5 ms·
It’s probably a myth that we’re sleeping less than we used to
- jwmoz 11y agoI always need more sleep.
- agentultra 11y agoMe too. Father of two young ones.
- jxm262 11y agoMe too! Although, I'd love to try taking a couple weeks where I literally sleep until I can't anymore. Take the first couple days, crash for as long as needed (probably a while) until I'm fully rested, then repeat this daily and see how many hours my body "actually" likes to sleep in it's most natural state. Seems hard to do though when you're working a job, moonlighting projects, life gets in the way, etc..
- afterburner 11y agoThe headline is misleading; the article is talking about research that shows we're sleeping as much as we used to, the "myth" being that we're sleeping less than we used to. We still might not be getting enough sleep, it's just now it seems that might have always been the case.
- akshatrathi 11y agoI wrote the piece. Thanks for the feedback. I see it differently though. If you look at the studies most people are sleeping between seven and nine hours, which is what the little research we have done on sleep says we need. The "myth" is that, as opposed to what the CDC says, the number of people sleeping less than the recommended hours hasn't increased. Thus the myth that most of us are not sleeping enough.
- lighthawk 11y agoThe problem we are having today is people that are overweight. Notice I said overweight and not obese. You don't have to be obese to have sleep problems. Simply getting your weight down enough can often reduce sleep apnea, which increases the quality of sleep. In addition, when we go to sleep matters, and this can vary, depending on the person. Finally, the amount of light, noise, the mattress, pillow, etc. all matter. Don't cheap out, but the most expensive mattress is not guaranteed to be the best. Don't sleep on a couch or an uncomfortable mattress.
- jerf 11y agoIf we have "always" been getting "not enough" sleep, then for sufficiently large definitions of "always" I begin to question the "not enough". The twentieth century saw a lot of poorly-informed scientists second-guessing human body mechanims that have been keeping us alive for millions upon millions of years, on the basis of "studies" that constituted tiny, tiny, tiny, tiny samplings of a horrifically n-dimensional parameter space. I don't think the twentieth century scientists came out of it looking too good even now in 2015 and I expect them to continue to look worse as we learn more. This seems as likely a place as any for them to end up having been wrong.
- basch 11y agoenough probably means optimal not baseline to function adequately
- dang 11y agoOk, we changed the title to make that claim more explicit.
- quinncuatro 11y agoI'm not so sure this is accurate. Speaking entirely anecdotally here, as I haven't done a lot of research on sleep trends. But ever since I saw Inception, I got into lucid dreaming. I only got lucid a handful of times over the years, but in trying to do so I changed my sleeping habits. I get about six hours of sleep every day, but I'm at a point where I fall into REM the minute I'm out. It's supposed to take an hour to fall into the cycle, but I've had cat naps that last about fifteen minutes with a full on dream. Since REM is the part of the cycle where your body rests the most, I feel that if I fall into the cycle sooner rather than later, I can safely shave a few hours off my sleeping time. Just my $.02
- sp332 11y agoNot all dreaming happens during REM sleep, so it's possible that you're not changing your cycle that much but still dreaming more.
- abandonliberty 11y agoSounds interesting. I'm curious about your experiment. What worked, what didn't, and what changes you notice (including potential placebo effects).
- prodmerc 11y agoI've only lucid dreamed once - that was one interesting experience. Usually, I don't remember my dreams at all, and when I do it's some weird stuff :-D. I also have dreams when taking a 20-30 minutes nap during the day, and I can remember them more often. But I still can't go more than a few days sleeping a total of 6 or less hours, I'm just too tired. I need 7 hours at least. What a waste of time... :-)
- jpapon 11y ago> Since REM is the part of the cycle where your body rests the most, I feel that if I fall into the cycle sooner rather than later, I can safely shave a few hours off my sleeping time. That's a pretty big leap to make. If the natural sleep cycle has several stages, it's likely that the other stages are also important.
- matthewrhoden1 11y agoWhen I was single I was really into fitness and as a result also made sure I got plenty of sleep. I would go to be really early to ensure I got the full 8hrs. Once I caught up on my sleep something funny started to happen. I would only sleep about 4 hours, then wake up for 2 hrs in the middle of the night. Then go back to sleep for a few more. Net result being only about 6 hrs of sleep. Anymore, I'm of the opinion that your body knows how much sleep you need. That being on a schedule is almost more important than the specific hourly amount.
- koenigdavidmj 11y ago> Once I caught up on my sleep something funny started to happen. I would only sleep about 4 hours, then wake up for 2 hrs in the middle of the night Some are convinced that this was our sleep pattern before electric lighting was a thing: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Segmented_sleep https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Segmented_sleep
- arawde 11y agoThere's also http://aeon.co/magazine/psychology/why-broken-sleep-is-a-golden-time-for-creativity/ http://aeon.co/magazine/psychology/why-broken-sleep-is-a-gol... which was posted a while back on HN and which I found quite interesting.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- icelancer 11y ago>I would only sleep about 4 hours, then wake up for 2 hrs in the middle of the night. This happens to me 100% of the time when I "go to bed early" and it ruins my day unless I seriously force myself to fall back asleep. I understand this is a "natural" pattern from years past, but it's incredible disruptive. I'm back to setting an alarm and jolting myself awake, which doesn't sound like the best way to do things, but oh well.
- ashark 11y ago
- NumberCruncher 11y agoIt´s probably a myth that a systematic review of X studies, each involving 35 participants on average is better than throwing a d100.
- waxman 11y agoA recently published controlled study found that in two groups who were deliberately exposed to the cold virus then forced to sleep less than 6 hours a night or more than 8 hours, the group that slept less than 6 hours caught colds at a 4.5X greater rate, which was independent of previous immune system strength, age, socio-economic, and every other variable they tracked. The experimental design seems to be pretty solid, and once these findings are replicated, this is pretty strong evidence that "we're not getting enough sleep." http://well.blogs.nytimes.com/2015/09/02/short-sleepers-may-catch-more-colds/ http://well.blogs.nytimes.com/2015/09/02/short-sleepers-may-...
- eterm 11y agoNo, it's evidence that we need more than 6 hours sleep, it's not evidence that we're not getting 6 hours sleep.
- mayoff 11y agoIt's evidence that lack of sleep is unhealthy. It's not evidence that we are (on average) lacking sleep.
- mordocai 11y agoUnless you also show that a majority of people are getting less than 6 hours of sleep a night I don't see how the summary you gave shows that people are not getting enough sleep. I did not read your link.
- obastani 11y agoThe claim made by the article isn't that getting < 8 hours of sleep is bad (they agree it is), it's that most people get 8 hours of sleep; more specifically, that many surveys overestimate the number of people who get too little sleep.
- waxman 11y agoThere are interesting challenges with data collection (and I don't think the survey paper discussed in the OP really solves this problem), but to be clear, somewhere between 10-30% of Americans average fewer than 6 hours of sleep per night, which increases your risk of catching colds by 450%. So getting less sleep than you need is definitely harmful, the questions become: a) how much do we really need, b) how much are people actually getting, and the jury still seems to be out on both of these.
- kyleblarson 11y agoIf I get less than 8 hours of sleep I feel like crap. That's all the evidence I need.
- joshdance 11y agoI don't know why they don't just use the data that is already being collected - https://jawbone.com/blog/circadian-rhythm/ https://jawbone.com/blog/circadian-rhythm/
- dsjoerg 11y agoThat is very cool however this data set has some serious selection bias to contend with.
- lazyant 11y agothey made a study with an NBA team where players used to get about 5 hours of sleep (lots of traveling) and they when to sleep about 7-8 hours and their metrics (free shooting etc) improved quite a bit
- pd1 11y agoSource? That sounds intersting
- gwern 11y ago> Instead of using self-reported data, he wanted objective data—that which is recorded using sleep-monitoring instruments or by observers as participants slept in a lab. Youngstedt’s and his colleagues’ systematic review, published in Sleep Medicine Reviews, took into consideration 168 studies with objective data conducted between 1960 and 2013—involving more than 6,000 participants (understandably a much smaller set than the self-reported surveys) across 15 countries. It too reveals that the total sleep time hasn’t changed much in that period. Why would you consider this as any evidence about whether the general population sleeps more or less? When you participate in a study, you are not making your usual decisions; you're cooperating and will sleep as long as you can or they let you, and there doesn't seem like much reason to expect sleep lab technicians to have gotten more impatient over the years and start rushing in to wake up subjects at hour 7.
- skav 11y agoGood objection, but the article also mentions other sources like time use diaries.