-driving cars on the road, then that's what, >6 million square meters of space? If the cars are parked in a few secondary lanes, then the city is subsidizing the parking. Otherwise there will be some sort of commercial parking facility.
- x5n1 11y agoNext to zero then. You definitely don't need parking companies. Most likely the owners of those vehicles, the commercial companies, would have their own lots for parking in places where it was the cheapest. But third party parking companies with parking lots charging exuberant fees would definitely be a thing of the past. What does a 5x10 piece of land cost of rent for a month at the edge of the city. Next to nothing.
- dalke 11y agoFor this to work, I think you are predicting there will only be a handful of large commercial companies in this autonomous future. Otherwise I don't think the economics works out. In any case, if I go on the Great American Road Trip, I am going to have a single vehicle the whole time, yes? (Assume I rented it for a month, and that it's fully autonomous in a city.) I don't want to load and unload all of the luggage, including the tent and stove, when I visit a city. So where do I park it? If I rented it in Florida, and park it in L.A., does the car owning company in Florida own parking spots in L.A.? Or does it have a parking agreement with the parking facility in L.A.? Or do I contract directly with a third party parking company? My guess is there will still be third party parking services. With the option of renting a space that's cheap but 15 miles away (adding $5 in fuel and a 25 minute latency) or a local place that's more expensive, but where I can easily fetch the suitcase I forgot in the car.
- seanmcdirmid 11y agoTake the taxi model, eliminate the driver, and there it is. There are plenty of cities in the world where taxis are more ubiquitous and owning personal cars are very expensive (parking being a big expense, but also winning the license plate lottery). American centrism doesn't really explain it. So you normally don't take a taxi out of the city, and it is such a niche activity that I'd assume that it would be a different kind of speciality business with much higher costs that allow it to solve these problems. E.g. Private parking lots like those today.
- cwilkes 11y ago
- tzs 11y agoLet's assume we do automated cars right, so that the cars have a wireless connection to some central traffic planning system that coordinates traffic for an entire city. As traffic dies down in the evening and overnight, fewer lanes are needed. Some lanes could be deallocated from traffic use and allocated to parking use to hold cars overnight, and then put back to traffic use in the morning.
- dalke 11y ago"some central traffic planning system that coordinates traffic for an entire city" That would be impressive uptime for both power and wireless connections. I was under the impression that autonomous vehicles would be more autonomous than that. Else what happens should something like http://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2014/07/01/chicago-storm-flooding-power-outage/11884545/ http://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2014/07/01/chicago... occur? In any case, we're starting from the position that there are commercial parking services. For your proposal to work, as a way to get rid of "companies like Impark" we have to assume that either that 1) street parking as you suggest will be free, ie, subsidized by the tax base as a whole, or 2) the city does not contract/sell operation of the central traffic planning system to companies like Impark. Chicago (to mention it again), leased out its meters to a foreign corporation for 75 years.
- Retric 11y agoIf the cars can read signs then all it takes is a sign that says parking lane 2am - 5am.
- dalke 11y agoWhich is my option (1), free parking subsidized by the city. If we wanted that now, we could nationalize all of the commercial parking systems. We instead often see the desire to find more revenue sources. BTW, it won't be as simple as having a sign. Some areas already are free parking between given times, except during a declared snow emergency, or during hurricane evacuation. I'm not saying it can't be solved, only that it's not simple.
- 11y ago
- jstanley 11y agoI think the problem with building houses with nowhere to park is that people will just park on the street. The purpose of the law is probably to prevent the streets from being overrun with parked cars.
- simoncion 11y agoOnly people who can afford endless impound fees will "just park in the street". Realistically, if there is literally nowhere to park your car, you either get rid of it, or you live somewhere else. SF could do with much better public transit and many, many fewer parking spaces that aren't in a multi-story garage.
- michaelt 11y agoOnly people who can afford endless impound fees will "just park in the street". It depends if all the other parking in the area is restricted - the jargon I've heard is "displaced parking" and I've seen it in action. When a university near me raised parking prices, any road or grass verge or dropping-off point on campus that wasn't marked 'no parking' got cars on it. When those were marked 'no parking', they started parking in the customer parking of nearby shops. When the shops restricted parking to two hours, people started parking on residential streets further out. So the residential streets needed a residents permit scheme. Now, if parking is already extremely heavily regulated you might already have the street parking and customer parking and residents parking restrictions (and admin and enforcement for them) in place. But it's my experience that restricting the supply of parking spaces isn't always a simple matter.
- IkmoIkmo 11y agoObviously these things take time to carry through. When you half the parking space, you don't suddenly half the amount of cars. Over time people frustrated with the parking, the fines for parking in wrongful areas and the walking distances when parking further from home, will sell their car, and over time fewer people who didn't have a car yet will buy one than they otherwise would in a world of ubiquitous parking. Gradually this reduces the amount of cars and displaced parking. If you build new housing without parking for new inhabitants, you don't have that inherent excess of cars per parking spot. You might have some excess still but not nearly as much. The biggest solution though is to offer alternative transport, first, and then removing, reducing or making more expensive the parking infrastructure. Here in Amsterdam the city has been removing parking and hiking up parking fees quite rapidly. But it was after establishing ubiquitous, separated, safe cycle paths everywhere, a decent tram, bus system and metro, 8 train stations (in a city of just 1 million) and another relatively high-speed underground light rail project in the works today, as well as public-transport's rentable bicycles and mini electric cars (which, due to sharing, is getting iirc about ~20 users for the space of one traditional parking spot). In Amsterdam I've never owned a personal car and won't ever need to. But having lived in America, I can't imagine that to work.
- fennecfoxen 11y agoHmm. Pretty sure I read about this from the libertarians in Reason at least a decade ago. Amusing to see a few people catching up. :P While we're at it, here's some other fun transportation/planning policy articles from that group that might be relevant to the HN demographic: Why New Urbanism Doesn't Work: https://reason.com/archives/2013/06/07/why-new-urbanism-doesnt-work https://reason.com/archives/2013/06/07/why-new-urbanism-does... - "Urban elitists don’t recognize that their policies helped create the “sprawl” that they disdain. It’s not as if middle-income San Jose workers would choose to live over the mountain ranges in places such as Tracy" Self-driving cars could destroy fine-based city government! https://reason.com/blog/2015/07/15/self-driving-cars-could-destroy-fine-bas https://reason.com/blog/2015/07/15/self-driving-cars-could-d... - "What's the downside? Increasing automation limits the ability of authorities to profit off human error."
- robotdongs 11y agoThe New urbanism article was pretty bad.. The author made some OK points, but the only example he provides is the San Francisco which you can really only compare with a city like New York, London, Hong Kong. I thought it was funny the idea that New Urbanists are this big powerful entity pushing all these regulations and codes in place, as if building developers and their investors don't have any sort of input. Also he fails to provide any sort of evidence these new codes and regulations pushed by new urbanists are responsible for sprawl. Especially when most of the suburbs mentioned in the article are much older than new urbanist policies.
- JesperRavn 11y agoLibertarians don't have a monopoly on free market thinking. Most mainstream (non-libertarian) economists would have said the same 50 years ago.
- dllthomas 11y ago"Libertarians don't have a monopoly on free market thinking." Right, otherwise they'd underproduce...
- dalke 11y ago
- Tiquor 11y agoSeems to me like a false flag by someone claiming a libertarianianish ideal when the real goal is to make cars more difficult to own.
- jacobolus 11y agoWhat? Matthew Yglesias is not “libertarianish” by any stretch of the imagination, and does not claim anything of the sort. He states outright that the goal is to reduce the extremely expensive (in land, money, etc.) parking subsidy that we currently provide to cars, which obviously makes cars more difficult to own.
- Natsu 11y agoI wonder what their response will be when low income people are the hardest hit by the lack of well-developed public transport? "Sucks to be you?" is what it's sounding like, but I hope that's wrong.
- jacobolus 11y agoYglesias argues for guaranteed basic income, http://www.slate.com/blogs/moneybox/2013/02/17/guaranteed_basic_income_the_real_alternative_to_the_minimum_wage.html http://www.slate.com/blogs/moneybox/2013/02/17/guaranteed_ba... But he also argues for increased spending on public transit, universal healthcare, more worker-friendly labor laws, and so on.
- wmt 11y agoWhen you can't counter an argument, attack the motives!
- smaudet 11y agoReading through the articles/comments: 1) You can't just 'change parking'. There are already too many variables involved. Articles such as the above are all well and good, but they're pie in the sky, up there with personal space vehicles. Implementing something like this at the national level is...going to be more than complicated (think, just as bad or worse than healthcare), controversial, and probably not worth it (inefficient and we we trying to get away from centralization anyways). 2) There are some technological solutions...but they are just as difficult, if not more so, than the legal solutions. So my conclusion is that, for some sort of reform to work, there must be a general 'framework' that is invented, with general solutions, general planned costs, and then this framework must be publicized. That way a larger number of local governments can use these guidelines as a blueprint for reforming/updating their parking regulations. I'm not saying this would be easy either, but it sounds more attainable than any of the alternatives. I think it would also tackle the problem more efficiently - no painful major overhauls, no expensive long planning/implementation processes, just what people actually want. And can do, given already limited time/money budgets.