3 ms·
The article assumes that if you defend public libraries, you must defend them for the same reason the author defends them, and that particular reason happens to
by mikeash 11y ago
The article assumes that if you defend public libraries, you must defend them for the same reason the author defends them, and that particular reason happens to fit well with file sharing.
But there are other reasons to defend public libraries than simply the fact that they disseminate knowledge and this is worth carving out an exception in copyright. I think most people would defend public libraries on the basis of the doctrine of first sale: after an author sells a copy of a work, they can't control how you use it. As long as you're not making unauthorized copies of it, you can lend it out or do whatever else you like with it.
- moviuro 11y agoHow is reading a book different of watching a movie? When I'm done, I can return the book/delete the movie. The only difference is outlined in the article: the movie can be watched simultaneously by different people who got it, whilst I'm the only one with the book in my hands.
- mikeash 11y agoYes, and that's the doctrine of first sale: you can do what you like with a copy you own, besides make additional unauthorized copies. As such, libraries operate within the law and within the spirit of copyright, while file sharing doesn't. You can certainly object to the spirit of copyright as expressed here, but there's nothing inconsistent about supporting it, and supporting public libraries.
- lumisota 11y agoYou say "only" as if this isn't an important distinction in terms of creating value for a copyrighted work.
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoConfused: you can 'return' the movie AND keep a copy, which you distribute widely thus ruining any chance of the creator profiting by their work. Can't do that with the physical book. Not for free anyway.
- shripadk 11y agoYou can scan the book and distribute digital copies of it for free. The only investment is time required to scan the books.
- e28eta 11y agoYou can also steal a book from the library under your jacket, and then you don't have to return it. It doesn't mean it's legal or right.
- shripadk 11y agoI was just countering his point on copying physical books: "Can't do that with the physical book. Not for free anyway." Stealing a book doesn't amount to copying the book and returning it.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- an0nym1ty 11y agoIs that not one of the most common analogies used by Pirates, the similarities between file sharing and lending a book or movie to a friend? That argument has failed for file sharing, what makes your argument different?
- mikeash 11y agoThe fact that file sharing involves copying, not lending existing copies, is significant. If pirates make that analogy then they're being ridiculous. I'm not sure I've seen it made myself.
- shripadk 11y agoLending existing copies does not prevent copying. I have come across plenty of "pirated" physical copies of various literature sold for a fraction of the actual cost.
- mikeash 11y agoWho said anything about preventing copying? I'm just saying that the way libraries operate does not involve making their own copies, which is a (and I would say the) significant difference from file sharing, in terms of morality and legality.
- shripadk 11y agoThat is an important point which you are not seeing. I can share a file (an ebook) with my "friend" which i acquired legitimately. He then makes a copy of it and distributes it via a file sharing site. Similarly, I can borrow a book from a public library and make digital copies of it and distribute it. In fact some illegal copies of ebooks you find on file sharing sites are scanned copies of legitimately acquired physical copies (I have personally come across comics with library seals in one of the scanned pirated digital copies). Some pirates also distribute colored xerox copies of physical copies acquired from libraries. The only difference between the two is time taken to do it.
- grecy 11y agoAnd this concept is shackling libraries today. My local library will only allow one person to "borrow" a given e-book at a time. You must wait until someone else returns it before you can "borrow" it for a set period of time. Obviously this is nonsense, and if the library were interested in efficient lending, they'd let everyone that wanted it borrow the e-book at the same time. IMO, the same applies to DVDs - why not let thousands of people "borrow" a digital copy of a DVD simultaneously
- rhino369 11y agoBut it's always been nonsense. A library could print their own copy of books for hundreds of years. They could easily do it since Xerox was invented. Digital just reduces the cost to copying just a little bit. There is a fundamental difference between loaning and copying, both from a legal and moral perspective.
- lazylizard 11y agohow can one return the song one just heard on radio? does anyone intend to?
- scintill76 11y agoI think you're looking at it differently than Falkvinge (granted, he may be willfully contorting his perspective to whatever fits his argument.) Wikipedia says about the Libraries Act[1], "The Capitalist economic model had created shift patterns which left workers with free time[...] Campaigners felt that encouraging the lower classes to spend their free time on morally uplifting activities, such as reading, would promote greater social good." A committee reported, "the first step taken by a foreign writer was to consult a public library on the subject of his studies or composition; we find that no such auxiliary was at the service of the British intellect." So, the supposed reason (for the British, at least), was for the public good and intellect. The first sale doctrine is a legal defense, which is not the same as a reason public libraries should exist or why they are good. This may be somewhat muddied by his use of "defend" everywhere, rather than something else. Anyway, I think he has a decent point, that libraries were last century's big threat to IP holders (would have liked to see some citations on the controversy though), the government decided a public good would be served with a smallish sacrifice from the industry, and that filesharing is a similar but much more efficient execution of that public service (but at perhaps too big of a cost to the IP holders.) [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_Libraries_Act_1850 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_Libraries_Act_1850
- mikeash 11y agoWell yes, I'm looking at it differently, that's my whole point. The article is saying that if you defend one you must defend the other. My point is that if you look at things from a different perspective then it's quite easy to defend one without defending the other. It's all about whether you look at libraries as an exception to copyright which has been carved out for the public good, or whether you look at libraries as something that is naturally allowed within copyright. Put it another way: the article argues on the basis of a library's purpose. I'm ignoring that, and merely looking at a library's right to exist. If you see the purpose coming first, and the right to exist being created on the basis of that purpose, then the argument in the article holds. If you see the right to exist coming first, and the purpose merely being why people take advantage of that right, then you get my position. Maybe this is one of those American versus European things. It looks from my cursory examination (and I could easily be wrong, and welcome a more informed opinion from anyone who knows better) that the doctrine of first sale is an American thing, and European laws give more rights to the copyright holder.
- Nadya 11y ago>As long as you're not making unauthorized copies of it, you can lend it out or do whatever else you like with it. How does this work with files? How do I distribute a file without also copying it? If I cut->paste instead of copy->paste the file for a friend, am I distributing my original file? What happens if I give my friend my music library and decide to buy myself new music? I'm allowed to make copies of my music for personal use (otherwise good luck getting that MP3 on your computer to play on your mobile device). I make a copy and give the original to a friend. My friend then makes a copy of the original and gives the original to their friend. The copies made are authorized and we're lending out the original. It doesn't work once you leave physical constraints on scarcity and existence.
- mikeash 11y agoYou're right, once you hit the digital realm things change a lot. Which is exactly why I think it's silly to think that one's views on libraries must decide one's views on file sharing. They're extremely different things.