4 ms·
“Given the legal precedents, it’s clear that users have the right to try to block ads,” he said. “But at the same time, publishers have the right to respond, ei
by kwhitefoot 11y ago
“Given the legal precedents, it’s clear that users have the right to try to block ads,” he said. “But at the same time, publishers have the right to respond, either by blocking access to ad-block users, or allowing us to help them serve ads in ways undetectable to ad-blocking software.”
That's a bit like saying that encrypting a DVD is going to prevent someone copying it. If you reveal something to the user you reveal it to the computer too and then it's just an arms race.It would be better to have a functioning micro-payments system.
- maelito 11y ago"It would be better to have a functioning micro-payments system." What's the closest to this at the moment ?
- nothis 11y agoDon't think there's any serious options but check out Google Contributor: https://www.google.com/contributor/welcome/ https://www.google.com/contributor/welcome/
- porsupah 11y agoIt's never really managed to gain much traction, but I've long been fond of Flattr's model: you allocate a monthly budget, and that's then split across all the sites you've flattr'd that month. (If you really liked something, you click more than once, to give them that many more slices of the pie) That way, you know how much you're spending every month, avoiding the tip jar situation where you might wind up donating more than you'd reckoned, and you're able to contribute, even if modestly, to that many more sites than with, say, Patreon.
- nothis 11y ago>It would be better to have a functioning micro-payments system. There's some things that seem inevitable to me. True flat-rate music streaming services was one of those things and we're pretty much there. Moving away from ad-supported websites to a convenient subscription model is the other. I don't think the war against AdBlock can be won. How do you disable a software that simply hides content? Force users to click the ads? Put them into more and more annoying places? We already know the endgame of that and it's shady pop-up orgies. I doubt the New York Times wants to be associated with that. But I also won't pay $10 for every single website I might visit a month (some, maybe, for only an article or two in a link). What we need is a common subscription flat-rate that fairly splits revenue between websites you actually visit. Not sure about the privacy concerns but at least here, the user data wouldn't have to be used for advertising.
- DanielBMarkham 11y agoAgreed. More to the point, it can be argued that if I do not want to consume ads, my browser displaying them means my browser is broken. This entire thing where your attention is hijacked because you have a passing interest in subject X is out of date. Yes, we've had passive ad sponsorship of all kinds of events in times past, but it wasn't a situation where the advertisers monitored your every move and were aggressively interfering with your content consumption. It was a situation where they wanted to be recognized for supporting the content you were consuming. Ads have gone from being passive, supportive, widespread constructs to being aggressive, directive, in-your-business constructs. Not good.
- dhimes 11y agoAlso agree. It's especially broken on mobile, which seems to be the Wild West of grabbing accidental clicks and seedy tracking. I don't mind ads. Trackers need to be outlawed. I'll tell an ad service what kinds of ads I'd like to see if they'd like. I don't want to be tracked though.
- smoe 11y agoI would love to have an option between flat rate and non-expiring prepaid. Let me pay e.g 100$ into an account and subtract some cents for every article I read. Or maybe I'm just weird with my dislike of subscriptions in general:) I'd be happily spending the equivalent of a annual nyt subscription per year but I'm not willing to pay that amount to a sole news site. As it is, everybody tries to do a vendor lock-in while whining that people are not walking into or get out of that trap.
- DanielBMarkham 11y agoInteresting concept: a centralized content micropayment service. You pay in ten bucks a month, a little gets taken out every time you visit various sites. I like it. Not sure how to get enough vendor participation, though. I imagine the way to go would be to pair up with one of the large ad networks -- you could even work it where if you pay, the ads don't come. If you're not in the system, you get ad-ed like everybody else.
- Guthur 11y agoI'm not sure if it's intentional but the DVD copy protection is a some emotive comparison. There are clear laws against copying content without permission, not so with adverts. I am not obliged to sit in front of TV and watch ads during the break, nor when visiting a website unless there is some contractual obligation for me to do so. I have yet to come across a site that tells me I must agree to view the adverts to access the content.
- feld 11y agoI would like to see someone challenge ads and/or ad blocker blockers in court. They're a huge waste of resources especially on mobile: bandwidth, battery life, etc. Bandwidth is very expensive on mobile especially outside the USA. This uninvited use of your resources is stealing. I think you could make the case that all of the resources wasted by visitors is more valuable than the website is generating via ads (or losing from being blocked). There would be many hurdles to cover especially due to all of the technical details (you requested a resource, they just served it) but I think you can argue that when you click a link to an article the user intends to request the article not the junk they're forcing you to have with it. It actually would be nice if Google ranked pages by page size or had some way to tell you what you were in for by clicking on a link in your search results...
- cwyers 11y agoIt's not uninvited, you're requesting the website.
- gadrfgaesgysd 11y agoPerhaps some distinction between domains could be made. The law should/could be interpreted in a way so that a website belongs only on a certain domain. Then access outside of it would be uninvited?
- cwyers 11y agoI mean, I feel like outlawing cross-domain site access in order to shut down online advertising is like burning the house down while you're still inside it to avoid taking out the trash.
- gadrfgaesgysd 11y agoHyperbole. Cookies were banned in European Union, e.i. only made available if the user agrees. Then it is up to the user to white/black list sites. The same could be made for external domains. Most blockers already support that. It is already happening. What we need is merely making it mandatory by law.
- ejcx 11y agoNot necessarily. Browser extension APIs have to provide APIs for the way ads are loaded. For example if they are magically loaded, chrome needs to give you an API to intercept magic. I'm not sure if chrome requests API allows you to block websockets, but maybe it's possible to load ads over websockets and Adblock would be unable to interfere. Even if it is not possible, there's probably a lot of ways to abuse Adblock to make it do a much worse job.
- Vendan 11y agoLoading doesn't matter as much as display does. You pretty much have to alter the DOM to show your ad, and we already have the ability to mess with the DOM.