3 ms·
It really depends on whether or not Apple can get third parties to produce useful iOS applications. Recently, I was somewhat surprised to find that Lightroom o
by jrockway 11y ago
It really depends on whether or not Apple can get third parties to produce useful iOS applications.
Recently, I was somewhat surprised to find that Lightroom on the iPad is missing 90% of the desktop application features, including the ability to show RAW files that are sitting on an SD card attached to the iPad. They have a long blog post blaming slow Internet connections (because it would "have" to sync your RAW file and edits to the cloud) and some Apple misfeature (there would have to be two copies of the photo or something) for why the iPad can't do "field triage" from an SD card. I don't buy it, it's clear to me that they have limited resources and they don't care about their iPad app.
If Apple wants to make a first-party photo editor for the iPad that beats Lightroom, fine, that will help the iPad Pro catch on. I would be happy to buy one. (OK, it needs photoshop too.) But the path of least resistance is to get a Surface and have every Windows app ever made running on your tablet. The fact that the Apple Pencil is better than other pen input devices doesn't really matter; if all you can do is adjust the brightness of the image with said pencil, it's all moot.
(That said, I've never used a pen-on-screen interface. I don't mind having my pen away from the screen, and it's cheaper. But I don't use computers for drawing, where that might matter.)
- MBCook 11y agoHonestly I don't think developers get access to the SD card, that would defeat the whole 'there is no file system for users to worry about' thing. I wouldn't be surprised if it simply shows up as a second photo stream, where they'd have to pull the images off edit them and save them back again as a new image. I can understand why you wouldn't really want to trust Adobe, but I'm pretty sure they're actually correct on this one. You're right that getting good software that is sustainable price is going to be what causes the iPad pro to live or tie. It's too expensive for a general tablet for students who might want normal notetaking, but if it doesn't have the software than pros might not want to use it and would stick with the surface or other laptops with Cintiques.
- jrockway 11y agoYeah, they say something to the effect of having to make a copy of the "Camera Roll" photo in order to edit it. Yes, that uses twice as much storage. I personally don't care, I will just upload it to A Real Computer when I get home and then delete it from the iPad. I look at it like a cache, not a permanent home for the photograph.
- majormajor 11y agoUnfortunately, if Apple made a first-party photo editor for iPad that was as good or better as Lightroom, I'd still get a Surface (looking to do just this in a few months before a big trip, very interested in how well the pen works for local adjustments). Why? Because I was an Aperture user before I was a Lightroom user. It'll take a long time to convince me I wouldn't just be buying into the wrong system for a second time.