4 ms·
Two big reasons this article is wrong: 1) The more sophisticated a technology, the poorer a job that government is going to do picking winners. The US Intersta
by joe_the_user 17y ago
Two big reasons this article is wrong:
1) The more sophisticated a technology, the poorer a job that government is going to do picking winners. The US Interstate Highway was an unvarnished success - it is used, well, rather often. The National Information Infrastructure? That was a failure.
2) Paying to create good jobs is worthwhile and concrete infrastructure generates jobs of some reasonable social value. A massive biological program simply couldn't hire enough biologists to put a dent in unemployment. Even concrete infrastructure programs need sophisticated tech too, so it wouldn't all be shovels.
Now, I'd mention that rebuilding the school system would also qualify as basic infrastructure. And that's beyond over-do. Of course, the problem is most reform has gutted actual learning a la no child left behind. Hard to know what to do...
- tptacek 17y agoIsn't the IPv4 internet --- the product of DARPA, run with federal money for decades --- kind of a stark counterexample to that?
- arch_hunter 17y agoYes, the IPv4 internet is a good example of a technology project managed by the federal government that went well. But I think that it is worth pointing out that it was not created and managed by congress (of which I have a very low opinion, I have always had trouble seeing a group of 500 people ever being able to reach a worthwhile decision, especially if they all are also trying to keep thousands of other people happy with their decisions). But was created and managed by the military due to their fear of nuclear war.
- joe_the_user 17y agoNo, sorry, I considered this before my original post. The Internet is not an example of the government picking winners. The Internet was just one of many inventions government research produced through DARPA and many other agencies. IP, a portable protocol that a variety of companies simply picked up, won despite any bets of policy maker, not because of them. The Internet was never the subject of a massive infrastructure funding drive. It was not seen as a technology which would jump-start the economy until people started making money through servers stored in their dorm rooms. No, the boom was not the result of government picking winners here. My argument: Government doing basic research = good. Government picking particular winning technologies = bad.
- tptacek 17y agoSecuring and developing right-of-ways for bulk fiber is also not an example of the government picking winners. I suspect you're being a bit knee-jerk.
- MikeMacMan 17y agoIf all you have are 2 data points for argument #1, then I'll take my chances with the government picking, what, Wifi technology? How hard can that be, and more importantly, how bad could the consequences of picking a 'non-winner' be?