9 ms·
Running seti / etc on the school computers does result in thousands of dollars spend on extra electricity. He was number one on SETI for years, running the cli
by DanBC 11y ago
Running seti / etc on the school computers does result in thousands of dollars spend on extra electricity. He was number one on SETI for years, running the client without approval on 5,000 machines. It's not surprising that people get fired for increasing costs by that much without getting approval first.
See also
http://www.securityfocus.com/news/300 http://www.securityfocus.com/news/300
- nadams 11y ago> does result in thousands of dollars spend on extra electricity Thousands maybe - definitely not millions as they are claiming. From what I read it was setup to calculate through the screensaver. For most of the day - the computer will be in use and I would imagine/hope that they turn them off when they leave.
- DanBC 11y agoAdvice used to be to not turn machines off but let themgo into sleep. This avoided power cycling which some people though caused problems. A sleeping machine still costs money, but much less than a machine churning SETI. 5,000 machines churning SETI for nine years? I'd be interested in estimates of cost.
- mikeash 11y agoQuick and inaccurate estimate: Let's say 100W per computer running at full blast, and assume 12 cents per kWh for electricity. Running for 9 years straight, that's about 5 million dollars. If they're running for 16 hours/day then it's more like 3 million dollars. Adjust other factors to taste, but "millions" sounds pretty reasonable.
- sean13013 11y agoIf the machines were awake for 12 extra hours a day, and drew 100 watts, that's 0.1kW * 5000machines * 12hours = 6000kWh per day. Where I live, electricity costs about 20 cents per kWh. 0.2dollars * 6000kWh * 365days * 9years = $3.94 million.
- Alupis 11y agoWell, far from being definitive, but it looks like a regular pc will cost around $227.52 (350 watt psu, $18.96 per month) in electricity per year to run 24/7.[1] (calculated using $0.06 per kWh, which is rather low for most people in the US) So, 5,000 machines running 24/7/365 would cost around $1,137,600 annually (5,000 machines * $227.52 per year) in electricity usage alone. Of that 24 hours per day, we can assume 8 hours of each day the district expected to pay for them to run, so that leaves ~16 hours the district expected the machines to be asleep or off. 24 - 8 = 16 (about 66% of the 24 hour period) So, the admin was consuming about $12.51 per machine per month the district did not expect. This comes out to around $750,600 the sys admin potentially cost the district, for a single year. He ran this scheme for 9 years -- so... $750,600 per year * 9 years = $6,755,400 in additional electricity costs Keep in mind this is likely rather low, since most places in the US have a significantly higher per kWh fee than the $0.06 per kWh used in these calculations. I'm certain that this sum alone was enough cause to terminate the sys admin. Think about all the things the school district could have spent an extra ~$7MM+ on... [1] http://www.dslreports.com/faq/2404 http://www.dslreports.com/faq/2404
- redblacktree 11y agoSomething is wrong with your math. $227.52/year is $0.62/day Also, bear in mind that PSUs do not use their full rating unless the hardware they are powering requires it. [0] Your number could easily be double what the machines actually used, if the PSU was somewhat oversized, as they typically are. [0]: https://superuser.com/questions/106792/does-a-power-supply-draw-only-as-much-power-as-it-needs https://superuser.com/questions/106792/does-a-power-supply-d...
- Alupis 11y agoSorry, type-o, math is still correct though. Meant it to say "per month" not "per day".
- digler999 11y ago> 350 watt psu, PSU's arent light bulbs. A "350 watt" psu doens't draw 350 watts. That's the theoretical maximum you can draw from it. Sure, SETI was probably drawing a higher load than idle, vs off, but I highly doubt it was drawing 100%. Even more complicated is the heat. If they lived in a cool climate, at least some of the waste heat that was emitted would have been absorbed by the building, which they are (presumably) paying to heat at least a few months of the year. Edit: also if it was a public school, wouldn't they be off for about 3 months over summer ?
- tomswartz07 11y agoAll of that extra power really only amounts to tens of dollars per year. Running a processor at an extra (grossly exaggerating here) few watts + an extra 5-10 watts for fans, LEDs, etc don't amount to much. Especially when you consider that all electricity is paid for by the Thousand-Watts/Hour.
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoThousands can be wasted on dumb stuff like bad office-supply purchasing decisions. Those folks don't get fired. Sounds overblown - folks afraid of anything they don't understand.
- Alupis 11y agoWould you still consider it "overblown" if he had run, say... a bitcoin miner on all those machines? Sure, he didn't make profit from the seti@home instances, but he did it without approval, did ultimately cost the district money, and likely caused other issues along the way (like additional wear-n-tear on the machines)
- ohitsdom 11y agoI'd think administrators would have a very different approach to disciplining a "bad office-supply purchasing" decision versus a well-thought out choice to use school equipment & electricity for non-work related causes.
- tomswartz07 11y ago> electricity for non-work related causes I wish we could fire teachers for using their computers for Facebook and Amazon shopping during the day.
- blacksmith_tb 11y agoAnd should private sector employers fire their employees for using their computers to do the same? Obviously I don't want to see teachers goofing off on social media instead of teaching kids, but if they aren't actively teaching, why not? The idea that every second of your time on the job needs to be spent furiously working is an attitude from the industrial revolution - I would have thought these days we were more interested in results.
- lotharbot 11y agoin the school where I most recently taught, there was an explicit expectation that teachers could use district computers for personal business when on break. Being on facebook when they had kids in the room would be an entirely different matter. The internet was also heavily monitored, with a proxy server that required a login to get to forbidden sites. Our IT guy had a pretty good idea of when teachers were getting on facebook etc.
- samstave 11y agoWere the machines always on regardless? Wouldnt they have consumed some portion of the said electricity no matter what? Or was he preventing the machines from being shutdown or sleeping?
- DanBC 11y agoThe software runs on lowest priority. So when people are using the computer the software just sits there, not doing much. After a few minutes of inactivity the seti software (which sometimes was a screensaver) would kick in. Rather than sleeping or idling the computer would be doing computationally intensive work. Some distributed stuff (especially Prime95) is used specifically because it makes the computer work hard - it's a reliable stress test. This causes extra power to be used for the processor and the fans. http://www.mersenne.org/download/ http://www.mersenne.org/download/
- garrettgrimsley 11y agoRunning Folding@Home, SETI@Home, Prime95, and other CPU intensive applications requires much more power than simply running idle. For example, I have a processor that when running Prime95 will use more than double the idle load wattage. [0] [0] http://www.bit-tech.net/hardware/cpus/2010/04/27/amd-phenom-ii-x6-1090t-black-edition/7 http://www.bit-tech.net/hardware/cpus/2010/04/27/amd-phenom-...
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- masklinn 11y ago> Wouldnt they have consumed some portion of the said electricity no matter what? Some yes, but there's a lot of difference between a machine idling at 0% CPU and one fully loaded with SETI or Folding and running 100% all the time. Would be even more worse now with deep sleep states and GPGPU, but even back then the difference between an idle and a fully loaded machine was absolutely significant.
- logfromblammo 11y ago
- kazinator 11y agoRunning MS Windows on computers results in wasted electricity.
- acqq 11y agoYes, running 5000 computers on 100% CPU instead of idle is a lot of money and a lot of electricity spent: If these were typical desktop computers, the CPU working at 100% can use some 50 W more than the one staying idle. 5000 computers at 100 % CPU produce then the load of 250 KW, resulting in 6 MWh per day which at 10 cents per KWh costs 600 USD per day, or 220000 USD per year. Finally, 9 years that he did it make almost 2 million dollars (!) for electricity that he managed to spend.
- reddog 11y agoYou can roughly double that. Thats the cost of the extra electricity needed by the ACs to offset the heat generated by the pegged PCs.
- tinalumfoil 11y agoThat's ridiculous. Now you're going to say I'm "breaking the law" for installing a bitcoin miner on all the computers I support and donating the money to charity (well, some of it;rent doesn't pay itself)!
- peter303 11y agoYep, government works have been fired for mining on government computers. Unauthorized computer use. http://www.businessinsider.com/researcher-bitcoin-supercomputers-2014-6 http://www.businessinsider.com/researcher-bitcoin-supercompu...
- TallGuyShort 11y agoMaybe not breaking the law, but if you're not the person ultimately responsible for the costs and they're not actually your computers, that's still a dick move. I'd fire you if you worked for me and caused a massive increase in my power bill for something that had no relation to what I asked you to do.