5 ms·
I am always amazed that people can't figure out why Google is doing this. Google is rolling out fiber to neuter Comcast. Period. Comcast basically blackmaile
by bsder 11y ago
I am always amazed that people can't figure out why Google is doing this.
Google is rolling out fiber to neuter Comcast. Period.
Comcast basically blackmailed Google several years back and thought they won. Google, rightfully, now saw Comcast as an existential threat to their business.
Google will keep rolling out until they have Comcast by the balls. Only then will they stop.
- pdkl95 11y agoI am always amazed when people can't figure out that google is doing this because their business model is based on "targeted advertising", which necessarily requires gathering as much personal information as possible. All of their products are designed to give them different kinds of data, and being the man-in-the-middle to the entire internet on a per-household basis gives Google an incredibly fine-grained picture of the patter-of-life of the people that use their ISP service. Being able to steal Comcast's market is just a nice side benefit.
- jpatokal 11y agoGenuinely curious here: what additional data would Google get as an ISP that it doesn't already get via search, Gmail, ads, etc? Or do you mean "man-in-the-middle" in the cryptographic sense, and you think Google is playing mini-NSA and start spoofing Facebook certs so it can eavesdrop on SSL connections or something? See also Google Fiber's privacy policy: Other information from the use of Google Fiber Internet (such as URLs of websites visited or content of communications) will not be associated with the Google Account you use for Fiber, except with your consent or to meet any applicable law, regulation, legal process or enforceable governmental request. https://fiber.google.com/legal/privacy.html https://fiber.google.com/legal/privacy.html
- yummyfajitas 11y agoMITM attacks. Verizon currently injects tracking headers into HTTP pages. https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2014/11/verizon-x-uidh https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2014/11/verizon-x-uidh A variety of ISP's (Comcast, MTNL, IDEA) also run MITM attacks and inject ads in pages, sometimes on behalf of law enforcement. I imagine they inject tracking as well. https://blog.ryankearney.com/2013/01/comcast-caught-intercepting-and-altering-your-web-traffic/ https://blog.ryankearney.com/2013/01/comcast-caught-intercep... https://medium.com/@sushubh/delhi-police-is-literally-doing-a-mitm-attack-on-all-mtnl-broadband-subscribers-in-delhi-these-days-e26e4d673e50 https://medium.com/@sushubh/delhi-police-is-literally-doing-... Google could either do these things or block others from doing them.
- stephenr 11y agowith your consent - when's the last time you actually read a the terms and conditions of your account? Honestly even if you take that as meaning they won't ever track history of internet access to a google account, why would you assume they need to do that, just to have more information on you? It's not like you escape their privacy invating antics if you just use google search (or a site with google ads) without an account.
- xienze 11y agoWell the problem with info gathered via search, GMail, etc. is that they can only capture info about things that go through their servers. With access to the Internet connection you can gather info about other sites the user visits, when they're typically online, how long they spend playing XBox, etc.
- pdkl95 11y agoWhile they certainly can pull a man-in-the-middle in the cryptographic sense (DJB gave an outstanding talk[1] that discusses this problem), you seem to be assuming a lot. Google doesn't get much data from me at all (spyware like google analytics is blocked at the router, and I started blocking ads before Firefox existed). Even if you ignore that, there is a lot of traffic that Google normally doesn't have access to that they would be able to log as the ISP. They get some of this already when people choose to hand Google their DNS traffic, but being the ISP makes this complete. You may want to also watch Aral Balkan's talk posted just above DJB's at the same URL; he does a better job than I can at describing how Google (and Facebook, etc) are using surveillance-as-a-business-model. > Google Fiber's privacy policy The risk of a national security letter (which the part you quoted includes as an exception) is already enough of a reason to limit how much personal data is in a single database, that's not the main problem. That policy isn't a binding contract. Do you really think it won't be changed the moment someone at Google decides it would be profitable? They promised "Nest" data would stay separate, too, which quickly changed to sharing "limited" data. Sorry, but promises not to snoop don't mean much when the promise contradicts their business model. [1] https://projectbullrun.org/surveillance/2015/video-2015.html#bernstein https://projectbullrun.org/surveillance/2015/video-2015.html...
- IshKebab 11y agoYou are not typical.
- a3n 11y agoJust knowing that I visit the sites that I do is more than google gets now. Although I have a legacy google account, I'm never logged in. I don't use gmail. So the only thing they know about me is when I visit a site displaying their ads. If they were my ISP, they'd know everywhere I go, they'd know who I use for email, they'd know my address and my payment reliability. Probably lots more, I'm not as smart as they are.
- mseebach 11y agoAnd I'm always amazed at the lengths people will go to in pushing the "Google is an ad company" trope. Your argument doesn't make sense, especially not with the rapid migration of traffic to SSL (and no, Google aren't MITM'ing SSL connections). The lifetime value of a single family's worth of ad-eyeballs simply isn't there to justify an undertaking of the size of Fiber. Yes, they are ultimately an ad-company, but that doesn't mean that there is always a single-hop connection between any Google activity and ad revenue. If there's an ad angle here, it's in enabling end users to consume much larger quantities of ad-supported content.
- exelius 11y ago> And I'm always amazed at the lengths people will go to in pushing the "Google is an ad company" trope. When 95% of your revenue comes from ad sales, you're an ad company.
- mseebach 11y agoAnd I conceded as much. But for all its truth, it just doesn't give you a useful analytical framework for reasoning about Google and what they do.
- roymurdock 11y agoAlways a good idea to weigh financials heavily when analyzing a company's strategy. After all, that's what the C-suite and investors are doing. Granted, they have more info than us, the public, but sources of revenue are an important part of the framework for sure. Perhaps it makes more sense that Google is investing in high-cost infrastructure because they want to move away from the ad-model business. It's risky to have 95% of your revenue coming from a single industry. Google can eat a lot of the costs of setting up a better network, which is a great investment in the future if you're betting that a majority of people will need high speed internet access 10-20 years from now. Then they can start extracting monopoly profits just as AT&T, Verizon, Comcast etc. do now.
- 11y ago
- rhino369 11y agoI disagree. I think it's pretty clear that Google fiber is an attempt to create demand for faster residential connections and provide a model for ISPs to do it. If Google wanted to come at Comcast, they'd be gearing up a lot faster than they are. At this point Google Fiber is mostly FttPR-Fiber to the Press Release. And also, I don't think any of the first several Google Fiber locations were even in Comcast territory. So far AT&T and TWC have been their competitors. They want to create demand because Google loves remote computing and loves internet consumption. Google is providing a model for the ISPs by forcing local communities to deregulate their ISP franchising system. Before Google Fiber, each town or state would take a pound of flesh from the new company trying to lay down a network. Google made the cities bend over backwards.
- halviti 11y agoThis is exactly it, and it was their stated intention from the beginning. https://gigaom.com/2010/02/10/google-doesnt-want-to-be-an-isp-it-wants-to-be-a-rabble-rouser/ https://gigaom.com/2010/02/10/google-doesnt-want-to-be-an-is...
- GBond 11y agoI believe this is correct. Google Chrome, Android, & Chromecast (kinda); Google has learned that influencing the lowest controllable tier is worthwhile.
- dublinben 11y agoA press release seems to be all it takes for local incumbents to shape up. Faced with even the threat of competition, AT&T and TWC will pump up their speeds and service in a given area. It's quite transparent.
- dnsbty 11y agoI agree with most of this except for the bit about any of the first locations being in Comcast territory. I'm a Google Fiber subscriber in Provo, UT. Before Google got here I was on Comcast. Our cap was 50 Mbit which wasn't bad, but then when Google came in, Comcast upped that plan to 250 Mbit with no hardware upgrades or anything for the same price which was really nice. The main thing I noticed though is that reliability with Google is a lot higher. My Comcast connection would go down for an hour or two about once a week, but my fiber connection seems to always be fine. As far as cities bending over backwards, Provo definitely did that. We had put in a citywide fiber network using a $40 million bond and then ended up selling it to Google for $1. It was definitely the best move considering the company that had been operating it before defaulted on their payments, but Provo will still be paying for the network for 12 years.