4 ms·
Another blatant smear for the benefit of the author's corporate paymaster!
by tedunangst 11y ago
Another blatant smear for the benefit of the author's corporate paymaster!
- PhantomGremlin 11y agoHuh? Is that sarcasm? If not, perhaps you can enlighten us as to the root cause of the problems with the Bolivarian Republic of Venezuela. Please tell me it's Yankee Imperialism. It's always our fault.
- Dylan16807 11y agoYou saw the end of the article, right?
- Natsu 11y agoI assume you mean this part: > Every time I wrote that Chavez was in fact direly mismanaging the economy, diverting investment funds that were needed to maintain oil output into social spending, I knew that I could look forward to receiving angry e-mails and comments accusing me of trying to sabotage his achievements for the benefit of my corporatist paymaster. And in fairness (though without minimizing his appalling authoritarianism), those policies undoubtedly did improve the lives of some incredibly poor people. The problem here is that there's nothing to enlighten anyone not already in the know about who this "paymaster" is. As near as I can tell this is some libertarian journalist publishing an "I told you so" article ("This was predictable. Indeed, many people predicted it, including me [...]"). I assumed that the respondents were saying there was some big, obvious conflict of interest, like a stake in the money made off of their oil. However, Google could not enlighten me as to what that might be and her bio on Wikipedia only lists her working for media outlets, so I'm left in the dark here. I probably wouldn't ever read Bloomberg if it had not appeared on HN.
- Dylan16807 11y agoThat would be a strange, rude and unhelpful way to point out a conflict. It's just poking fun at the politically paranoid that lash out at anyone that points out their mistakes.
- Natsu 11y agoHmm, well, we ended up closer to confusing. I couldn't make sense of your comment at all, not knowing anything at all about this author I assumed there was some reference I was in the dark about.
- Dylan16807 11y agoThe author mentioned nonsense emails calling them a shill because people don't want to accept reality. Someone made a comment just like those emails. Pretty simple. It's already a reference, no reason to assume it's a deeper reference.
- mehwoot 11y agoRead the article.
- PhantomGremlin 11y agoReplying to myself. Sorry about this, guys. I messed up. I've read Megan McArdle off-and-on for years. I am familiar with her writing. So when I read the part that said "angry e-mails ... my corporatist paymaster", I thought "well, of course you will get those". And that was the end of it. My brain was thinking of the messed up situation in Venezuela, and probably just set aside the "paymaster" remarks. And then Ted remarked on exactly those words. My brain wasn't thinking of Megan's lament, it was thinking about Venezuela. That's why Ted's comment seemed out of the blue for me. In retrospect I should have re-read the article to see if I missed anything before I replied to Ted. Once again, sorry.
- igravious 11y agoI really don't think so. I will grant you that it looks like blah blah capitalist ideology versus blah blah socialist ideology with your usual helping of US backyard imperialism and Latin American defiance thrown into the mix. I support wealth distribution in Venezuela. I feel for the people of Venezuela. At the same time I am forced to recognise that the ideals of the regime in Caracas are not translating into a robust economy even though I wish they were. If the level and rate of increase of inflation is as bad as it is being claimed then I really feel for the average person in Venezuela. I have never lived through times of rampant inflation and I hope I never will. I am not an economist but as far as I can tell the only way to generate inflation is buy cranking the printing presses. And I guess that is what is happening in Venezuela. Unless there is some kind of hidden outside pressure that would force the Central Bank to do this? Is that even possible? I thought it might be the case with Zimbabwe, an act of covert economic warfare by the West, but I know of no mechanism.
- matthodan 11y agoAnother way to generate inflation is by increasing the velocity of money in an economy-- i.e. people spending money faster by borrowing more and saving less. Doing so increases the amount of money in the economy, but instead of the source being a printing press it is a bank balance sheet.
- obrero 11y ago> I am forced to recognise that the ideals of the regime in Caracas are not translating into a robust economy even though I wish they were. What about prior to 1999? The people running Venezuela had many decades and centuries to create a "robust economy" in Venezuela. I wasn't seeing constant US headlines about how Venezuelan leaders were mismanaging the economy in those times. Venezuela is being hurt by the same thing hurting every oil producing state - low oil prices. Those in Venezuela who wanted to create a "robust economy" had decades to do so. As soon as power falls from their hands, everything becomes a crisis, they suddenly notice Venezuela lacks a "robust economy". The PSUV has been continually reelected since 1999, they must be doing something right, the people of Venezuela keep putting them into power. Remembering the New York Times editorial page celebrating the coup d'etat against Chavez's elected government, by the head of the Venezuelan business council, who, surrounded by the heads of the military, abolished the parliament, I'm slightly skeptical of the concern of the owners of US media outlets for the economic well-being of the average Venezuelan.