8 ms·
Data retention and the end of Australians' digital privacy
- 1971genocide 11y agoI am really happy the Anglo-Saxon World is shooting itself in the foot with technology. I worked for a tech company in the UK who had german clients that produced economical policies that were used by Merkel's Cabinet. It was the same time that the snowden scandals were all over the news and the client flat out told us no amazon, microsoft or american cloud computing platform. It was a pain to find good European cloud providers but as a young 20 year old I was cynically happy - It meant that just like in the cold war - physicist never ran of jobs In my lifetime there wont be a shortage of jobs for programmers. Essentially the world had twice as many physicist ( Soviet and America ). Snowden has been the best thing to happen to the tech world. Finally I can stop making shitty apps to connect to amazon and make my own amazon !
- trengrj 11y agoMy wish is not that the Snowden scandals cause European companies to make shallow clones of American cloud platforms but that libre / free software software and open hardware emerge. I feel this is the path to real privacy and freedom.
- openfuture 11y agoI could not agree more with this. We need to figure out a way of making a more united front in this war. Its crazy how hard it is to reach people regarding the danger of all this surveillance, I feel completely drowned out.
- ZoeZoeBee 11y agoThe people you're trying to inform are incapable of seeing beyond what Big Brother tells them the way things are. Best of luck waking others up
- openfuture 11y agoThat's why the 'we' I was referring to doesn't include them.
- zmmmmm 11y agoThere were three really shocking things about this. Firstly, how little any of the politicians who voted for it understood what it was. Virtually none of them could even define what "meta data" meant, yet were casting judgement on the privacy implications of retaining it. Secondly, how poorly drafted the actual legislation ended up being. Since nobody involved understood it, the law itself is a series of self contradictory statements that make very little sense. At some point they decided to exclude "web browsing history" but nobody obviously knew how on earth to write that in, so it became its own section that overrode the other sections to say that "nothing else in this bill requires retention of anything that could be interpreted to be web browsing history" - despite the fact that the rest of the bill very explicitly details retention of web browsing history. As it stands, the law is unimplementable, and thus what is now happening is that ISPs are going through a process of getting "guidance" which is a euphemism for "since we can't legally operate any more given this law is unimplementable, just tell us what you want and we will do it". Finally, the fact that there was a sudden and inexplicable spike in terrorism raids in the weeks when the bills were debated. There have been almost no raids since, and there were almost no raids before. Yet in those critical weeks, law enforcement just happened to decide that it was timely to execute a bunch of "raids", which have had no material outcome. In other words, law enforcement appears to be transparently corrupt and willing to abuse its powers for political ends. Which means we are very much well on the way to being a police state.
- sillygeese 11y agoPoliticians "not understanding" something is an age-old excuse. They don't even give a fuck about anything besides themselves, because they're psychopaths. They're smart too, because otherwise they wouldn't have managed to climb up the hierarchy of political power to their current positions, what with all the other smart psychopaths jockeying for position along with them. So if it's in a politician's personal interest to vote X on whatever, then he will do so. If it's not, then he won't. It's as simple as that. Understanding has nothing to do with it. It's not like they couldn't get someone to help them understand, if they wanted to. Also, the Australian government (along with any others that can) has been doing the things listed in the article already. They don't need permission from themselves.
- boyter 11y agoAs a voter in Australia I actually wrote and called my representative. The response I received was borderline insulting. At this point I have no choice but civil disobedience or to leave the country. Both of the main parties pushed this through and both are unlikely to ever repeal this law. I'm angry. I feel betrayed by representative democracy. The system is absolutely insane.
- techdragon 11y agoAs an Australian, I'm doing what I can to legally shift my tax burdens to other jurisdictions. I'm hiring more overseas and looking to shift the registration and tax obligations of the corporations I'm involved with to Switzerland.
- contingencies 11y agoYep. OP here. I left the country 15 years ago but care deeply about its downward spiral in to US-style totalitarian anti-democratic corporate hegemony. New Zealand seems to be doing a lot better, though still on the same path. The sad fact is, I feel more free here in China than the US/UK, and it seems to me that Australia's only a little behind those jurisdictions in its rapid descent.
- narrowrail 11y ago>I feel more free here in China than the US/UK It seems a bit hyperbolic to write something like this right when the Chinese economy has been in a tail spin, and the Chinese government has been censoring the press coverage of declining value of public companies (many of which have significant government ownership stakes).
- contingencies 11y agoWell, perhaps I should clarify that it's felt that way for a good while. Likewise, it seems telling that you conflate economy and freedoms.
- 11y ago
- anonymousab 11y agoGrowing pains of the post privacy era.
- lemming 11y agoSadly, I guess Fastmail will now have to change their privacy policy: https://www.fastmail.com/about/privacy.html https://www.fastmail.com/about/privacy.html. They were pretty openly appealing to people worried about surveillance but that will be more difficult for them now.
- brokentube 11y agoNo they don't: http://blog.fastmail.com/2015/04/09/fastmail-is-not-required-to-implement-the-australian-metadata-retention-laws/ http://blog.fastmail.com/2015/04/09/fastmail-is-not-required...
- lemming 11y agoThat's great news, thanks - I hadn't seen that. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10139442 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10139442 is very worrying though and I'm sure that sooner or later the gaps in the law will be plugged since the intention is clearly to catch the likes of Fastmail. The direction that the law in Australia in general is taking is clearly towards more surveillance - Fastmail was top of my list of alternative mail providers, but this will definitely make me think twice even if they're exempt right now.
- hga 11y agoUnless Fastmail is really dumb, and they've not been dumb in the 6 1/2 years I've been using them, they've got contingency plans to move their business (as opposed to their servers, which can't realistically be in Australia with its very expensive connections to the rest of the world) to a better jurisdiction if/when Australia continues to have the 1st World's worst Internet regime. They've already experienced this sort of thing in the 2010-2013 period when Opera in Norway owned the company (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FastMail https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FastMail).
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- ZoeZoeBee 11y agoBefore today, Australia was on my short list of countries to consider moving to, now its on a growing list of countries I'll have nothing to do with. Looks like it might be time to make friends with some Kiwi's
- cloudier 11y agoWhat does your shortlist look like right now?
- ZoeZoeBee 11y agoNew Zealand, Switzerland, Chile
- undefined0 11y agoMines: Switzerland, Czech Republic, maybe some caribbean island or south american country such as paraguay/panama. If PiratePartyIS win the election, they I'll be adding Iceland to the list. I'm suprised that you listed New Zealand considering all the political dirty which came out of the Kim Dotcom scandal.
- ZoeZoeBee 11y agoHe hasn't been extradited from there as far as I know, hell he even set up a political party called the Internet Party last year. The Czech Republic seems pretty cool too. The only reason I left it off my list as a place to reside is its strategic location.
- cbaleanu 11y agoAustralia also has one of the slowest internet in the world, which is a consequence of the Telstra monopoly there. It is just sad data retention happens now, it will only hinder even more future development in the IT sector. I lived there for one and a half years then moved back to Europe, enjoying my 500mbps fiber connection.