5 ms·
Canada's Economic Slide in Five Charts
- f2f 11y agoIt comes from a very ancient democracy, you see..." "You mean, it comes from a world of lizards?" "No," said Ford, who by this time was a little more rational and coherent than he had been, having finally had the coffee forced down him, "nothing so simple. Nothing anything like so straightforward. On its world, the people are people. The leaders are lizards. The people hate the lizards and the lizards rule the people." "Odd," said Arthur, "I thought you said it was a democracy." "I did," said Ford. "It is." "So," said Arthur, hoping he wasn't sounding ridiculously obtuse, "why don't people get rid of the lizards?" "It honestly doesn't occur to them," said Ford. "They've all got the vote, so they all pretty much assume that the government they've voted in more or less approximates to the government they want." "You mean they actually vote for the lizards?" "Oh yes," said Ford with a shrug, "of course." "But," said Arthur, going for the big one again, "why?" "Because if they didn't vote for a lizard," said Ford, "the wrong lizard might get in. Got any gin?"
- raquo 11y agoI have a laugh every time I read this, but it's not a very good analogy for modern politics. You can't distinguish between good leaders and bad leaders quite as easily as you can distinguish lizards and people. Especially when both kinds spend millions of dollars trying to convince you that they're good and others are bad. Not to mention that this story kinda assumes/implies that people would somehow be better rulers. We didn't get to the current system in a revolution. It's not like it was designed to work well. All the laws that allow things like massive surveillance, civil forfeiture, gerrymandering, lying in official capacity, obvious corporate bribery ("lobbying", what a nice word), self-favorably changing elections rules for the next election – all of this has been created gradually over decades, often by different parties and people, each of whom put self-interest ahead of their duty to the people and walked away from the disaster at a leisurely pace. Given complete lack of accountability of individuals properly positioned in the state machine, we will not see any improvements in how the state works. People everywhere are trained to think "if only we elect the Bernie Sanders of the day, everything will change for the better", then either of the two things happen – a) they get elected and don't fulfill even a tiny fraction of their promises, if not the opposite, or b) they don't get elected ("oh well, let's try again in 4-5 years"). Just to clarify, this is not a call to arms to overthrow the government or anything. It's kinda too late for that to work. And that would be grossly illegal. For some reason.
- mynameishere 11y agoFive mentions of the word "conservative". Zero of "commodities" which, in the form of their crashing prices, is 100 percent of what ails Canada. When Bloomberg decided to publish opinion pieces was there any question it would be nothing but shameless liberal propaganda?
- skylan_q 11y agoI'd say real estate is another ailment here. When Bloomberg decided to publish opinion pieces was there any question it would be nothing but shameless liberal propaganda? That's called "news about Canada". Albertans don't exist, I tell ya!
- empressplay 11y agoIt's funny how Conservatives are quick to point the finger at Liberal social-spending for all of the ills of a country's economy when they're in opposition, but when they're in power and things don't go well it's "all the fault of external forces." Hypocrites.
- Mikeb85 11y agoWe're (Canada, to be clear) one of the richest countries in the world. One of the most educated. One of the most cosmopolitan. So why is it that we're limited to being a petro-state? We live next to the biggest economy in the world, we're their largest trading partner (and vice versa). They're growing ~4% a year and we're in a recession. I don't know about you, but I'd like to think that we could do better. The reason the conservatives are mentioned is that they've been in power for 9 years and there's an election coming up. Their only plan seems to be to deny that there's a problem and hope people believe them...
- raverbashing 11y ago> We're (Canada, to be clear) one of the richest countries in the world. One of the most educated. One of the most cosmopolitan. > So why is it that we're limited to being a petro-state? Yeah, that's for you (the Canadians) to answer. (IMHO) In Canada everybody is very good at doing what they're told, but they're not so good at coming with solutions (I mean, big solutions, not the Stack Overflow kind of solution) by themselves
- skylan_q 11y agoWe've gutted productive jobs in central Canada. The federal gov't should have taken a more direct role in energy policy at least in Ontario.
- z92 11y agoOne has to consider the sharp fall in crude oil price with it. A worse performing government might have shown better graphs had crude oil price been rising.
- derefr 11y agoEven though those charts are framed in economy-neutral terms (positions in global indices, instead of absolute indicators), I still wonder whether setting the comparison year to 2006—right before the beginning of a global recession—has anything to do with the results. Did Canada, perhaps, slip all the way to its current positions in 2007, and then simply not recover? There's no way to tell from the representation used.
- Tiktaalik 11y ago2006 was likely chosen because it was the first year the Conservatives were in power. Noting the 2008 recession as a contributor to Canada's difficulties is a good point to raise though.
- bryanlarsen 11y ago2007 was a relatively good year for Canada. Due to a combination of luck and good regulation, our banks did not need bailouts. So Canada weathered that recession better than our peers. Contrast that with now, where we are the only G7 country in recession.
- skylan_q 11y agohttp://www.cbc.ca/news/business/banks-got-114b-from-governments-during-recession-1.1145997 http://www.cbc.ca/news/business/banks-got-114b-from-governme... Our banks did get bailed out. Even more than the American banks on a per-capita basis.
- nitin_flanker 11y agoWell I am not a Canadian, but this news piece seems like part of the election campaign. In more honest words,a paid news this seems to me.
- jpatokal 11y agoNot just seems: it was witten by the chief speechwriter for the leader of Canada's Liberal Party (= the opposition).
- nitin_flanker 11y agoThat's why. :}
- moonshinefe 11y agoThose are some pretty depressing charts. It's actually somewhat surreal that we pay $0.75CAD to $1 USD these days, since as I recall several years ago the CAD was actually around the same as USD (even higher at one point). Also, let's not forget the terrible domestic policies Harper has had, not just economic. Bill C-51 comes to mind. If you view the Wikipedia page on it, you can see how a couple of deaths loosely related to "terrorism" (just a lone maniac with a gun, really) was used to drum up fear and ram through sweeping new powers to various agencies. All at the expense of the privacy of the average citizen of course. I'll be quite surprised if Harper gains another term. But with 2 left-leaning parties splitting the vote, anything can happen.
- tempestn 11y agoI agree that the charts are unfortunate. (Also with your stance on C-51 FWIW.) I wouldn't necessarily agree that the reduction in the CAD/USD recently is a symptom of poor policy though. For one thing, the CAD has remained more stable compared to most other currencies; it's mostly that the USD has gained, likely due to its status as the 'safe' reserve currency. For another, a lower dollar isn't necessarily objectively 'bad'. Yes, it reduces the Canadian GDP as measured in USD (as per that one chart), but that doesn't necessarily translate into a reduced average quality of life for Canadians. (It's good for some, bad for others, and probably not hugely impactful for most.)
- moonshinefe 11y agoI agree with your points. I guess personally, I just noticed the dollar being low in particular when making online purchases. For instance on eBay, a lot of the listings are often US sellers that are just shipping to Canada. The dollar difference is extremely noticeable when it converts the currency at that point and it's turned me off of buying off eBay as much in recent history. But if you're buying / selling within the country, the prices haven't gone too crazy, you're right.
- tempestn 11y agoOn the flip side, my income comes primarily from online sales and advertising, mostly to US companies, which means a lower CAD is great for me. We're a microcosm of importers vs exporters. Most people probably don't do a lot of either. As for those who do... although increased cost of online purchases must directly affect more people than increased demand and income for exports, when you consider higher-order effects I suspect it could go either way. (Certainly all you ever hear in the news when the dollar moves significantly is how it's good for manufacturers but bad for importers.)
- qCOVET 11y agoI live in Alberta and feeling the pain. In my opinion, the only industry that might be doing well in Canada is lumber (mainly, BC). With high USD, lumber exporters are making good money and with low crude, they spend less on their machinery. The entire service industry in Alberta is in chaos and it impacts the whole country. We were the biggest contributors to the over all GDP and employment growth in Canada. Unfortunately businesses are now putting their equipment up for auction, people are losing their jobs and not sure what might happen next. I am optimistic though - in periods of down turn and recession, people tend to get more entrepreneurial and find ways to bring innovation to their work. For long term prospect, this recession may be helping us in diversifying our portfolio and minimizing our dependency on just one industry.
- desdiv 11y ago>In my opinion, the only industry that might be doing well in Canada is lumber (mainly, BC). I think you're underestimating the strength of the auto industry in Ontario. Canada is actually ahead of UK and France in terms of vehicle production [0]. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_motor_vehicle_production https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_motor_veh...
- qCOVET 11y agooooh .. very interesting. Thanks for that !
- wsh91 11y ago"[The author] was a senior policy analyst for Bloomberg Government and chief speechwriter for the leader of Canada's Liberal Party." Why does this belong on HN, especially given the relatively low resolution of the data being presented (ordinal vs. cardinal)?
- Canada 11y agoBecause the Liberals are trying to win an election against the ruling Conservatives right now.
- lewisl9029 11y agoAs a recent Waterloo grad, I can't help but feel that the tech industry in Canada has been losing a lot of talent to the US, even from our own top schools. Just about everyone I know who's good enough to have offers from US companies have taken the offers and left. And it's not hard to imagine why: the average "highly competitive" salary in Canada is pathetic compared to what you could be making in the US for a similar position. I think Blackberry has been a prime example of a company hit by this. Even with the advantage of being literally next door to the Waterloo campus, most students I know treated it as nothing more than a "safety" in their co-op and grad job search. So in the end, the only students Blackberry ever had access to were the ones who weren't good enough for the US companies, and the few good ones that didn't want to go to the US for what ever reason. I can't see this trend slowing any time soon, unless Canadian companies start offering salaries competitive with companies across the border, rather than just with their other Canadian neighbors.
- Mikeb85 11y agoSo true. Every one of my highly educated family members are in the US. I'm going to be looking at jobs in many parts of the world, most of them not Canada. There's nothing here right now, except sub par wages and ridiculous house prices.
- cylinder 11y agoWhy do people blame governments for these kinds of downturns? The global oil price took a dive. Sure, you want a diversified economy, but Canada has not many comparative advantages other than resources and being adjacent to the US. How do people expect Parliament to just make up successful industries out of thin air? Is there something stopping a Toronto resident from starting the next big fintech startup? Is there something stopping Vancouver residents from starting the next Salesforce? Nope. Comes down to the culture.
- Mikeb85 11y agoIt's part culture, part lack of capital. In the US you can get funding for just about anything. In Canada it's nearly impossible, and investors impose ridiculous terms. Government grants help, but its not enough. As for culture, you're right. Canadians go for the safe, sure bet. Get a job as an accountant or (non-CS) engineer, and enjoy a safe, steady life in the middle class.