4 ms·
> Sleeping-stops kill...If you had a stop to sell if RSP crossed under $70, say, right after the open, your order became a market order, and you could have been
by testerralph 11y ago
> Sleeping-stops kill...If you had a stop to sell if RSP crossed under $70, say, right after the open, your order became a market order, and you could have been executed anywhere in the line of terrible trades.
Is there another mechanism that serves the same purpose as a market order, but that isn't quite so vulnerable to these flash panics? Maybe something like "sell if it stays below $X for more than an hour"? Though I guess that wouldn't save you if the crash really was because of bad news.
- seanhunter 11y agoI used to work on the algo-trading desk of a big brokerage firm (so writing trading algorithms that execute other people's orders for them), and I have to say almost always if someone sends a market order, it would be safer for them if they sent the same thing as an aggressive IOC ("Immediate or Cancel") limit order. The IOC flag gives similar semantics to a market order (in that no portion of your order is going to stay on the book if it's unfilled), but you are guaranteed to execute no worse than the limit you have set. This is clearly way better in situations where the market has big dislocations.
- yummyfajitas 11y agoThe problem with the IOC order is that you have execution risk. I.e. quite possibly your order isn't filled. Then if your favorite stock were to go down and stay down, you would still be holding it. In short there is no perfect "stop loss" order. There is either price risk or execution risk - pick your poison. That said, unlimited price risk and zero execution risk is probably NOT the optimal point to be at.
- secabeen 11y agoI'm not sure about that. If the market is moving in an orderly fashion, and you're trading in a very liquid asset, market orders remove a psychological impediment to trading. For someone who trades 3-5 times a year, doing a limit order requires additional consideration (making sure you're doing the right limit, setting a limit price, etc.) If you just want to buy or sell some stock for reasons totally unrelated to trading, It's rational to accept a tiny risk that the market is going to have a shit fit between when you hit submit and when your order is filled 2 seconds later when the news is quiet. Certainly, I would never put in a market order when the market is operating under circuit-breakers and things are unstable. When things are stable, it can be a reasonable choice for someone transacting in stock who just wants it done so they can get on with other things they have to do.
- kasey_junk 11y agoIf you are trading 3-5 times a year, I'd argue that requiring people to put in the limits on their limit orders would be a good thing. It makes people think about how the market actually works instead of how they hope it works.
- secabeen 11y agoBut what benefit does that actually have? People aren't going to remember this interaction or learn anything, they're just to be annoyed at having to come up with that number. They might even put off the transaction. I would be in favor of restricting the use of market orders by non-professionals during any time a market special rule is in place (circuit breakers, Rule 48, etc.) However, I think allowing them during normal market operation makes transacting easier for investors, which is also a good thing.
- kasey_junk 11y agoIf someone is so annoyed to have to come up with a price that makes their order invalid, I'd argue they should put off the transaction.
- seanhunter 11y agoYes, completely agree. And in fact for my own trading I don't use stops because they introduce downside that isn't there in many other situations. On the quant trading analyses that I have done, adding stops frequently makes performance strictly worse while not helping that much when things get really extremely bad, because of course there is no guarantee of liquidity at your stop level if the market is dropping like a stone. So I've seen things like having a trigger in an order manager that at a certain price will place an aggressive IOC limit order to unwind something. In normal conditions that will behave exactly like an at-market stop loss order, except that in the case of really extreme disruption you won't get filled before your limit. So the hope is in those cases the market will bounce. You don't want to get unwound at any cost on your stop if the market is going to rapidly recover afterwards. It also means there's no information leakage if you're worried about your broker taking advantage of the information in your stop (paranoid, but yes...). As you've said, there's no panacea.
- PaulHoule 11y agoA lot of people think of stop orders as a risk mitigation method but I think in today's markets, stop orders are a bad idea. The only "normal" investors I know who have been hurt by flash crashes are people who use stops.
- dnadig 11y agoA stop with a limit is perfectly fine. It's essentially saying "If the stock trades below X, sell it, but not unless its above Y." So if you bought at 80, its now at 100, and you want to make sure you make some profit, you could put in a stop loss that was at, say, 90/85. So you sell if it goes below 90, but only at better than 85. The issue there is that in a fast moving market, you might not get filled. When the stop triggers, the order "becomes" another limit order in the limit order book, and if the market's already moved bellow your limit, you dont execute. Also, Market Orders are ALWAYS executed before limit orders, even if the limit makes it executable. That's just the priority system of the market.
- minimax 11y agoAlso, Market Orders are ALWAYS executed before limit orders, even if the limit makes it executable. In the continuous market time priority rules. If a marketable limit order arrives before a market order, the limit order executes first.
- harmegido 11y agoThe priority system of which market? There's something like 40+ exchanges where equities trade, each with different rules. There is no "market"
- kasey_junk 11y agoYour question is a touch confused. Are you asking about an alternative to stop orders or to market orders? Stops are overused as a hedging strategy but there aren't really many alternative order types (stop limits are generally less vulnerable but not by much). If you are using stops it should because you've evaluated all your other hedging choices (options, futures, etc) and know they are right even in the face of flashes. As for market orders the generally better choice is a fill or kill order that crosses the book.
- testerralph 11y agoYou're absolutely right. I meant to ask about stop orders and got confused.
- lmm 11y agoThe whole point of a stop-loss order like that is to fire immediately, because it's meant to protect you against crashes. If RSP were to crash down to zero, then an hour after it hit $70 it would be at zero or close to it - the idea is to sell at $70 on the way down before it goes to zero. Really you should buy the thing you actually want - a down-and-in put option struck at $70. But that would cost money, whereas you can do a stop-loss order "for free", so people prefer to do that. IMO these stop-loss orders are bad for the market, people trying to get something for nothing, and if the increasing prevalence of flash crashes gets people to stop using them that will be do bad thing.
- gnaritas 11y ago> The whole point of a stop-loss order like that is to fire immediately, because it's meant to protect you against crashes. Stop losses are meant to exit you from a position, not just protect you from a crash, so it's not at all equivalent to getting a put. People use stops for profit taken when the trade is over or for cutting losses when the trade didn't go their way. It has nothing to do with getting something for free.