8 ms·
I would like to see the US step up its process to accept refugees. Currently it takes 18 to 24 months for refuges to be able to get on a plane the US. The US h
by sschueller 11y ago
I would like to see the US step up its process to accept refugees.
Currently it takes 18 to 24 months for refuges to be able to get on a plane the US. The US has agreed to accept up to 70k refugees yet at this rate it will take for ever while Germany has hundreds of new refuges per day.
[1] http://www.theguardian.com/world/2015/mar/11/us-accept-thousands-syrian-refugees http://www.theguardian.com/world/2015/mar/11/us-accept-thous...
- bpodgursky 11y agoYour comment annoyed me enough that I looked through your history to find > That is what it was for me when I moved to the US from Switzerland. > Only then I realized that the way people live in Switzerland is not something you can take for granted and in the end made me move back. Since you don't live in the US anymore, please stick to trying to influence Swiss policy. Since you aren't going to have to deal with the consequences of a widely expanded US refugee policy.
- 542458 11y agoThat's an ad hominem. Rather than debating the merits of his suggestion, you're attacking his person. Furthermore, it's not unreasonable for people living in one country to have opinions on the policies of others, especially when it's something like taking in refugees which has strong influences on a global scale.
- dropit_sphere 11y agoI don't think ad hominem is necessarily a bad thing in this case; we practice it as a society by not counting votes from 17-yr-olds based not on the merits of their ideas, but their persons. And in this specific case: citizenship and residency ought to give one's voice more weight.
- 542458 11y agoFor sure, but we're not counting votes, we discussing policy. In the case of discussion the goal is to hear many sides and opinions of the merits and drawbacks of an issue. Just like how in an election non-voting minors can still participate in debate, in a discussion of policy I think we should still hear the opinions of others.
- dropit_sphere 11y agoBut was it an opinion? When members of a group discuss policy for that group, they do so under the implicit assumption that their values are similar enough that what they are doing in the conversation is trying to find a way to achieve their shared values. But the great-great-great-grandparent comment was simply a statement of values, not a suggestion of how parties concerned could achieve theirs. I realize the lines are fuzzy: HN is certainly not a 'murican forum for 'murican issues. But its composition is such that neither is it a non-American forum. As such, the greatx3-grandparent could have been more sensitive.
- ManFromUranus 11y agoHe's not attacking his person and it's not ad-hominem, he's saying the guy is basically a moral hazard, he is advocating for policies here that he won't have to suffer the consequences of.
- jacobush 11y agoYou are a MORAL HAZARD. That is not an ad-hominem. But seriously, I thought we all share the same planet and thus share the consequences.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- dragonwriter 11y ago> He's not attacking his person and it's not ad-hominem, he's saying the guy is basically a moral hazard, he is advocating for policies here that he won't have to suffer the consequences of. That is ad hominem -- specifically, ad hominem circumstantial [0] -- and lies at the nexus between the genetic fallacy and appeal to motive. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ad_hominem#Circumstantial https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ad_hominem#Circumstantial
- adaml_623 11y agoThey live on this planet therefore they have to deal with the consequences of "US refugee policy"
- cylinder 11y ago70k per year is hundreds per day. And then there's all the asylum seekers on top of that as well as the massive undocumented migrations across the southern border. If Germany were an island it would do the same kind of processing. There's nothing wrong with examining a person for a year before letting them settle in your country. The system has worked well thus far, why bust it up?
- jacobush 11y agoActually it is quite bad for families to get their lives halted for such a long time. Problem is, they are not examined for a year. They are in queue for a year and then examined a week or something.
- cylinder 11y agoBackground investigations are done as well. Again, I see no problem with it. I thought they were escaping a dangerous situation? It seems they are now in a safe third country, it's not a big deal they have to wait a year. I have many relatives who came to the US this way.
- mrdodge 11y agoHow do you do a background investigation on someone from Syria?
- icebraining 11y agoWell, you can check with your foreign intelligence agencies to see if the person is suspected of any malicious behaviour or connections, and if the person has acquaintances already in the US, you can ask them questions.
- jacobush 11y agoOf course it's better than the alternative and I am sure they are thankful. But a common scenario is, send a family rep, typically the father on the dangerous journey, a person most likely to succeed. This person then in the receiving country applies for permission to get his family over too. By the time everything is done, children may have been without their father for two years. Everyone is getting kind of traumatized from it. I am all for thorough background checks, but at least in my country, they take a long time not because of thorough checks, but because the system is seriously backlogged. Most of the time could be cut if we had more resources allocated to the task. Alas, reality, budgets and stuff gets in the way...
- caseysoftware 11y agoCorrection: Germany is believed to handle thousands per day, just as Hungary has handled more than 2k/day throughout August: http://www.theguardian.com/world/2015/sep/01/trains-of-refugees-reach-germany-as-eu-asylum-checks-collapse http://www.theguardian.com/world/2015/sep/01/trains-of-refug... As a country of 80M people (Germany), they can probably handle quite a few but there's a point when the demographic shift is going to be.. unpleasant. Most immigrants don't leave their old practices behind and in most cases, that's not a big deal. This group of immigrant isn't Christian or areligious (most of Europe is one of the two) and doesn't hold similar views of [choose: women, society, gays, religion, etc, etc], so there already are and will continue to be clashes. Hopefully those groups assimilate into the common German belief/societal structures but history says that with big enough numbers, they won't have to..
- phaer 11y agoA relevant part of "this group", if you talk about refugees from Syria, actually is Christian or secular/atheist. And many of them who are even Muslim actually share a bunch of questionable views of women and gays with conservative German Christians.
- dba7dba 11y agoDid’t think there were enough Germans that are conservative and/or Christian anymore?
- lentil_soup 11y agoNot that that is the whole story but the governing party is called the "Christian Democratic Union of Germany"
- y4mi 11y agoits their name, not their program. the cdu isnt really a christian party anymore, considering how many of their staff are self proclaimed atheists
- mcmalloc 11y agoWe have our own continent to deal with. We already have hundreds of thousands of refugees coming to the US from central/south America every year. How many refugees are we supposed to accept anyway?
- sp332 11y agoAs many as we can?
- hoopd 11y agodefine "can"
- hoopd 11y agoAs usual, a challenge to the drive-by downvoters: answer the question. At what point have we done all we can? We "can" give ourselves as slaves to refugees to make their lives easier but I don't think that's what was meant. So A) where's the line and B) how close are we to that line?
- sp332 11y agoI don't think we're really straining ourselves to handle the amount of refugees we are currently taking. That means, wherever the line is, we're not that close to it.
- hoopd 11y agoBy what measure? If you don't know how to recognize when it's become a problem then it's not meaningful when you say you don't see a problem. What is straining to you? I would describe our education system, our legal system, our prison system and our welfare system as all being currently "strained" so we must have different definitions. (and to the downvoting crew, feel free to explain to me what productive disagreeement looks like, eh?)
- not_your_daddy 11y agoI would like to see you put a bullet in your head swiftly after deleting this cultural Marxist comment. We don't need refugees. They can rot in their own countries. They are useless subhuman animals. If you think you're such a progressive liberal hero open your own fucking home to some Muslim Africans and don't come crying to us when your wife gets gang raped. You are the indoctrined liberal moron destroying first world countries.
- mc32 11y agoI would like all the g8 countries including Russia China and Japan to accept their proportion of refugees. And also work deliberately to resolve the issues affecting the home countries. You can't just standby and hope the violence just miraculously disappears one day. It's going to take military confrontation and there will be casualties but waiting and standing by will result in greater casualties.
- michaelbuddy 11y agoaccept "their portion" as if countries are suddenly responsible for everyone else now. "you can't just stand by" yes I can. Why is it my problem? Oh is that supposed to be the guilt of the first world for cooperating amongst each other and paying taxes, I also HAVE to do all things for all people, even those I dont' like and so does my government with my tax money? Hogwash. The propaganda of we're all "global citizens" sounds great but it doesn't work. You can't sustain a welfare system in 1st world countries when you add the numbers they are talking about here, it doesn't work. And as we know from england and france and sweden, these cultures do NOT mix into their homestay lands all that well. They bring crime with them and they usurp the welfare from the elderly of the host country. They destabilize the economy and hurt the middle class. You can look at this in a small way. Let's say you're neighborhood isn't as nice as the one down the road. You don't just get to move in there, nor do those people suddenly have to make a space for you. And even if your neighborhood in shambles isn't your fault or even if those other people laid off your parents employment, you still don't get to just come in droves and become a resident of their neighborhood and they have to pay for your lifestyle on top of free room and board.
- PopeOfNope 11y agoI would like to see the US step up its process to accept refugees. Why, do you want to see a lot of dead refugees? Because that's where all of this is heading. It'll happen in Europe first, since they have a stronger sense of national identity than most Americans, so we get a preview of what will happen here. Germans have started attacking refugee centers. Anti-immigration political parties are rising in popularity with shocking speed throughout Europe. The Greek and Italian coast guards have quietly started to sink refugee boats coming from Africa. It'll take the US a little longer to get there, but when small town America starts to feel unsafe in their own communities, their reaction will not be peaceful.