3 ms·
The article is arguing as if Social Darwinism is an accepted theory of business success. Is it really? I don't think so. I followed several of the links the art
by dahart 11y ago
The article is arguing as if Social Darwinism is an accepted theory of business success. Is it really? I don't think so. I followed several of the links the article was using to support the Social Darwinism claim. One only was actually making that claim (inc.com) and it was obvious pseudo-science, it has the wonderful line: "Self-employment income is heritable".
To the people taking offense to this because they didn't start out with a lot of money: the article is talking about probability, not possibility. Just because most entrepreneurs start with some money doesn't mean there is no-one who starts without family financial support. And it's talking about genetics vs financial support, and not about the people who challenge the odds with hard work.
- Terr_ 11y ago> I followed several of the links the article was using to support the Social Darwinism claim. One only was actually making that claim (inc.com) and it was obvious pseudo-science, it has the wonderful line: "Self-employment income is heritable". Your post confuses me, because I think you're lumping two very different -- almost contradictory -- claims together under the vague banner of "Social Darwinism". The inc.com article you are referring to suggests a biological mechanism (DNA molecules and genes), while this article refers to a purely social mechanism ($$$, influence of kin, learned behaviors.)
- dahart 11y agoHave you heard of Social Darwinism before? Its not a term I made up, and you've succinctly identified the exact reason it's so questionable. From Wikipedia: Social Darwinism is a modern name given to various theories of society that emerged in the United Kingdom, North America, and Western Europe in the 1870s, which claim to apply biological concepts of natural selection and survival of the fittest to sociology and politics. You seem to be agreeing with me in pointing out the contradiction between some parts of the article and some of the sources the article used to back up its own claims. It was Aimee Groth that used inc.com to make her points, not me. Aimee's article is inferring biological mechanisms, both through her sources, and directly in the language: “Genes probably matter, as in most things in life, but not much.” "..and found that environmental factors (not genetic) most influenced behavior..." Do you read purely social from those uses of the words "genes" and "genetic"? To me they reflect the biology meanings, or at the very, very least are intentionally conflationary.
- Terr_ 11y ago> the sources the article used to back up its own claims You've got it all backwards: The article is ARGUING AGAINST the inc.com thesis of an "entrepreneurship gene", calling it a myth: > New research out this week [...] found that environmental factors (not genetic) most influenced behavior, pointing to the fact that risk tolerance is conditioned over time (dispelling the myth of an elusive “entrepreneurship gene“).
- dahart 11y agoDisagreeing with inc.com assumes that inc.com's Social Darwinism argument has merit in the first place. You are agreeing with me and making the same point I am.
- ilaksh 11y agoSocial Darwinism is literally the most popular belief system in the US (and many other countries) aside from some Christian morality. It is popular among rich, poor, and in between. Most are thinking to themselves "even though I don't have as many advantages I will still be able to make it some day because deep down I a, special". So that belief system helps rationalize self-worth.
- Retra 11y agoMost people believe they will be successful because failure is not an option to aspire to.