4 ms·
How on earth can you miscalculate something like that by almost an order of magnitude when we have satellite imaging around for decades?
by elorant 11y ago
How on earth can you miscalculate something like that by almost an order of magnitude when we have satellite imaging around for decades?
- mninm 11y agoFrom the article: "satellite observations and ground-based ecological work. The former gives an overall view of where forests do and don’t exist on the Earth’s surface. But the latter goes underneath the canopy to determine how many trees exist in a given area in a given type of forest." It seems that satellites give a good measure of the acreage covered by forests but are not suitable for differentiating individual trees. To do that requires on the ground sampling and as more sampling is done it is being discovered that the actual number of trees differs substantially from previously established estimates.
- hessenwolf 11y agoDoesn't it seem that acreage is more relevant? (I didn't read the article)
- vidarh 11y agoAcreage doesn't tell you how much biomass there is. Imagine a 1m tall shrub with big leaves and not much underneath vs. a dense rainforest where the top canopy extends tens of metres up and there's massive undergrowth. So I guess the answer it depends what you're trying to measure.
- elorant 11y agoSo basically we have no way of counting trees from pictures? I mean it shouldn't be that hard, right? You have green pixels and brown ones. We have software that can discern car license plates in urban environments where you have a gazillion of different colors in the picture. I guess the need never arise for an automated tree counting algorithm.
- vidarh 11y agoYou'll have green pixels in areas covered by shrubs as well as in areas covered by 40m+ trees intertwined with massive undergrowth. I'm sure we can count trees from pictures reasonably well, but we can't count tree mass that's entirely obscured by other objects. To count trees accurately from pictures would require a vast quantity of footage taken from under the canopy.
- pbhjpbhj 11y agoGeneral forest type can probably be determined quite well and I imagine that ecologists have been estimating tree mass of various types of forest for quite some time? Recent developments with laser scanning using drones is likely to improve accuracy too.
- kbutler 11y agoThe whole point of the article is that they've (hopefully) improved the accuracy by using recent developments and combining different types of counts, and that method dramatically increases the count.
- leppr 11y agoDid you even ever set foot in a natural, dense, wild forest? This isn't like in a timber plantation or the park near your home, trees are fighting for light and overlap vertically, and satellite images happen to be two dimensional. Shouldn't be that hard to understand, right?
- benihana 11y ago>So basically we have no way of counting trees from pictures? I mean it shouldn't be that hard, right? Are you a programmer? Have you never had to deal with someone who thinks they're smarter than they are and thinks they know everything get pushy about the simplicity of doing things that are not as simple as they assume? I have, and I can't say I'm a fan of those conversations or the people who initiate them. Your comment feels a lot like that.
- pawelk 11y agoIt's explained in the article. They have combined satellite imagery with observations from underneath the canopy, so they had both the area of forest and tree density in the particular forest. > The scientists were able to reach these estimates by merging together two separate mechanisms for sampling trees — satellite observations and ground-based ecological work. The former gives an overall view of where forests do and don’t exist on the Earth’s surface. But the latter goes underneath the canopy to determine how many trees exist in a given area in a given type of forest. Thus, the study amplified satellite views with no less than 429,775 separate measurements of the density of trees at different locations around the globe.