5 ms·
Thousands can be wasted on dumb stuff like bad office-supply purchasing decisions. Those folks don't get fired. Sounds overblown - folks afraid of anything they
by JoeAltmaier 11y ago
Thousands can be wasted on dumb stuff like bad office-supply purchasing decisions. Those folks don't get fired. Sounds overblown - folks afraid of anything they don't understand.
- Alupis 11y agoWould you still consider it "overblown" if he had run, say... a bitcoin miner on all those machines? Sure, he didn't make profit from the seti@home instances, but he did it without approval, did ultimately cost the district money, and likely caused other issues along the way (like additional wear-n-tear on the machines)
- ohitsdom 11y agoI'd think administrators would have a very different approach to disciplining a "bad office-supply purchasing" decision versus a well-thought out choice to use school equipment & electricity for non-work related causes.
- tomswartz07 11y ago> electricity for non-work related causes I wish we could fire teachers for using their computers for Facebook and Amazon shopping during the day.
- blacksmith_tb 11y agoAnd should private sector employers fire their employees for using their computers to do the same? Obviously I don't want to see teachers goofing off on social media instead of teaching kids, but if they aren't actively teaching, why not? The idea that every second of your time on the job needs to be spent furiously working is an attitude from the industrial revolution - I would have thought these days we were more interested in results.
- lotharbot 11y agoin the school where I most recently taught, there was an explicit expectation that teachers could use district computers for personal business when on break. Being on facebook when they had kids in the room would be an entirely different matter. The internet was also heavily monitored, with a proxy server that required a login to get to forbidden sites. Our IT guy had a pretty good idea of when teachers were getting on facebook etc.
- ArkyBeagle 11y agoThis question is not intended at all to be snarky. Seriously. And then you'll hire them? Gets complicated fast, dunnit?
- blacksmith_tb 11y agoIf they have shown they can get the job done, why wouldn't I? (Other than not being in HR and all). Also, hard not to feel a little snark in the emphasis and "dunnit", really...
- ArkyBeagle 11y agoI would not have thought of that :) I just thought it was a contraction of "doesn't it". Perhaps they are like farmers we paid to not grow corn in the past. But that's just for the time-servers, not the dedicated professionals, who are probably the majority.
- pbhjpbhj 11y agoDo you want to be fired for using your computer for non-work activities?
- sixothree 11y agoHaving lived in the deep south most of my life I think I understand what's going on here. It's not that they're afraid of things they don't understand. It's that there is a certain type of person they generally don't like. In this case it might have been a man that had some sort of intellectual curiosity, maybe a bit eccentric. And they will use their ignorance as a weapon against those people. The police department knows full well they can determine whether this was a bomb or not. It's within their ability to interview every person he interacted with to find if he claimed it was a bomb at any point. Instead of doing that they will use their lack of knowledge to allow falsehoods to move the investigation. It was within the ability of the staff to determine the monetary cost of this man's actions. In the very least they could compare the electricity bill during a month he was running SETI versus the next month when he was not. They could calculate the power consumption of the machines. It's not that they are afraid of knowing. But that knowing or admitting the truthfulness of the facts makes them less powerful as people.
- lisper 11y agoI think it's both: ignorance is the source of their power, and they are afraid of losing it. (I also grew up in the South.)
- Florin_Andrei 11y ago> ignorance is the source of their power Ignorance is a source of power only within a like-minded group, and only as long as that group is powerful. Now get out of there and see where ignorance gets you. Or wait until that group washes out into the irrelevance of history.
- lisper 11y agoIt's actually not the ignorance per se, it's the self-confidence that comes from a mindset that allows you to believe things without evidence, or even in the face of contrary evidence. That sort of self-confidence can be very powerful (c.f. Donald Trump) but, of course, it can also be very dangerous.
- 11y ago
- nowarninglabel 11y agoI don't get how this point is debatable. I did this when I worked as a network administrator for a new school campus. It was folding@home vs. SETI but same concept. Once the administration realized all the computers were running folding@home they compared the bills after turning it off and it was tens of thousands of dollars difference (granted this was 2001 and full-size desktops). Now, one could say they overreacted, sure, in my case I just got reprimanded and told to uninstall it off all the computers. But firing for costing the district significant amounts of money isn't some testament to the ignorance of the South, unlike the "bomb" clock.
- nadams 11y ago> tens of thousands of dollars difference I still don't believe that - unless this was 10k computers+. I'll bet that if you used watts up on an idle computer, then used it on a computer running seti@home I'll bet the difference would only be 100 watt difference at the max (probably more like 50 depending on what is running on the computer).
- TallGuyShort 11y ago5k is easily within an order of magnitude of what you would find believable, and he's only expressing an order of magnitude. I think your dispute is rather academic.
- vacri 11y ago"compared bills after turning it off" is a direct measure of costs.
- acqq 11y agoSee my other post here for details, 5000 desktop computers using 100% CPU all the time can cost some 18000 USD per month (1) more versus keeping them idle. 1) if 1 KWh costs 10 cents, which is reasonable to expect, and the load increases just 50 W. And for this guy here it's even much more: http://setiathome.berkeley.edu/forum_thread.php?id=54609&postid=918308#918308 http://setiathome.berkeley.edu/forum_thread.php?id=54609&pos... His single computer uses 490 Watts when turned on and calculating Seti, and he's keeping it on for 18 hour more per day just for Seti. Only 500 of such computers and such usage patterns make 14000 dollars more per month.
- ja27 11y agodumb stuff My wife was on the advisory committee for a local middle school that's struggling. One winner is that they bought SmartBoards for a bunch of classrooms but didn't get stands for them, so they just mothballed them for a year until they could buy stands with the next year's budget.
- HeyLaughingBoy 11y agoWhat would you have them do? If they're over budget, they're over budget and non-emergencies will have to wait.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- phaus 11y agoThe obvious solution would be to buy fewer smart boards this year, along with the stands, and then buy the rest of the smart boards and stands the next year.
- nmrm2 11y agoSure, obvious. Until you're negotiating price points and you can save X% aggregate by purchasing Y boards at a time, and then figure you're only losing <<< X%*total_cost in depreciation... then it's just as obvious, but you're making a different decision.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- benihana 11y agoIt's much easier to justify wasting money on normal business things every day people understand, like buying office paper. Most people can relate to that, even when things go wrong and money is wasted. Most people, be they in the deep south or the northeast have no fucking clue what SETI is and may even have very specific metaphysical opinions on how we should deal with the possibility of alien life that doing this violates. Most people don't care enough about paper to do more than write it off as a normal expense. I personally think that alien life is everywhere and I can't wait until we discover more evidence of it. But I think SETI is a huge waste of resources that could be spent better elsewhere. Even though I'm pro science, discovery, and utilizing wasted cpu cycles, I still think searching for life this way is a huge waste of time and resources and I'd be pissed if some teacher decided he was going to use the resources I take a part in paying for to do this. The benefits of this are external while the cost is internal. If you're going to use resources, at least use them to benefits the kids who are in your budge.
- conanbatt 11y agoThey pretty surely do if their costs were measured by someone. I wouldnt call someone externalizing costs for whatever noble endeavor responsible or forward thinking.