4 ms·
It's (relatively) easy to write a GUI that puts all the information in the machine "at your finger tips". What hard and requires GUI designers as well as progr
by joe_the_user 17y ago
It's (relatively) easy to write a GUI that puts all the information in the machine "at your finger tips".
What hard and requires GUI designers as well as programmers, is writing a GUI that puts the relevant information at the users finger tips in a way that's understandable, that users can easily take-in.
Relevant, relevant, relevant! Understandable, understandable, understandable!
These are just two words but implementing them is a hard, cross-discipline problem. What's telling is these consideration often don't even enter programmer's discussions about GUIs.
- wglb 17y agoCuriosity has the better of me: What other GUI puts all the information at your fingertips besides the one noted here?
- joe_the_user 17y agoRegedit and bsh
- blasdel 17y agoAny modern Unix Shell -- just because they're character-addressed doesn't make them not a GUI -- they have interactive screen-level features using curses. If it wouldn't work via teletype, it's a GUI. All of the state information is available via the filesystems (including procfs/sysfs) and environment variables -- on a modern system you don't even need to exec.
- asciilifeform 17y ago> Any modern Unix Shell Can I stop a Unix kernel, view + modify the line of source corresponding exactly to where it halted, and resume?
- wglb 17y agoBy "all the information at your fingertips" i meant the things that Genera can do. So you look in /proc/core and find the bytes, but it won't show you the source that produced that, or even the program. The Unix Shell and curses doesn't cut it.
- j_baker 17y agoTake a look at this stackoverflow question: http://stackoverflow.com/questions/238177/worst-ui-youve-ever-used http://stackoverflow.com/questions/238177/worst-ui-youve-eve... Notice something? Poorly designed UIs tend to cram every bit of information as densely as they can.
- wglb 17y agoAre you saying that the Genera interface is badly designed?
- joe_the_user 17y agoI was only saying that in discussion of Genera, the only argument for Genera's superiority was how much information it presented. I've never Genera's interface but the criteria of amount of information presented seemed a bit off.
- Hexstream 17y ago"It's (relatively) easy to write a GUI that puts all the information in the machine "at your finger tips"." I don't think so. In most cases the relevant information doesn't even have a formal representation (ex: it's "hidden" in turing-complete code) at the application level so it's literally impossible to get at this information unless you rewrite that application. What you need is support from the OS that lets you write "semantics-preserving" programs easily.
- joe_the_user 17y agoWait, you said "relevant information"... Respectfully, let me point that original context of the quote should show I was contrasting merely displaying information with organizing it into some degree of relevance.