9 ms·
Two things: I went back to my original employer and said I had a new job offer for $70k, and I didn't want to negotiate, I just wanted their final, last ditch
by joezydeco 11y ago
Two things:
I went back to my original employer and said I had a new job offer for $70k, and I didn't want to negotiate, I just wanted their final, last ditch offer
That's an incredibly awesome way to have a huge target painted on your back. A lot of employers get really pissed at this tactic but won't say so to your face. They will gladly give you that new salary for just enough time to get a (cheaper) replacement on board. Then your salary is changed to $0.00.
I found a solid startup, _one_I_would_actually_work_at_, and tell them I make $100k (a lie, I added $20k to my current salary).
Welcome to the 2010s, where credit bureaus now run additional services for employers and HR departments. My company regularly uses The Work Number from Equifax. I pulled up my report and it has my salary history for the last 20 years on it. Perhaps working for small startups that can't afford this service will let you fly under the radar when it comes to bluffing about salary history (and don't get me wrong, I'm all for not letting your next employer know what you were making before), but you gotta tread lightly here.
https://www.theworknumber.com/ https://www.theworknumber.com/
My opinion is that one should tell the new employer what it would take to make you jump, and that's it. If they can't make that number then you have your answer. That, or they need to make up the delta in other ways.
- klenwell 11y agoWelcome to the 2010s, where credit unions now run additional services for employers and HR departments. My company regularly uses The Work Number from Experian. Interesting. I've always suspected something like this existed and have argued with people against lying about salary history on the assumption that it does. This is the first confirmation I've seen. Thanks!
- srtjstjsj 11y agoI guarantee you that The Work Number does not include the value of bonuses, perks, benefits, and appropriate equity valuation. TWN includes base -- which is what banks care about.
- AnimalMuppet 11y agoBut, in this case, he wasn't lying about his salary history. He was inflating (lying about) a competing offer (that he had no intention of taking). That's a lot harder to disprove...
- joezydeco 11y ago...a lie, I added $20k to my current salary It's right in the text.
- AnimalMuppet 11y agoAh, sorry. For some reason I thought you were talking about his initial job offer. My error.
- andrewstuart2 11y agoI've gotten the same advice from multiple sources. You don't have to lie to say what salary you're looking for. You also don't have to give your current salary. In the information age, you better be extra careful about bluffing because it's easier every day to call those bluffs.
- Lawtonfogle 11y agoOr just calculate your total compensation and give that (be sure to call it compensation and not salary).
- hollerith 11y agoThanks for the information, but Experian is a credit bureau or credit reporting company. A credit union is something else, more like a saving-and-loan association.
- joezydeco 11y agoD'oh, you're right. My mistake. Fixed. I also attributed The Work Number to Experian, but it's owned by Equifax.
- inglor 11y agoIt's worth mentioning that in some parts of the world (for example Israel) people don't have credit scores and you can't pay a service to find out what their income is. Of course, lying is still mostly unnecessary, especially if you interview a lot and actually do have offers to back up your claims. Personally I think the hit your reputation would take from lying just isn't worth it.
- joezydeco 11y agoTrue, and let's quantify this a bit more. It's a lot easier to be upfront honest and give a take-it-or-leave-it number when you're currently employed and can afford to pass up the offer and move to the next company. A lot of people are not in this position. Negotiation certainly becomes critical. A little bit of homework and diplomatic work can bump your salary by thousands or tens of thousands with a few hours of work. This is impossible to do once you start your employment.
- burnallofit 11y agoI tried to look myself up, and indeed they don't have my current employer (a small startup). My guess is that only larger employers participate. More importantly, this raises significant privacy issues. How can a current or former employer make sensitive data like salary information easily and publicly accessible, without permission? That ought to be illegal. I agree that it's really wrong to lie about one's salary; the best answer is to not disclose that, and probably to point to available information like glassdoor, or just be honest about your expectations.
- joezydeco 11y agoMy take (as it was explained to me by HR) is that currently it's used as a way to let decisionmakers (landlords, bank loan officers, court systems, etc) get verification of employment and/or salary via mutual agreement. You, as the wage-earner, grant an access key to a landlord for example. He then can get quick verification of your application information without wasting HR's time. But I trust the credit bureaus as far as I can throw them. This will certainly morph into other uses for the data, like this: Hiring Company: "Did Joe Pastebin earn $100,000 last year?" Equifax: "Nope." And out goes the bong letter.
- SilasX 11y agoThen why do they require copious documentation of your wages (sorry, salaries) when you apply for a mortgage if they can just look it up?
- srtjstjsj 11y agoMy mortgage lender asked me for my access code to Work Number. What shocks me is that Work Number is legally allowed to publish data without the individual's authorization
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- 11y ago
- blazespin 11y agoWrong! There was no cheaper option and this engineer/negotiator knew it. (70k? Seriously? Even in 2010...) Everything he said was dead on and I recommend everyone to follow his lead. Admittedly, you should have a firm grasp of the market, and the way he got it by aggressively pursuing alternative offers is absolutely the right way to do it. Also, he was dead on when he said you should always have an alternative that you'd seriously go to. Asking for a raise without serious alternative in hand is dumb dumb dumb. That all being said, ideally you'd work for a company that didn't force you to do these sorts of shenanigans. Such companies are more rare than they should be.
- ashwinaj 11y ago> That's an incredibly awesome way to have a huge target painted on your back. A lot of employers get really pissed at this tactic but won't say so to your face. They will gladly give you that new salary for just enough time to get a (cheaper) replacement on board. Then your salary is changed to $0.00. I believe the op was in the NE where there are limited choices for employers when it comes to hiring (unlike in SV, they're dime a dozen).
- MCRed 11y agoDon't give a company you're interviewing with your social security number. You only have to give it up if you accept their offer and become an employee. Generally this happens on the first day of work or when doing the on boarding paperwork...not during the interview process. Also, I find it amusing the tacit assumption that its somehow moral for companies to look up salary histories via credit reports but that interviewees don't have a right to know the salaries the company has given to other employees. The information asymmetry is part of the reason that this guy lied-- and to be honest, in 25+ years, I've never had a salary negotiation where the company didn't lie to me "oh, we can't afford that!" (when in reality they are just trying to lowball by pretending they don't have the money. It's a lie no worse than his.)
- joezydeco 11y agoCompanies that pull credit reports on candidates are a completely different form of scum, and they should be called out more often for this. Yes, there are exceptions where credit difficulties could indicate an unstable employment situation (like having a security clearance or working in finance), but otherwise your personal finances should be completely independent of your employment.
- draw_down 11y agoOh, there are so many ways around something like that. Say your total compensation was that plus equity/bonus, etc. Plus you could just flat-out claim the thing is wrong. Still though, I agree that lying is a dangerous strategy and can backfire.
- nissimk 11y agoThere's a wide range of oppinions regarding the counter offer. It's interesting to read some of them if you search on google. One thing many people are not aware of is that as part of your counter offer acceptance you can demand a mandatory severance agreement. This is a contract that says that the company has to pay you if they lay you off shortly after making the counter offer. It's worth asking for, especially if you're concerned about having a huge target painted on your back.
- s73v3r 11y ago"Then your salary is changed to $0.00." No, then you use your savings, which should be higher because you were paid more, and you go get another job, which should offer a higher starting salary because most starting salaries are based off of what you were making previously.
- revelation 11y agoSo employers now share salaries between each other in an effort to depress wages while telling workers they can't possibly discuss their compensation with coworkers? The american worker is hilarious. Gotta keep fighting those unions!
- StillBored 11y agoOr they just fax your current company as part of a credit check, requesting salary. I had that happen, during the process a few years ago at a place I decided to stay at after they made a counter offer (that I didn't request). A couple days after I told them I would stay, I got a call from HR asking me what I thought they should do with the fax asking for my current salary (AKA if it was a legitimate request for a lone approval or something).