26 ms·
CloudFlare and Google Cloud Platform
- steckerbrett 11y agoIt's becoming unusual not to see sites behind CloudFlare now, pretty neat from a routing standpoint and devastating to user privacy and security on the whole. If things continue in this direction we'll have the cloudflare, and some scraps of regular internet off the side.
- dangrossman 11y agoThe more popular it becomes, the more incentive there is for other companies to enter the space and grab a chunk of the money. The barriers to entry are not insurmountable for e.g. existing CDN companies to start offering DNS, WAF and DDOS mitigation products, making them more like Cloudflare. They already have the peering/hosting relationships and engineering teams experienced at working with large volumes of traffic. I wouldn't be too worried about Cloudflare taking over the internet this early on.
- TheSisb2 11y agoTo continue with your point, we use https://sucuri.net/ https://sucuri.net/ where I work because it has such a great set of tools and extension for our Wordpress blog, which kept getting hacked. Lots of space in this area.
- dangrossman 11y agoGood example: "Sucuri is Building a Comprehensive Alternative to CloudFlare" http://wptavern.com/sucuri-is-building-a-comprehensive-alternative-to-cloudflare http://wptavern.com/sucuri-is-building-a-comprehensive-alter...
- steckerbrett 11y agoIs there reason for people to enter a market with a single obvious leader though? I got the impression that making peering agreements with people on any sort of scale was a bit of a bear. It is already quite ubiquitous, a surprising number of websites use it even if it's not completely obvious, reddit.com has some sort of stealth configuration that bypasses the normal DNS setup for example.
- toomuchtodo 11y ago> Is there reason for people to enter a market with a single obvious leader though? Were there not search engines before Google? Isn't AWS the cloud computing "leader" while Google is trying to break into the space? There is no such thing as an obvious leader, only juicy prey waiting for the next hungry org to eat its lunch. > I got the impression that making peering agreements with people on any sort of scale was a bit of a bear. Hardly. Peering agreements are of similar difficulty level as any vendor negotiation, whether it be with a specific network or an interconnection fabric (IXP).
- manigandham 11y agoThat's how the market works... otherwise we wouldn't have any new companies if everyone gave up before competing with the big guys. There's a lot of potential to do better against anyone.
- Someone1234 11y agoThat's a lot of hyperbole there. If you look at the top 500 websites very few of them are behind CloudFlare, CloudFlare's penetration seems to be SMBs mostly (since larger orgs can afford the in-house mitigations that CloudFlare offers).
- steckerbrett 11y agoDid you know reddit is? You wouldn't know it from looking at the WHOIS, I'm betting lots of places are behind it without showing the normal indicators. Name Server: CNS1.REDDIT.COM Name Server: CNS2.REDDIT.COM Name Server: CNS3.REDDIT.COM Doesn't look like it from here.. ;; ANSWER SECTION: CNS1.REDDIT.COM. 172246 IN A 173.245.58.24 Delegated to? OrgName: CloudFlare, Inc. OrgId: CLOUD14 There we go! CloudFlare after all.
- nulltype 11y agoIt might be easier if you use curl. curl -I https://www.reddit.com https://www.reddit.com HTTP/1.1 200 OK Server: cloudflare-nginx
- joshmn 11y agoThose top 500 websites have the money to sit atop of CloudFlare's enterprise plan, which I believe offers custom-branded DNS servers.
- AdmiralAsshat 11y agopretty neat from a routing standpoint and devastating to user privacy on the whole I'm interested. Please expand on the privacy point. I thought the general move to CloudFlare was a good thing for privacy, as it provides an easy mechanism for getting sites onto HTTPS without having every site to worry about managing certificates.
- ceejayoz 11y agoIf CloudFlare is compromised by an intelligence agency or forced by law enforcement and courts to cooperate, they're a large single-point-of-failure for privacy.
- MichaelGG 11y agoAdditionally, a lot of sites probably just use CFs crypto, without securing it to their backend servers. Hence there could be less encryption overall.
- duskwuff 11y agoIndeed, CloudFlare will happily run an HTTPS front-end proxy to an origin which is using a self-signed certificate, or even to a HTTP origin. Thought that site was secure? Think again!
- slipstream- 11y agoIf the origin used a self-signed cert, doesn't cloudflare use certificate pinning?
- devbug 11y agoLess severely, they themselves know the vast majority of sites users are visiting and the content they're being served. Valuable stuff for advertisers, among others.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- orf 11y agoit’s routed through a high-performance interconnect instead of the public Internet The public internet does seem to be shrinking, more and more closed data silos and now huge chunks of traffic going through a 'trusted' man-in-the-middle. From an individual sites standpoint it's amazing (and I use it for most of my sites), but the bigger they become the more juicy a target they are.
- rakoo 11y agoIs this not some kind of peering, though ? The way I see it, Cloudflare decided to peer with Google instead of using transit or, even worse, public internet (with the overhead it has over AS-to-AS connections). I don't see how the "public internet" somehow lost anything.
- spicyj 11y agoDoes this apply to App Engine too? Is there a way to test if you're getting the direct route?
- arihant 11y agoThis is tangential, but is there any way one can use Cloudflare and not be subject to Google Analytics spam?
- jgrahamc 11y agoWhat are you talking about?
- arihant 11y agoThis: https://moz.com/blog/how-to-stop-spam-bots-from-ruining-your-analytics-referral-data https://moz.com/blog/how-to-stop-spam-bots-from-ruining-your... And this: https://blog.sucuri.net/2015/07/malicious-google-analytics-referral-spam.html https://blog.sucuri.net/2015/07/malicious-google-analytics-r... I and others that I know get this kind of referral spam on every single domain we have with cloudflare. I know DNS records are public, but is there something cloudflare and other public DNS hosting services can do to prevent this?
- chinathrow 11y agoThose spambots hit hard these days. However, they never ever touch your origin or your CDN at all (check your logs, nothing). They fake the log entry directly into the Analytics systems. Google has to cleanup, but sadly, they haven't moved a bit since ages.
- arihant 11y agoYes, that is true. However, the fact that only my cloudflare domains experience this suggests either, 1. They are targeting domains specifically with cloudflare nameservers. 2. They are somehow obtaining a list of domains running on cloudflare. Both these tasks are not hard to accomplish. And it is extremely irritating.
- shazow 11y agoMost of these spammers just emit events to a large range of GA tracking ids completely blindly, think of it as the equivalent of... for (var i=0; i<100000; i++) { ga('create', 'UA-' + i + '-1'); ga('send', 'pageview'); // But with a fake referrer } They do that a bunch of times per day from a bunch of different IP addresses. Adding host filtering to your properties on GA eliminates about 80% of spam which use this technique. It's possible you're being targeted due to being in a specific market or something, but it's unlikely to be related to Cloudflare. (At least I can't think of any reason why it would be related.)
- verelo 11y agoI want to love CloudFlare, I really do. We currently use them, but sadly the number of times that CloudFlare has been the cause of a service interruption is somewhere around 50% mark. They are no longer in use on any critical/important end points, I just don't need PagerDuty waking us up over an issue I have no control over. This is not a problem I expect to improve. As they start to cover all of the web, i imagine that it'll actually only get worse. Curious about how they see this progressing.
- jgrahamc 11y agoI would love to talk to you about this. jgc @ guess the domain.
- saurik 11y agoI wrote an article a while back digging into the details of an outage in a website I work with caused by CloudFlare, and while at some level the issue here was "CloudFlare didn't care enough to test their stack against popular browsers and then didn't have the in-house expertise to debug and correct issues that were later found", I frankly feel like this problem is pretty engrained into their business :/. If nothing else, the article might be interesting to some as it looks at how to even go about debugging complex interactions between web browser internals and overly clever JavaScript. http://www.saurik.com/id/14 http://www.saurik.com/id/14 "When 'Dumb Pipes' Get Too Smart"
- pdknsk 11y agoI strongly advise against hosting images, particularly photos, behind CloudFlare. I don't use it myself but I'm frequently noticing CloudFlare aggressively stripping color-profiles from images. Most noticeable if the photo has an AdobeRGB profile, as many do. It makes skin tones in particular look very dull. I don't know if CloudFlare honors no-transform – I suspect they do, but most sites don't send it.
- jgrahamc 11y agoI would like to understand this. If a customer asks we do do image recompression to save space, and strip metadata (this is one of our services) but would like to know what this is about.
- Kalium 11y agoMy experience in web-dev is that browser support for color profiles is dodgy at best. Much like alpha in PNGs. It's usually wiser to not rely on occasionally-supported features. PNG alpha in particular was a nightmare for me. After that I knew to look out for the pain caused by occasionally-supported features in images.
- billyhoffman 11y agoThis "much like alpha in PNGs" makes it sound like you think this is a recent problem we still have to deal with. It's not: http://caniuse.com/#feat=png-alpha http://caniuse.com/#feat=png-alpha PNG alpha transparency was a problem with the decade old IE6. And even then IE6 worked fine with PNG8 images that had alpha transparency. IE7 and IE8 required a 1 line style attribute to work 100% with PNG + alpha, and IE9 did away with that need altogether.
- Kalium 11y agoThe problem of haphazard feature support is not new, no.
- malkia 11y ago
- MichaelGG 11y agoSo does this apply to any GCE customer hosting in US? If I've got machines in us-central and I'm using CF, then I don't have to do anything? My bandwidth charge from GCE should go to about 0?
- asuth 11y agoThis is great! We run Quizlet behind Cloudflare, and use Google Cloud for all our server infrastructure (>150 VMs). We've been very happy on both platforms. We'll be saving around $2k/mo on bandwidth because of this deal, and we didn't have to lift a finger. Yay :) Happy to answer any questions about either platform.
- mattbasta 11y agoThis is excellent, honestly. We recently moved a few billion requests each month behind CloudFlare and our metrics show that our median user (in terms of load time) had their assets loaded almost 40% faster. It's also worth noting that CloudFlare is the only reputable CDN that currently supports SPDY, and is (purportedly) actively working to turn on HTTP/2. Compare that to a company like Akamai that's still advertising Edge Side Includes like they're new and innovative and the year is 2004.
- rprime 11y agoSide question, does anybody have any experience with their RailGun feature, is it worth it? We recently switched to CF and mostly use them as a CDN and we're quite happy, good value for the money.
- thekonqueror 11y agoI use railgun on a few sites, it does make noticeable difference in page load times.
- buro9 11y agoI work at CloudFlare and have tried every feature on my site https://www.lfgss.com/ https://www.lfgss.com/ at some point. Railgun is the single biggest improvement a dynamic web site can enable. The biggest benefit is the established connection between the CloudFlare PoPs and your origin server. The second benefit is the "compression" that is the result of each side having a shared dictionary. But really, it's the open connection. The things I tell my friends to use from CloudFlare: * DNS * Railgun * Caching (my S3 bill is so small now) * DDoS protection (I'm under attack!) That's usually the order I recommend it too... Railgun is up there. After that list it tends to get more specific, about their web app and what works for them... but all of the above, just enable and use. If you are on Chrome and install the Claire plugin then you can view Railgun information in the address bar: https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/claire/fgbpcgddpmjmamlibbaobboigaijnmkl https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/claire/fgbpcgddpmj...
- rprime 11y agoThank for the information buro9, my company has started to go global and we now serve clients in Australia, Japan, locations far away from our origin server (+200ms) and I am hoping to see a big improvement there. I'll enable it today and see how it goes.
- manigandham 11y agoTo offset some of the feedback here, we run close to a billion requests a month through CloudFlare with no issues at all. We use their Strict SSL setting and everything is fast and secure and we save a ton on bandwidth. As far as CDN service goes, free SSL and bandwidth and peering + all of their datacenter locations + DNS integration gives us better latency than pretty much everyone else we've tried.
- aagha 11y agoDitto! We're a small startup and serve up about 3.5M requests through CloudFlare a day. when we were using AWS CloudFront, our costs quickly escalated to $100/day as we brought on new customers. We switched over the CloudFlare and made that $100/day cost go away. CloudFlare's free service has been amazing and we've had no hiccups with it.
- manigandham 11y agoHacker News and Reddit and StackOverflow use CloudFlare too. So they must be doing something right.
- maartendb 11y agoI'd love to see more transparency in the way CDNs decide to cache or not cache your content. For example: Cloudflare publishes crawl frequencies in their pricing table but what do they actually do with that content? Push it to all their edges? I'd doubt that. I guess it's based on website traffic, your website pricing plan, ... but it seems quite arbitrary to me.
- forcer 11y agoIt took us a while but we tested what sort of speed up you can see with this new partnership - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10233035 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10233035