4 ms·
At this point it would be news if exercise isn't beneficial for $CONCERN. So the question is how, do we make it so that people want to get of their ass and exe
by tomjen3 11y ago
At this point it would be news if exercise isn't beneficial for $CONCERN.
So the question is how, do we make it so that people want to get of their ass and exercise? Considering the general state of health in most first world countries (especially given the recent news that half of US adults are either diabetic or pre-diabetic), this may very well be the question in public health.
And yet we almost never see any research about this.
- fleshshelf 11y agoOr, how about instead of having to exercise like crazy to cope with work, we make work itself more sustainable?
- dllthomas 11y agoOr, since people aren't getting enough exercise to begin with, how about we do both - with priority on upping the exercise to a reasonable level.
- stdbrouw 11y agoActually, most of these studies show that moderate exercise is beneficial for $CONCERN. Strenuous exercise can lead to a heart attack, knee damage et cetera, and sports are often inherently dangerous – from broken bones to tennis elbows. The prevailing scientific view on exercise is actually quite nuanced.
- 0xcde4c3db 11y agoIndeed. Given the actual state of the science, it's arguably irresponsible to make unqualified claims about "exercise". Doubly so if the claim is being made with regard to an individual or small group rather than a large population. The way people talk about the benefits of "exercise" is about on the level of saying that "food" prevents scurvy, goiter, and rickets.
- throwaway1967 11y ago> So the question is how, do we make it so that people want to get of their ass and exercise? Sell it in a pill, or sell a service so that someone else can do the hard work for me, or otherwise sell a gadget I strap around me and it works "me" out. /s In other words, pigritia imperat - laziness rules. More seriously, people will exercise if you can distract them from the fact that they are exercising. Once those immersive first-person shooters become cheaper you might see a change.
- mahyarm 11y agoTreadmill desks!
- arielweisberg 11y agoGive people private offices with treadmill desks? Made a huge difference for me. Being able to get in exercise without having to think about made it fundamentally more effective than any other lifestyle change. It's also upped my energy level to the point that I seek other forms of exercise and activity. The barrier besides cost and space is getting people to ramp up slowly enough that they are successful and don't hurt themselves. A treadmill that automates the amount of walking you do and and takes into account how you report feeling and how much experience you have would make that possible. If your desk provided you feedback and metrics and you gamified it a bit I'll bet you could solve the motivation issue for a good chunk of the population. I've encountered many people who haven't used a treadmill desk full time who think it wouldn't work for them, but never someone who has tried it and failed. I don't know how strongly survivor biased that is. I think it's a public health issue and it's in the best interest of the government and insurers to reduce costs down the road by driving change today. I really think what we are doing today is borrowing from our future selves and society (by way of medicare).
- maccard 11y agoI run 5k three times a week, and do a moderately heavy weights session each of those days. I don't want my employer to force me to be standing when I've already done 2 hours of exercise that day.
- kd5bjo 11y agoIn the US, exercise being recognized as "medically necessary" would open up a lot of doors via the ADA -- employers would be required to make reasonable accommodation for you to get the exercise you need.
- virmundi 11y agoWe're sneaking in a punching bag to my wife's work. It's a hospice -- emotional job. Adding a heavy bag to the back should help with frustration and loss. It also makes room for the pul up tower.
- Symbiote 11y agoI've just moved to Copenhagen. Part of the appeal was joining the 50% of residents who commute by bicycle. Denmark has one of the lowest obesity rates in Europe. There are some statistics relating to walking/cycling/public transport in this paper, but I haven't read it properly yet: http://www.cycle-helmets.com/walk-bike-obesity-rates.pdf http://www.cycle-helmets.com/walk-bike-obesity-rates.pdf
- JohnBooty 11y agohow, do we make it so that people want to get of their ass and exercise? We have to make it fun. Look at all the nerds (and I would definitely include myself as a nerd) who wouldn't dream of working out, but burned millions of calories on Wii Fit and Dance Dance Revolution. I'm not saying it necessarily has to be a video game. A lot of people would love sports if they had a local, easily accessible, and judgement-free chance to play them. I think very few people have the mindset to do grueling, non-fun workouts on a regular and lifelong basis. And you know what? Nobody really should, either. There are so many fun ways to do it.