3 ms·
If billboard advertisers had to pay every person whose life experience is degraded by seeing a billboard for a product they'd never buy I've never found my lif
by mindcrime 11y ago
If billboard advertisers had to pay every person whose life experience is degraded by seeing a billboard for a product they'd never buy
I've never found my life "degraded" by a billboard, even if it was for a product I'd never buy. In fact, some of them are still useful, especially when driving long distances on the Interstate. They're something to break the monotony and give you something to think about, if only for a minute or two. Some are downright funny/amusing, and others at least provoke a "I wonder what that's supposed to mean" reaction.
"cognitive pollution"? That smells suspiciously like bullshit to me.
- Dylan16807 11y agoYou may welcome the billboards, but "cognitive pollution" sounds like a perfectly good description to me. Something that disrupts your focus and is forced on you as part of the environment rather than asked for.
- krapp 11y ago> Something that disrupts your focus and is forced on you as part of the environment rather than asked for. By that definition, anything outside of one's immediate focus and interests is "cognitive pollution." If that's the standard, then it's so vague and subjective as to be nearly useless. As forms of advertising go, I can't think of many which are less disruptive, or easier to simply ignore, than billboards.
- sillysaurus3 11y agoI've been thinking it over. Dang left an agreement, so the premise is worth reconsidering. It seems like the problem was that billboards were a remarkably bad example. A better example might be alternative medicine. It's bullshit because it's mistaken. It's a negative externality because it costs nothing to imply that it works. And it's harmful because it can kill you. Most cases of bullshit aren't as extreme, and I'm trying to think of some better examples of bullshit that won't kill you but will degrade your life. TV comes to mind.
- krapp 11y agoEven tv is a problematic example. It's nothing more or less than a medium, and that medium can vary widely in the quality of what it presents. You could replace it with any other medium (film, radio, books, the internet) and have the same effect. One person's bullshit is another person's popular culture and creative outlet.
- Dylan16807 11y ago> By that definition, anything outside of one's immediate focus and interests is "cognitive pollution." If also has to bring you no value as it acts to distract you. > As forms of advertising go, I can't think of many which are less disruptive, or easier to simply ignore, than billboards. Each billboard is less disruptive, but a hundred can cry for your attention at once.
- mindcrime 11y agoWhy would you say a billboard is any more disruptive than whatever else I'd be looking at if the billboard weren't there? Maybe it's a tree, or a fence, or a cow, or a farm tractor, or just sand and dirt... but when you're driving on the Interstate, at some point you're going to get bored and your eyes are going to wander looking for something to fix on for at least a few seconds, other than the road in front of you. Well, mine do anyway. Maybe I'm abnormal. Anyway, I acknowledge that a lot of people get really worked up over billboards. I just have a hard-time getting excited over that. Maybe there are better examples of this "cognitive pollution". shrug
- veidr 11y agoThere certainly are better examples[1], but I think you are being willfully obtuse. Of course there would be something where the billboard would have been, but advertising is designed, at great expense and with a huge amount of effort, to arrest the attention of the audience. (A significant amount of which is accomplished by being intentionally obnoxious.) [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5766534 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5766534
- mindcrime 11y ago* veidr 1 hour ago There certainly are better examples[1], but I think you are being willfully obtuse.* Please... that kind of thing just lowers the level of discourse for everybody involved. Of course there would be something where the billboard would have been, but advertising is designed, at great expense and with a huge amount of effort, to arrest the attention of the audience. Perhaps it is, and what I'm saying then is that that doesn't bother me. But it's probably a reflection of some ideological / philosophical bias on my part. I've never been up-in-arms about advertising the way some people are. I don't even surf the web with an adblocker installed. Ads are something I see as occasionally beneficial, occasionally Really-Fucking-Annoying, and mostly just ignorable background noise. The only time I find myself drifting into anti-ad rage is when the ads are particularly obnoxious, or repetitive, etc. For example, video/audio ads on a page that start playing with no prompting from the user. That gets on my tits a bit, and that's where I jump on the "end the bullshit" bandwagon somewhat.
- viraptor 11y agoThere are billboards and billboards. It depends on the country, city, culture, etc. how many of them you get. If there are no limits, this is your view on a normal road: http://bi.gazeta.pl/im/ae/8b/d5/z13994926Q,ponad_300tablic_reklamowych_stoi_na_20_km_drogi_miedzy.jpg http://bi.gazeta.pl/im/ae/8b/d5/z13994926Q,ponad_300tablic_r... They're not funny / amusing / thought provoking anymore. They're not even readable or recognisable because there's too many of them. The photo title from the link is "300 billboards on a 20km road". And it's a fairly standard thing in Poland for example.
- Spivak 11y agoRight, but the counterpoint is that, for me, all forms of advertising are negative. I dislike them and would prefer to never see another one again. I'm sure there are plenty of people like me and the problem is that we aren't compensated for the economic harm they cause us. I seem to have no way to signal my demand for such things other than avoiding products and brands that advertise, but my signal is probably misinterpreted by companies thinking they're not advertising enough. Maybe a better term is just negative externality. The masses suffer the negatives while the advertiser and the business paying for the ads receive nearly all the benefits.