2 ms·
It's fascinating the number of plausible arguments people come up with for this behavior. One that occurs to me if that someone has unlimited tosses, then the
by joe_the_user 11y ago
It's fascinating the number of plausible arguments people come up with for this behavior.
One that occurs to me if that someone has unlimited tosses, then the number of correct guesses doesn't matter that much for their "expected income stream" - if they want more money, they can just toss more coins instead of cheating. And oppositely, if the experiment is coming to an end, the only way to get more money is by cheating and so now the incentive to cheat becomes a factor.
This isn't fundamentally that different than kazinator's approach [1] but it is a little different.
The position I take on all this is that psychological experiment always involve some particular, reproducible series of behaviors that are then given an abstract intuitive interpretation (distorting heads-tails results becomes "cheating-in-the-abstract"). But naturally any particular behavior actually can have legion abstract interpretations and explanation. I suspect only a much large collection of behaviors and abstraction interpretations could serve as a real compelling explanation. The problem is the intuitive human "toolbox" of abstract explanation - such as "cheating"(in the abstract) might not be the real toolbox we need to use to explain human behavior.
[1]https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10223289 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10223289