10 ms·
It is interesting comparing Microsoft and Apple's convertible tablet strategy. Microsoft's devices use the full OS and are basically laptops first and tablets
by slg 11y ago
It is interesting comparing Microsoft and Apple's convertible tablet strategy. Microsoft's devices use the full OS and are basically laptops first and tablets second while Apple is doing the opposite. If this is truly designed to be "Pro" as in enterprise , I think Microsoft's strategy is going to lead to more productive and therefore better enterprise devices.
EDIT: And after the price is revealed the scales tip a little more in Microsoft's favor. The entry level iPad Pro is the same price as a Surface Pro 3, but has half the disk space and doesn't include the stylus.
- relaytheurgency 11y agoThe Samsung Galaxy Tab Pro is basically the Android version of the new Apple device. I own one, albeit not for enterprise purposes, and it's not very well executed. I could never imagine using such a stripped down interface as my primary work device. People use Surfaces here all the time for whatever that's worth, it's a valid device choice option.
- 72deluxe 11y agoI have a Note 2014 edition and like you, I feel it is clunky by comparison. I really wanted to love it but lame battery life in comparison to a three-year old iPad3 and the inability of S Note to ignore my hand motions and not do zooming when I move my hand irritates me. Coupled with worse performance than the iPad3, and I have the LTE edition of the Note. I can only imagine how stuttery and slow the non-LTE edition is (which uses an 8 core chip and got rubbish performance reviews). Using Google Maps in 3D mode gives me framerates like viewing a compressed VNC session over an SSH link on a Raspberry Pi over a 2G GSM connection. Slow.
- drzaiusapelord 11y agoThis a million times. Apple is just slowly re-inventing the Desktop OS (hey look multi-tasking, a keyboard, etc) while MS went full into a hybrid OS over all its lines that can adapt to whatever hardware its installed on. For all the grief MS got for Windows 8, the move it made was ultimately the right one and builds the proper foundation they need for the future. As side note, lets recall about three or four years ago that we were reading, and agreeing with, articles predicting the death of the MS, at the very least, if not WIMP computing in general. Now we're sitting here with Windows 10, Surface, etc. MS did what it needed to do to stop its fall into irrelevancy. I can't imagine shelling out near a $1,000+ for this thing (lets price in the keyboard and other accessories) when I can get a proper Macbook or Surface Pro, both which are much more capable. I imagine this will become the next hot executive toy (I need my twitter and my exchange mail up at the same time, nerds!). It'll sell in predictable low numbers and then one day mysteriously disappear from the Apple webpage with no fanfare. I feel Apple has painted itself in a corner here. It never bonded OSX and iOS and carefully made them separate products. This probably made sense 5-6 years ago, but unified devices are now practical and affordable. I suspect Apple has a unified OS ready to go soon and is just buying time with this "Pro" to seem competitive. I can't imagine the status quo lasting. What exactly does a mobile OS get me, especially when it needs hardware and RAM on the level of a desktop OS not too long ago? Trying to "keep it simple" is what got Nokia and Blackberry killed. I fear that this industry is destined to just re-invent the desktop, but with sexier devices, in the end. I'm not one to underestimate Apple, but the past couple years have been underwhelming. Even their much hyped watch is a fairly milquetoast design with a poor value proposition. Or the mobile game has simply matured and there are no more big ideas in this space. Are we at the "gimmicks and minor refinements" stage of this technology?
- tdkl 11y agoYeah, the whole hybrid thing went really well with Windows and Surface series was a success.
- yulaow 11y agoI agree with the fact the the windows10/surface idea is the best for my use and purposes but... I would not call it a success, at least not commercially. The surfaces aren't selling so well atm, even after already 3 iterations.
- icelancer 11y agoPretty sure that was the parent's point. But the short-term results may not be what is relevant. Plenty of good decisions were lambasted in the short-term because consumers aren't always the best judge of what will happen down the line. People overrate what will happen in 1 year and underrate what will happen in 5.
- chucknelson 11y ago/s
- X-Istence 11y agoI wonder if parent didn't mean to add a /s that statement.
- tdkl 11y agoGot me there.
- lotso 11y agoSurface seems to be doing pretty well. I'm sure even better when compared to other PC manufacturers. http://www.zdnet.com/article/microsoft-surface-hits-1bn-revenue-mission-accomplished/ http://www.zdnet.com/article/microsoft-surface-hits-1bn-reve...
- 11y ago
- criddell 11y agoNone of that really matters though. It's all about the applications. If you need to run Windows software, buy a Windows machine. If the applications you depend on require iOS, buy an iPad. Other non-software features (like battery life and weight) matter as well. Price doesn't really matter though.
- blumkvist 11y agoWhat professional applications require ios?
- snurk 11y agoPlenty of point of sale apps. Really common in smaller retail stores. Also waiters in restaurants using iPad minis
- criddell 11y agoI had an insurance adjuster at my house to evaluate hail damage earlier this year and he did everything on an iPad. My doctor uses an iPad for Medscape (? not sure if that's right) and some other mobile point of care app. My mother in law is a real estate agent and her office uses iPads for everything. There's a ton of them and it's a very hot area right now. It's a great time to be an iOS developer.
- yellowapple 11y agoIt's worth noting that some (probably most) of these aren't iOS exclusives; I've had Medscape on quite a few of my Android devices over the last couple years, for example.
- criddell 11y agoOh for sure. Many are fairly thin wrappers around web api client.
- blumkvist 11y agoAlright, I see now. Thanks.
- Jerry2 11y ago>I think Microsoft's strategy is going to lead to more productive and therefore better enterprise devices. If that were true, SP3 should have been a huge hit by now. It's not.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> > I think Microsoft's strategy is going to lead to more productive and therefore better enterprise devices. > If that were true, SP3 should have been a huge hit by now. That doesn't follow. "Is going to" does not imply "has" and "has" does not imply "has, and also the market in general has already realized and responded to this fact".
- Someone 11y agoThe risk with Microsoft's approach is that companies will think "our Windows app runs fine on Surface" and invest little on making their application work great on Surface because they form a small part of the market. The risk with Apple's approach is that companies will think "it's too much work to make a custom UI for such a small market". I guess time will tell who wins this. Possibly, things will go like they went with Mac OS and Windows: some companies decided to build applications for the Mac, thus forcing others out of the market, and making it easier for them to develop Windows versions. Another possibility is that the way larger market in 2015 vs 1985 and the existence of many existing iOS apps makes more companies decide that developing a custom UI for iPad Pro is worth the effort.
- chronic41 11y agoThere's no need to "time will tell who wins." The Surface has already won for the past 3 years.
- benologist 11y agoI think Apple will have a very hard time convincing companies to port / produce complex apps that come with a lifetime of free updates. Mac App store has failed pretty objectively at applying iOS conventions to serious software.
- Someone 11y agoMaybe, but what surprises me every time I browse the App Store is the amount of expensive apps I encounter. There are many textbooks that have made the jump to iPad while keeping prices that are far above $10. For an example, see http://www.pcronline.com/eurointervention/textbook/pcr-textbook/ http://www.pcronline.com/eurointervention/textbook/pcr-textb...: "Get the iPad application for only $149.99" Maybe that is just a web site in an app with limited interactivity, but there definitely seems to be competition in that market. The disadvantage of free updates in such markets may be more than balanced by the advantage of very limited ability to resell apps (the easiest way I know to resell apps is to create separate iTunes accounts for each app, and let te buyer set a new password for that account. That becomes impractical soon, of you have tens of apps) That 3D knee visualization, to me, seems a clear indication of that.
- listic 11y agoKeep in mind that Microsoft spent 2 generations before converging on the current strategy: 'non-Pro' Surfaces 1 and 2 were ARM-powered Windows RT devices that could only run Windows Store apps (similar to iPad). When noone seemed to want that, Microsoft went out and made 'non-Pro' Surface 3 just a cheaper, slimmer, lower-powered device, running the same version of Windows as its bigger sibling; also non-Pro was released after the Pro and just after the newest Intel Atom chip: http://ark.intel.com/products/85475/Intel-Atom-x7-Z8700-Processor-2M-Cache-up-to-2_40-GHz http://ark.intel.com/products/85475/Intel-Atom-x7-Z8700-Proc... I actually expected the iPad Pro to support OS X apps; maybe via being powered by a new Apple Ax frankenchip that runs iOS ARM as well as x86 code (another payoff from the investment to custom chip design) and/or by requiring to recompile with the latest XCode for the App Store (a payoff from the long investment in LLVM). Maybe next year.
- npunt 11y agoIf a device has a frankenchip, it's guaranteed to be stuck with frankenapps. Which is exactly the state of Surface unfortunately. Its kinda heresy to say here, but good software is only possible when devs adapt to the platform users choose, not the other way around.
- seanmcdirmid 11y agoSurface Pro 3 has a fan, this doesn't. That's a big difference that I would pay a bit more for (I actually went with a surface 3 just for this reason). The screen is also higher res, I'm guessing the unit is lighter also. Looks like it might be time for a surface pro 4 though, so let's see.
- georgerobinson 11y agoI must say I sat opposite someone on the train the other week and thought "what is that noise?". It turned out to be his Surface Pro. I'm not sure whether he was doing anything particularly intensive or just checking email, but the fact that it was audible above the typical noise of a train put me off ever wanting to buy one. Imagine trying to read or watch a movie in bed with that whirring going on!
- seanmcdirmid 11y agoI'm done with fans in tablets. Surface 3's Intel X is ok, though performance is just on par with the A8 (it falls behind in many benchmarks, but it's good enough for me). I wonder if Apple will update the iPad air with 3d touch and stylus capabilities?
- Encosia 11y agoOut of the box, a Surface Pro 3 definitely does not spin up the fan just checking email, unless you're checking email with Chrome. Gmail on Chrome ended up being more resource intensive than Office or Visual Studio on my SP3.
- RexRollman 11y agoI think the one important thing that Microsoft's approach has over Apple's is file management. File management is horrible on iOS.
- therein 11y agoDo you know what happens if you let people see their files? They try to edit them. Do you want people to be able to edit their files? Yeah... I thought so.
- chillacy 11y agoI know you're being sarcastic, but yes, some people do edit their files. They see that folder that says System32 and start re-organizing the files within, and then feel like computers are scary and difficult when things break.
- mythz 11y agoFile Systems is also a complexity that confuses a lot of non-technical people, which is why Apple tries to hide that one even exists on iOS - Where can I find the latest document I was working on? Just open the app you created it with, as a bonus you'll get transparent syncing across all your devices. Syncing and Backup are tedial tasks most people wouldn't do if they needed to do it manually or configure an external program / service to do it.
- vezzy-fnord 11y agoIt's one thing to have a persistent object store instead of a file system (as the Newton did). It's wholly another to have a file system at the core of your OS but just pretend it doesn't exist. That's a regressive obfuscation, not encapsulation. (Yes, I understand who the target audience is.)
- mythz 11y agoApple's primary focus is on UX simplicity and Customers couldn't care less how it's implemented behind the scenes, they just want to get stuff done, find the Word document they were working on or see the Photo or Video they just took. The less Customers have to know about how technology works the happier they are, and the more successful Apple is.
- dendory 11y agoYet at the end of the day, the CEO will overrule the IT's multiples productivity arguments and tell them to get him an iPad Pro because it's Apple, because his Golf buddy told him today's presentation was awesome and because he is very satisfied with his iPhone.
- 72deluxe 11y agoSad but true. Do you feel like a pawn in a giant chess game sometimes?