4 ms·
Meh. Nest largely created this market, and their product is fine. But since the Nest appeared their competitors have upped their game and in my opinion overtak
by Someone1234 11y ago
Meh.
Nest largely created this market, and their product is fine. But since the Nest appeared their competitors have upped their game and in my opinion overtaken the Nest. For example the "Honeywell Wi-Fi Smart Thermostat," same price as the Nest, arguably easier to use, and doesn't require a third party app or website to get basic things done.
Nest might win awards for simplicity and design, and it is still better than traditional black & white thermostats with push buttons, but it definitely isn't leading the market at this point, in fact I'd argue Nest is sacrificing the user experience for the sake of that design.
I can teach my grandparents to use the Honeywell Smart Thermostat, I cannot say the same about Nest beyond the basics.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoDisagree. I still give the Nest away to family members and friends because of how simple it is to use. Does the Honeywell integrate with your utility to provide you rebates if you use their load shedding program? Does it have AirWave (the nest calculates how long it can keep running a fan over cold coils after shutting the compressor down to keep cooling your home while saving energy)? Does it integrate with Google Now? Does it show you the history of your heating or air conditioning over the last 7 days? Does it have an API you can interface with? My 86 year old Grandmother loves her Nest. If she can use it, anyone can. Nest second place in the market. Puh-lease!
- Someone1234 11y ago> I still give the Nest away to family members and friends because of how simple it is to use. The tap through menus are anything but pleasant. Just watch this video: https://youtu.be/YD3DfoJ3TVw?t=7m24s https://youtu.be/YD3DfoJ3TVw?t=7m24s To use a phone analogy it is like using a Nokia 3100 to write text messages, tap tap tap A, tap tap tap B, tap tap tap C. You have to do this literally in some cases to set the name. Contrast that with this: https://youtu.be/CmvX6YgAqMI?t=1m18s https://youtu.be/CmvX6YgAqMI?t=1m18s To use the phone analogy once again, this is like using an iPhone to write text messages. One is a modern accessible UX not dissimilar from a smartphone, the other is clunky and dated, you're working around limitations of the physical design. > Does the Honeywell integrate with your utility to provide you rebates if you use their load shedding program? Neither the Nest or Honeywell do. > Does it have AirWave, integrate with Google Now, an API It is a thermostat. It might have some of these, but they're beyond the scope of what I expect or would use from either one. It does offer history, most smart thermostats do. > Nest second place in the market. Puh-lease! That's what people said about Blackberry too. I think touchscreen interfaces are a proven technology that consumers love. The Nest could come back from this, they can offer additional product lines that address what their competitors are doing. Some people legitimately do want a minimalist product. There is a real market for that. Others want a straight forward product with an iPad-like UX.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoFrankly, the market will decide. As long as competitors include the right hardware, they can always iterate on software repeatedly. The Nest sales numbers are terribly high compared to Honeywell, and Nest has Google behind it. I wouldn't want to be Honeywell.
- hissworks 11y agoIn my (recent) experience, Honeywell owns the HVAC contractor market, which is where these decisions are being made on installation, repair, and maintenance. Limited sample size but between three furnace + air quotes proposed in August 2015, all three contractors recommended the Honeywell and all three contractors dismissed the Nest as a gimmick with lackluster functionality compared to the Honeywell.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoOver a year ago, Nest was selling 100K thermostats a month: http://www.businessinsider.com/nest-revenue-2014-1 http://www.businessinsider.com/nest-revenue-2014-1
- vnorby 11y agoI worked at Nest on their professional distribution channel for some time. The thermostat market is dominated by professional sales (80-90% are sold and installed by professional HVAC contractors) whereas Nest traditionally sold through to a consumer/DIY audience. Nest has a very steep uphill battle against Honeywell the way Apple has had an uphill battle against Windows in large enterprise. Nest just has more mindshare amongst the tech/early adopter community.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoI don't disagree its an uphill battle. I'm arguing that Google is a cash machine, and Honeywell is not. Google could continue forever trying to push Nest if they wanted to.
- joezydeco 11y agoDoes the Honeywell integrate with your utility to provide you rebates if you use their load shedding program? Are you saying the Nest now has direct integration with utility real-time programs, or is this just a rebate check you get from your utility for buying the setback thermostat?
- ocdtrekkie 11y agoThey actually do. Back when I had a Nest, I got $100 from ComEd for signing up for, and then $40 for keeping signed up all summer, for a program where they could go in and tweak my thermostat up a few degrees during peak load to prevent brownouts.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoAs ocdtrekkie mentioned, yes. When its cheaper for the utility to shed demand rather than spin up peaking plants, they issue a signal to Google/Nest, who then uses a push notification and temporarily shut down air conditioning compressors at utility customers who've signed up for the program. Your house gets a couple of degrees warmer but you get a discount, your utility doesn't need additional generating capacity, and Google charges a fee to run the program.
- jtoberon 11y agoI'm not 100% sure what you mean by utility real-time programs, but yes, this probably is they meant. Nest knows where you live (I don't mean that in a creepy way), and they can help you enroll in what are called "demand response" or "load control" programs in your area. When you enroll, you get an incentive like a bill credit or a free thermostat, and you give the utility permission to turn your AC off for a little while at some point during the summer. Many of these utility programs actively recruit customers, so chances are (a) you'll get a chance to sign up even if you own a different type of connected (e.g. WiFi) thermostat, and (b) the sign up process won't be hard.
- joezydeco 11y agoSome utilities (like ComEd in Chicago) have a real-time program where the price of electricity changes every 5 minutes in response to supply and demand. https://rrtp.comed.com/live-prices/ https://rrtp.comed.com/live-prices/ I was asking if Nest can observe and respond to that data, which it looks like it still cannot.
- fancyketchup 11y agoThat's a silly question. Of course it doesn't have AirWave. AirWave is Nest's trademarked name for the very simple technology of continuing to run the fan a bit after the compressor has switched off. But even old cheap digital thermostats with chicklet keys know to run the fan after turning off the furnace or AC[1]. [1] http://inspectapedia.com/heat/Thermostat_FAN_Switch.php http://inspectapedia.com/heat/Thermostat_FAN_Switch.php
- venomsnake 11y agoThe only thing you really need for a perfect thermostat is a 10GBP PID controller, thermoprobe and SSR. And your Grandma won't even have to use it because it will maintain perfect 22C all year long due to its dual cooling/heating outputs.
- pasbesoin 11y agoIIRC, Honeywell (I'm pretty sure, but it might have been a different major manufacturer) recently had some pretty serious security vulnerabilities with some of their models.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- aaronbrethorst 11y agoHuh, I worked on that thermostat (or a prototype with a similar feature set) at Honeywell in 2003 right after graduating from college. Given how dysfunctional the company seemed to be, I'm not surprised it would take them a decade to ship.