8 ms·
Ahmed Mohamed will not face charges related to device [pdf]
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- mikeash 11y agoIt's amazing how these assholes are incapable of admitting that they're wrong. "Attached is a picture of the device that shows it was suspicious in nature." I bet they don't even realize they just sound like idiots.
- yid 11y ago> I bet they don't even realize they just sound like idiots. I think we're past that. We're in cover-your-ass territory at the moment.
- rajbot 11y agoThey knew it was not a bomb. They were bullying him. If the school or police had actually thought it was dangerous they would have: 1. Evacuated the school 2. Called the bomb squad
- bentruyman 11y agoTheir justification is in the linked PDF: "Under Texas law, a person is guilty of possessing a hoax bomb if he possesses a device that is intended to cause anyone to be alarmed or a reaction of any type by law enforcement officers."
- escherize 11y agoThis is another way that governments (those with the monopoly of the use of force) expand their reach. By putting the precipice of wrongdoing not on what happened but on the reaction of state agents, it becomes extremely difficult to call out bullies like this.
- bentruyman 11y agoI read that line as more along the lines of yelling "fire" in a movie theater. Clearly there was no intent of causing hysteria with Ahmed's suitcase clock, which I assume is why he was freed. But, clearly, this shouldn't have gone as far as it did.
- tgflynn 11y agoBut there was zero evidence of any such intent in this case.
- bigiain 11y agoSo I found a five year old photo of mine on Flickr - I'm glad I wasn't a muslim schoolkid in Texas when I wrote that second paragraph in the Flickr description: https://www.flickr.com/photos/bigiain/5162711688/ https://www.flickr.com/photos/bigiain/5162711688/ (Also now waiting for the first reports of a muslim being convicted of a "bomb hoax" for carrying a pepper grinder, on the grounds that it "cause a sneeze reaction in a law enforcement officer"...)
- bentruyman 11y agoI'm not entirely sure what your photo has to do with anything.
- bigiain 11y agoIt's a home built clock. I think in Texas that'd make me suspicious - and I think that's _insane_.
- bentruyman 11y agoBut you even said if you had put it in a suitcase it would look like a bomb...
- fnordfnordfnord 11y agoI think the point here is or ought to be that there are a lot of things that are completely normal that might be mistaken for a bomb by the ignorant or the uneducated. And no, that's not an excuse for the Irving ISD or Irving PD peoples' actions either since we expect them to be neither ignorant nor uneducated.
- bentruyman 11y ago@fnordfnordfnord To my knowledge, no one has asserted this was ever a bomb. This is all about the zero-tolerance policy public schools appear to be applying to situations like this and others (see: gun shaped pop-tart). Hopefully situations like this give reason to begin discussions about rethinking the way we treat children in an environment where this kind of activity should be encouraged, not punished.
- Retra 11y agoIt was not intended to even be seen by police, let alone alarm them or cause a reaction.
- jeeva 11y agoProbably not the first time this joke will be made, but... "I'm impressed - I didn't realise Ahmed had built a clock with a functional alarm."
- osazuwa 11y agoI bet if you broke it down 80% of police activity would be saving face and putting on airs
- twerkmonsta 11y ago"The Irving Police Department has always experienced an outstanding relationship with the Muslim community." Wait, if this was an objective reaction having only to do with the nature of the device, then why is the student's religion even mentioned?
- dangoor 11y agoI don't fault them for this, though I have no idea if it's true. This was stated because of the huge media firestorm and the belief that this wouldn't have happened to a Bob Jones. Had this happened to a Bob Jones, there would not have been people saying that this only happened because he was Christian, and the sentence above would not have been in the PD statement.
- plonh 11y agoNote: it is not true. Irving government is one of the racist groups pushing "anti-Sharia" laws.
- MarkPNeyer 11y agohttps://i.imgur.com/Z1WbwdB.jpg https://i.imgur.com/Z1WbwdB.jpg it looks like maybe they suspected he wanted it to look like a bomb. it does kind of look like a bomb. of course the cops totally overrreacted. he's either a brilliant troll (the NASA shirt is perfect), or a nerdy kid with little social awareness. either way, bravo.
- tgflynn 11y agoThe defining property of a bomb is that it contains an explosive. I don't see anything in this picture that suggests the presence of an explosive.
- MarkPNeyer 11y agoi don't think the cops suspected it was a bomb. i think the cops figured, he made it to look like a bomb and was trying to use it for a bomb threat. i think they overracted and probably violated the law by questioning him without his lawyer present - they should go to jail. it's understandable why they did what they did, but they should be punished.
- TheCoelacanth 11y agoWhat kind of bomb gets plugged into an outlet?
- lfuller 11y ago"The student only would say it was a clock and was not forthcoming at that time about any other details." What did they expect him to say? It WAS only a clock. There were no other details regarding its nature or use.
- rhizome 11y agoNote how they impugn his character, implying he was and is less than candid. He couldn't win: either he implicates himself, justifying their actions, or they call him a liar, excusing their idiocy.
- jessaustin 11y agoPolice are great believers in the value of lawyerless interrogation. Therefore, they take every chance they get to attempt to convince the public of the wisdom of talking to cops.
- vubuntu 11y agoThe small metallic type suitcase/box may have been a perfect container 1) To cram in all the ugly looking wires inside while the outer appearance of the product looks polished 2) Nice platform to tether the circuit boards etc to keep them in place 3) Doubles up as a carry box to move around his project and display/show to friends , teachers etc On the flip side 1) There is subtle difference between timers vs clocks 2) Doesn't look anything like a traditional clock, but more like a James Bondish suitcase/gadget, especially if I just saw the picture of the device alone with no other context given to me. Having said that, , I am in no way defending the action of police or the school. What is needed was context, ability to do minimum analysis and common sense. And the teachers, school administration, police had plenty of that. It could have been a simple matter of explaining to the kid , while his zeal is appreciated, to notify his teachers in advance in future, to make sure his projects don't disturb the class, and to encourage more such robotic/electronic projects for science fairs etc (appropriate time and place for everything) Also unfortunately, due to the current security song and dance every where, kids (and adults too) have to be taught about being sensitive to fear and perceptions of others timing/location/context . Even kids may have to be explained to be sensitive to such things. May be all or some involved may be bigoted towards the muslim community as the media or comments suggest and that may have played a role in the escalation. And may be some(or all) weren't. But generally concerned about past incidents related to school environments and violence in schools (Shootings etc). Some of these were perpetrated by fellow students, which can't be discounted in playing into the fears of those involved in this incident. We can't say for sure , religion/color was the sole motivation. Some past violent incidents were perpetrated by white kids/persons. So if it were a white kid in this situation, can we absolutely discount 100% that similar amount of concern might have not been triggered in the class teacher's mind, or the administration or police. The point is, reasonable benefit of doubt can be given to the teacher, admin, police for going into a heightened/alert mode. But what cannot be justified is the failure in subsequent analysis and diffusion of the tension at every level. The teacher could have clarified the intention, and diffused the tension and not escalated it after establishing facts (and the awareness of the enthusiasm and character of a kid of their own class that they should be familiar with). Or the next level, school security/admin could have diffused and de-escalated the situation. Or the police could have done that. But, no, escalation seems to be a one way process for authority/admin/police these days. What happened to 'peace keeping' part of their job ?
- Cshelton 11y agoLast Insaw about an hour ago, he is still suspended through Thursday (tomorrow). Is this still true? I don't understand why if the charges were dropped...
- dalke 11y agoThe school system and the court system are two different systems. It's possible to be suspended without being arrested. It's possible to be arrested without being suspended.
- JoshTriplett 11y agoAnd if you think court systems have trouble admitting wrongdoing, they're nothing compared to school systems.
- obilgic 11y agoHonestly, I'm not worried for Ahmed at all, in 15 years he will be in much better shape compared to 99% of the population. I'm just concerned about all the other kids given those teacher and school admins.
- blizkreeg 11y agoYou're wrong, I'm sorry to say. The other kids will be just fine. He will be the one who will remember this and it could affect his life in ways that we can't say yet.
- DarkTree 11y agoI don't think the parent was commenting on how the other students would be more affected by this incident, but will affected simply by attending a school with horrible administration. He, on the other hand, has been invited to places like Facebook by Zuckerberg himself because of this incident. Not the worst outcome.
- vfdfv 11y ago> invited to places like Facebook by Zuckerberg Ah so now Ahmed will get to see the worst of the worst on a different end of the spectrum.
- Turing_Machine 11y agoI suspect that Ahmed is going to have plenty of money for any necessary therapy. I certainly hope so, anyway.
- blizkreeg 11y agoI'm glad Ahmed got all the support and encouragement he did but not one person of note/power, including Obama and Hillary Clinton (who offered their cute tweets) have talked of punishing, penalizing, or in the very least reprimanding the officers and teachers who put him through this. How is that? It's criminal to handcuff and interrogate a 14-yr old in front of his entire class and school when they found nothing to implicate him. It's an unconscionable act. These people are not only stupid (look at that 'suspicious' device), they are abusing power with no repercussions. "The student was handcuffed for his safety and for the safety of the officers". Are they out of their mind?
- rhizome 11y ago"Officer safety" is statutory language that supports a whole host of discretionary powers, from handcuffing to shooting dead. It's criminal to handcuff and interrogate a 14-yr old in front of his entire class and school when they found nothing to implicate him. It maybe should be, but isn't. However, what is illegal is questioning him without his parents or a lawyer present, which he requested multiple times to no effect. http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2015/09/16/police-violated-ahmed-mohamed-s-civil-rights-by-keeping-away-his-parents.html http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2015/09/16/police-viol...
- blizkreeg 11y agoI meant criminal in a metaphorical sense. But shouldn't they be prosecuted for questioning him without parental consent or presence, at least?
- rhizome 11y agoBut shouldn't they be prosecuted for questioning him without parental consent or presence, at least? No, because Civil Rights violations are generally established through civil suits, not criminal. More specifically, 42 USC 1983 is civil, 18 USC 242 is criminal. There is a telltale loophole in the criminal statute, "willfully," that provides wiggle room for the violator to play dumb.
- 11y ago
- bane 11y agoI really really hope he wins a multi-million dollar lawsuit for wrongful arrest and turns it into a billion dollar company that makes precision timepieces.
- paulgayham 11y agoThen, much like the guy they freed from Guantanamo for his innocence, he'll be picked up recruiting for Al Qaeda
- moron4hire 11y agoI agree in a sense, but that doesn't come without a protracted legal battle that I kind of hope his parents will spare him of.
- patrickaljord 11y agoPoor kid has been humiliated and called a genius inventor on same day, imagine the pressure he'll get to live up to this expectation as a future engineer/scientist.
- scintill76 11y agoI feel bad about the pressure he's already under -- everyone wants him to show off his clock and/or himself. Judging by this [http://www.theverge.com/2015/9/16/9341309/ahmed-mohamed-school-transfer http://www.theverge.com/2015/9/16/9341309/ahmed-mohamed-scho...] I guess he's up to it though.
- InclinedPlane 11y agoThe real problem is that the system that bubbled up this exceptional and notable instance of idiocy has just been churning away day in, day out for years and decades and affects a tremendous number of people's lives. Schools that are just industrialized baby-sitting facilities where kids are subjected to so much useless busy work it's a wonder that any enthusiasm for knowledge remains. And school and legal systems which treat non-white kids as terrorists or gangsters until proven innocent. Zero-tolerance, zero-compassion, zero-humanity, zero-education. It's shocking that the system isn't even more broken than it is given how terrible so many of the components are.
- Beltiras 11y agoIt's a little ridiculous thinking that institutions supposedly founded to increase intelligence insist on being governed by rules demanding it's absence.
- tomlock 11y agoThis is so stupid. This is as much a bomb as a disassembled alarm clock is. Everyone involved should be fired, from the school through the police department. Words cannot describe how terrible this situation is.
- duskwuff 11y ago> This is as much a bomb as a disassembled alarm clock is. In large part because that is precisely what it is!
- markbnj 11y ago>> Attached is a picture of the device that shows it was suspicious in nature Please. Suspicious if you've never seen electronics outside of a case, perhaps.
- krapp 11y agoTo play devil's advocate, though, most people have probably never seen electronics out of a case. Although the police really have no excuse not to know what a bomb does and doesn't look like.
- codezero 11y agoThis should have included some introspection on the part of the school and/or police force involved. Instead they are digging in behind the narrative that their fear was reasonable and their reaction was justifiable, and that Ahmed somehow withheld information that would have changed their mind at some point. This is classic school faculty behavior: do it our way or else. He could have 'played ball' and explained in detail the project he worked on, but he didn't. He shouldn't have to either. They can expel him or send him home, but they went further, to teach him a lesson for being 'smart'. It's clear they didn't fear the device. As others have pointed out, the school wasn't evacuated. They knew it wasn't a bomb.
- plonh 11y agoHe did explain in detail. The only part he left out was the not true part about it being a real or fake bomb.
- mikelyons 11y agoWhy does that look so much like a bomb though?
- cdelsolar 11y agoHow does it look like a bomb?
- Killswitch 11y ago> there is no evidence to support the perception he intended to create alarm. Good to know he didn't make an alarm clock.
- JBlue42 11y agoGeneral question: How come we're able to see his photo plastered everywhere? I thought there were laws about identifying minors?
- vermontdevil 11y agoThe family released the photo not the school.
- roymurdock 11y agoI'm interested to see if this changes anything.
- tinalumfoil 11y agoWhat's really shitty about this isn't that the school or police overreacted at first. It isn't that this somehow affects Islamic-American relations or American-Muslim citizens. It isn't even that this may have discouraged Ahmed from future creativity. What's so concerning about this story is that if it wasn't picked up by the news, a defenseless 14-year-old would have a criminal record for bringing a personal project to school. Situations like this make me think of all the similar incidents that never got picked up by the news because some terrorist was shot or the stock market dipped and the story was no longer important enough to report.
- joezydeco 11y agoIt seems to me that Ahmed's story is turning out to be this perfect intersection of zero-tolerance, racism, technological illiteracy, and police overreaction. It's an entire decade of nonsense in a tidy little package.
- krauthammer 11y ago-It's an opposing orthodox religious family -It's in an ethnic christian holdout of the earth -The kid is above average, and the device looks like he's been dreaming of a suitcase nuke People should respect the patriarchy and the nations of the Earth. This family should live in the larger city in Texas, if anywhere. edit: You don't respect how the world and culture and sanity works or how many people are on it if you're opposed to this way of thinking.
- plonh 11y agoClocks are not banned in Christianity.
- krauthammer 11y agoThat's just crazy talk just like calling a bigot a crazy person. Once again the world has failed inspect the relationship two nations have with each other appropriately. There's nothing wrong with what Texas did by arresting this muslim. He could have been doing it all for his father and for the arab spring, especially considering the intelligence they are showing and the outcry from the liberal community. If you move to Saudi Arabia you have to stick to the bigger city if you have friction with them, and his family should have known to do that. That's the basics of life, and it will not change. Stop targeting Texas.
- ausjke 11y agoA ticking device that is not supposed to be brought to other classes(he was notified by his science teacher), and is closed up with some string so you can not see what's inside, and by a 14 year old Muslim student, and suddenly it starts to tick during a class. If I'm the teacher I will call the cops too. Yes I know I'm politically incorrect here, and will get down votes for this, but if I'm the teacher I will do the same, though I do agree the cops can be much nicer to handle this. On the other hand, I frequently found to speak your true thoughts here at HN, it _scares_ me to some extent, because different thoughts here will immediately be punished by down votes, such as the one above. Maybe it's time to close my HN account all together.
- plonh 11y agoHN does tend to have a bare minimum level of intellect and a maximum level of abject racisim for avoiding downvotes , higher than the free speech bar.
- Gigablah 11y agoLooks like you missed the point entirely. Taking precautions about the device is understandable, if a bit silly -- and if they had left it at that, this would be nothing more than a "not The Onion" story to laugh at. What happened after (the arrest and suspension) is outrageous.
- warrenb 11y agoChild Arrested Because Adults are Stupid: https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2015/09/child_arrested_.html https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2015/09/child_arreste...
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- krauthammer 11y agoIt's no different than a family of archers moving from Italy to France in the 1500s. Eventually when they have the upper hand, they'll take territory, just like we've seen throughout human history and like what just happened in eastern Ukraine. A kid from a family that smart should respect christians and whites enough to know to stay in a big city as an outsider.
- ryanlol 11y agoLooking at the photo of the device I certainly can't see how that looks even remotely like a bomb. Nothing resembling an explosive payload or a detonator in there.
- glimmung 11y ago"Attached is a picture of the device that shows it was suspicious in nature." Nope, it shows no such thing - I see bare electronics, that's all. I really do think that the idea that that is intrinsically "suspicious" needs to be challenged, or better yet ridiculed.
- plonh 11y agoOr best, educated.