5 ms·
Wait - so TMO monitors your data usage and throttles you down when you exceed your cap on a phone, but doesn't do this for hotspots and trusts the hotspot to po
by joezydeco 11y ago
Wait - so TMO monitors your data usage and throttles you down when you exceed your cap on a phone, but doesn't do this for hotspots and trusts the hotspot to police the data cap?
- StavrosK 11y agoNo, I think the phone sends a certain bit to their servers when you're tethering, to say "this data is from tethering", and they only allow a certain cap for that. These "omg hackers" found a way to prevent that bit from being sent, forcing the carrier to make good on their promise of "unlimited data", which the carrier doesn't want to do.
- joezydeco 11y agoThanks for the clarification. As a TMO subscriber I've never had a problem with TMO's "unlimited data". What's the problem with throttling down once you've hit your cap? You still get data, just at 3G/4G speed and not LTE. IMO if you're pulling that much data from the tower then yeah, you should probably pay up because you're screwing it up for everyone else. This seems like a totally easy problem for TMO to fix, but I wonder why they haven't done it until now.
- wnevets 11y agoyou get 3G/4G speeds when you hit the cap? I've only ever gotten EDGE.
- mmcclure 11y ago> forcing the carrier to make good on their promise of "unlimited data" I'm on the fence about what I think about the announcement itself (because of the implications around enforcement), but this is a pretty untenable argument if you want to get into "promises", or, who's really breaking their contract. Contractually, the promise is unlimited data without tethering. Explicitly. If we want to talk about who's breaking what promises by rooting phones to bypass tethering data limits, it's actually the "omg hackers".
- StavrosK 11y agoHow do they know it's people tethering? How do they know it's not someone just doing all their downloading on the phone and then transferring it to the computer or whatnot? The only clue they have that these people were tethering was that they used 2 TB, but they may just as well have been watching a lot of Netflix on their tablet.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- cwyers 11y agoNetflix on tablets pulls down different data than Netflix on a laptop; if you look at the actual traffic you can probably figure it out pretty quickly.
- jsnell 11y ago> The only clue they have that these people were tethering was that they used 2 TB That's not true, and it's kind of uncharitable of you to assign malice and technical incompetence to T-Mobile. There can be all kinds of differences in the tethered traffic patterns vs. native phone traffic. For example: - Differences in IP TTL of packets - Differences in TCP options, advertised windows, and so on - Differences in packet ordering / RTTs (if you've got interleaved TCP flows one which is terminated at the phone and one which isn't, you'd see the terminated packets being acknowledged sooner) - Differences in the application layer data (for example the user agent field) The people who are camouflaging their tethering would of course try to apply countermeasures against as many things as possible. But if they miss one kind of fingerprint, it could be used to detect the tethering. That'd be the case if it's a signal that'd be hard to deal with by a realtime automated system, but requires some kind of expensive offline analysis.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- drzaiusapelord 11y ago90% sure the work around was to change your user-agent to something that was mobile. That was all the filtering they had in place for a long time. If they detected a desktop user-agent then they'd throttle/stop it.
- MiguelHudnandez 11y agoSo SSL was never throttled? Seems like there's got to be more to it than that. Like a TTL value on the packets?
- ryan-c 11y agoIf you prevent that "this data is from tethering" bit from being set and do nothing else, T-Mobile will block your traffic. They've been slowly ramping up detection of tether hiding for a while now. They at least do UA detection (for HTTP connections) and TTL monitoring. I'm not sure how they plan to deal with the endgame of "everything tunneled through a VPN".
- snuxoll 11y agoThis is incorrect. When you are a 'normal' XGB of high speed data plan your mobile device usage and tethered usage come out of the same bucket, you get 1-5GB (depending on plan) of high-speed data usage, after you hit your limit you are unable to use the Mobile Hotspot feature of your smartphone until your billing cycle rolls over. Unlimited smartphone users are in a different situation, they have "unlimited" un-throttled mobile data usage, and 7GB of Mobile Hotspot usage. To accurately measure Mobile Hotspot data usage, your phone connects to a separate data access point when Mobile Hotspot is turned on - but there are people who are using third-party tethering applications that simply use the 'standard' access point, allowing users on "unlimited" plans to skirt around the 7GB Mobile Hotspot limit. T-Mobile EXPLICITLY advertises the "unlimited" plan only applies to usage ON YOUR PHONE, not on any tethered devices. They have every right to curb people using their service in this fashion.
- joezydeco 11y agoThat makes way more sense, thanks.
- random28345 11y ago> but there are people who are using third-party tethering applications Actually, I think it's more common to simply tell Android to not send tethered data to a special "tethering" APN. Frankly, I bought my phone, I can configure it how I want to, and I see no reason to allow T-Mobile to configure my phone for me.
- snuxoll 11y agoYou can configure your phone however you want, the service provider giving your phone access to their network is within every right to say that you must have it configured within their specifications or you cannot use their service.