19 ms·
I most likely traded with this guy in my days on an interest rate desk. I am now not in the least in doubt that price-fixing behaviour occurred in the market at
by lordnacho 11y ago
I most likely traded with this guy in my days on an interest rate desk. I am now not in the least in doubt that price-fixing behaviour occurred in the market at the time, and possibly still does (investigations must have spooked people).
Back in those days, I was working at a fund that held positions in rates, equity index options, and currency derivatives. These are all instruments that depend on some sort of fix to determine a payout. I spent a LOT of time staring at Bloomberg charts when the fix was due. And over that time, I never shook the suspicion that people were systematically rigging these fixings. It was a time of very low volatility before the financial crisis, and yet you would see all these strange spikes on the third Friday of each month (equity index expiry) and often at 1600 (WM/Reuters Currency fix). It coincided with brokers saying such-and-such had a big position. Without being privy to the actual manipulation, there was always the plausible idea that the big player was hedging his risk, but it happened so often you tended to think it was a setup. With LIBOR, it was a bit different because we didn't have a line into the fixing desks.
I wonder how this will play out. Hayes is right that he is an unlikely fall guy. There can be no doubt his bosses understood how this was done. His boss would have been either a trader or a broker. He would have understood precisely why you would want to move the rate. They can also see the PnL statements and positions, so they know the dv01 (value of a basis point) of the fix. For the record, a million bucks per bp is not a huge amount. I know it sounds like a lot, but there are guys out there swinging 20M a day on average, and quite a lot more.
I'm also not shocked that Hayes says it's normal. Anyone who's ever sat on a trading desk has realised that if you could move the market at fixing time, you could make money. The article talks a lot about his Asperger's, and I guess you're meant to speculate that he didn't quite get that he was doing explicitly what other people would do with a wink and a nudge. It's not the first time I've heard rumours involving brokers and brown envelopes.
In any case, I hope the recent fixing scandals have lessened the temptation for people. It ruins the market when everyone suspects foul play.
- cm2187 11y agoIt reminds me of Fabrice Tourre. They blamed the whole originate and distribute scandal on a 28yo VP. Blame the Frenchman! It doesn't excuse the behaviour but I find hard to believe the desk heads knew nothing about it. [Update]: that being said he probably paid for adding stupidity to his criminal behaviour by documenting his crimes on recorded chatrooms.