4 ms·
I wonder if history will judge the PE business model as being illegitimate. For the moment, it sounds legal, (IANAL) but it also sounds like the corporate syste
by lordnacho 11y ago
I wonder if history will judge the PE business model as being illegitimate. For the moment, it sounds legal, (IANAL) but it also sounds like the corporate system was not meant to be run this way.
In short, what is generally done (and also in this case) is that when you buy a company, you can have the company borrow money, and transfer that money to the PE owner. You can do this because you have good bank connections, and the company is a large going concern that is used to borrowing some money from its lenders. I couldn't just open a company tomorrow and fleece the bank by paying it all to myself.
Our corporate system grew out of the industrial revolution. There was a need to finance large undertakings in a way that wouldn't be ruinous if it went wrong. Gathering a bunch of money from investors wasn't a new idea (various "Indian" trading companies) but limited liability was seen as a necessity for risk taking. During the 1800s a bunch of western countries created the modern forms of the law (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Limited_liability https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Limited_liability).
With the PE type model, you can take over a company, load it with debt, and transfer risk-free money to a parent fund. The company doesn't necessarily go bankrupt, but it's more likely if you take a lot of debt. If the company does well, great. You can take that account statement to your bank and... pile more debt on.
Most people who run a company will not behave like this. The idea is not to have a company that is constantly on the brink, but to pay out some dividends when it's safe to do so.
- walterbell 11y agoThere are also tax benefits, http://dealbook.nytimes.com/2013/04/15/the-top-10-private-equity-loopholes/?_r=0 http://dealbook.nytimes.com/2013/04/15/the-top-10-private-eq... "Right at the core of the private equity business model is taking a company private, loading it up with debt that was used to finance the acquisition and using the interest deductions to shield the portfolio company from tax liability."
- bobcostas55 11y ago>Most people who run a company will not behave like this. No, but companies that are taken over by PE firms are fairly special. In any case, since the fund is forced to sell the company after a few years, they're still interested in LT value maximization. Also, high debt levels aren't just a way of taking back some of the money the fund put in. Debt helps to fix the companies. The PE business model essentially focuses on fixing principal-agent issues (i.e. management working against the best interests of shareholders). Improved governance, high equity ownership by management, and high debt loads are how they do it. "Debt disciplines management" because it forces them to eliminate -NPV projects and increase cash flows.
- jsprogrammer 11y agoDid you take this straight from a PE playbook? Debt is what makes PE (and banks) money. That is why it exists. You think Apax and TPG trashed Hellas because they were interested in making its management "more effective"? Is that why they redeemed 1 billion euros right after the purchase? To reward themselves for all the debt-management value they brought to the company and its employees?
- jsprogrammer 11y agoSorry, "redeemed".
- bobcostas55 11y agoThey bought the company for 1.6b in 2005. They sold the company for 3.4b in 2007. Did this happen because they made its management less effective? Do you think people who spend 3.4b to buy a company are unsophisticated investors?
- hippich 11y agoI would love to read more about it (debt as an instrument to help fix companies.) Do you have links to stories about it?
- charlesdm 11y ago> Most people who run a company will not behave like this. The idea is not to have a company that is constantly on the brink, but to pay out some dividends when it's safe to do so. Dividend recaps (as they're called in PE jargon) are frequently being used by entrepreneurs and/or owners of stable businesses who don't necessarily want to exit but want extra (personal) liquidity. Like anything, it's a tool that can generate great rewards when used properly. Waiting for profits to roll in over many years can be inefficient (from a wealth building PoV) when, for example, the stock market is booming now (but won't be in 3-5 years). It's not because not many people know about this, or use it, that it's a bad idea to use it. PE levels might sometimes be a bit excessive, but it's still a good way to unlock some of your wealth.
- dsr_ 11y agoThe line between this and the classic fraud called a "bust-out" is very thin. A bust-out can take many forms, but the basic idea is that control of a reputable company can be leveraged into an unjustifiable quantity of cash, which then disappears along with the perpetrator. For example, a business might order more than the usual amount of stock from suppliers on credit, take out a commercial loan to cover expansion, and run a huge sale - even below cost - to pull in cash. Then the money and the owner disappear, leaving the business with debt to the suppliers, debt to the bank, and no cash. On an individual scale, the same thing can be done with fraudulent credit accounts: establish a record of repayment, get a big advance, go. Identity theft is useful, since you can use someone else's credit-worthiness. That appears to be equivalent to what's going on in PE.
- jsprogrammer 11y ago>the company is a large going concern that is used to borrowing some money from its lenders That may be more typical (I don't know), but in this case at least, according to the article, Hellas had no prior debt.