5 ms·
Tracking Bluetooth Skimmers in Mexico, Part II
- leoedin 11y agoIt would be nice to know what proportion of ATMs he found were compromised. It sounds like it was almost all of them!
- mbreese 11y agoIn his comments section he estimated it was a percentage in the single digits... http://krebsonsecurity.com/2015/09/tracking-bluetooth-skimmers-in-mexico-part-ii/comment-page-1/#comment-392856 http://krebsonsecurity.com/2015/09/tracking-bluetooth-skimme...
- largote 11y agoMy advice to people visiting Mexico regarding ATMs is to try to use one at an actual bank location, or at least operated by a major bank. Even in the US I'm skeptical of third party ATMs.
- throwaway583467 11y agoI had some suspicions that the previous installment was a fabricated story, and after correspondence with the author my suspicions were confirmed to my satisfaction: that this entire adventure is an out and out fabrication. I am reading Part 2 with great interest to see if it could easily be fabricated or if it includes any evidence not trivially produced. In fact, (I am not done reading), Part 2 confirms my suspicions: To wit, any normal person returning to Marriott CasaMagna and documenting his adventures would have felt great satisfaction to see the ATM unplugged in response to his complaints, and taken a trophy photo. This journalist did not. (Because the entire story is fabricated, at no point were the ATM's unplugged.) You heard it here, folks. This entire adventure is fabricated. My correspondence with the author confirms this to my satisfaction. (You can also see my previous comments for what initially raised my suspicions.)
- IshKebab 11y agoIt's still crazy to me that they left the BLE devices transmitting (and all the same name!) rather than one of: a) Don't set the name. b) Trigger advertising when you type in a specific pin. c) Use a custom radio protocol (much easier than you'd think - you could even use a pre-written one like Nordic's Gazell).
- rasz_pl 11y agoIts most likely a massive operation spanning few cities (if not countries), you dont want to provide IT support for random lowlifes employed by the gangs, this forces you to standardize on something every smartphone is capable of doing, and simplifying the process to the point of click for bacon.
- leoedin 11y agoI wonder what other protocols you could use. Perhaps a WiFi system that looks for a WiFi hotspot with a specific name (easy to do on most smartphones) which then connects automatically? Or just instruct your goons to set their phone's bluetooth name to a particular value and then initiate a bluetooth send to any phones with that name.
- jankins 11y agoKeying in a specific pin might actually be an incriminating and video-recorded action, so while it would probably make a compromised ATM harder to spot, it would be risky. Passing by with no physical contact is less incriminating, even if it does become suspicious.
- fit2rule 11y agoWell, now that Mexican cartel hackers are reading your comment, we can expect - in a years time or so - an equivalent HN article along the lines of "Mexican ATM's are the most sophisticated phishing system on the planet". I'll be here to read it when it happens.
- comrh 11y agoI just don't think there was a reason not to. Obviously these skimmers have been completely successful and I doubt even Krebs could make a dent in that.
- orf 11y agoTo the guy with the throwaway account who seems on a mission to discredit Krebs and this story (with as little evidence as you would expect), please stop. Your comments are ridiculous. As for the series, it's fantastic. I've always enjoyed Kreb's writing but never shared his fascination with skimmers, I always thought it was kind of niche and not really much of a big deal. Seems it's a lot more widespread than people think.
- throwaway7767 11y ago(not the same throwaway you are referring to :) I enjoy Krebs's writing, but to be honest I was underwhelmed by this. Based on the buildup in the first part I expected some insights into the workings of the skimmer group in the second one, but really it could have been summed up as "I walked along the tourist places in Mexico and found a bunch of skimmers of the type I described in the first part." Still interesting to see how widespread it is. I can only assume the next version will use a custom RF protocol or somehow hide the beacon unless provided with the right challenge from the phone.
- fit2rule 11y agoI didn't find the followup to be particularly enlightening. Basically, tl;dr: don't use an ATM in Mexico, you'll regret it. They're all hacked.
- throwaway583467 11y ago(This throwaway account is hellbanned at the moment, so only someone with showdead on would see it.) I actually have no beef at all with Krebs. I personally simply found it very unlikely that the configuration he showed in https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Pi6y2soOp8Y&t=3m30s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Pi6y2soOp8Y&t=3m30s (after sighing and clearing his throat, at the place I linked, before starting on his explanation), in that configuration, nestled between two PCB's, would be seen by the phone from the distance at https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Pi6y2soOp8Y&t=4m45s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Pi6y2soOp8Y&t=4m45s - it's outside class 2 bluetooth range (most phones are class 2) and class 1 chips usually even have an external antenna. PCB's like what the chip is sandwiched between are highly attenuating; but both signals show up at once, from an implausible distance, from inside an enclosure (the ATM) that is not designed to transmit well at all. I have many other specific reasons that confirm my suspicion, including in the video included in the present installment. To me it is completely obvious. (I also did a very light investigation in a brief email exchange with the author.) But just make a mental note of this throwaway, maybe in a few years someone else will pubicly discredit him. (I have no intention of doing so.) In the meantime, sure, he reads a forum where he realized spammers are planning to send him cocaine in the mail and SWAT his house, and averted it just in time. If you would like the other reasons I'm quite sure, then, you can reply with a brief comment and I can email you (you have your profile information linked.) It's obviously quite an egregious case of journalistic fraud if true, but there have been bigger ones. I have no beef with the guy, except that I don't find his story credible. I'm not on a mission to discredit him.
- peterwwillis 11y agoBrian Krebs either has a death wish or balls the size of the moon. Never in a million years would I go and actually try to track down the ATMs compromised by well-funded, sophisticated organized crime gangs. In Latin America, no less, where killing random people only improves your rep and buying police protection is cheap.
- timje1 11y agoHe does mention in the comments that he only published the story once he was out of the country. Certainly publishing it while in Mexico would be courting disaster.
- Apocryphon 11y agoI'd still be concerned for his safety right now. Hope he can get some protection stateside, just in case.
- lizzard 11y agoOh wow! This happened to me just recently; I was in Akumal and Tulum and only used a couple of different cash machines. My card info was stolen and then used in Mexico and Florida for withdrawals.