4 ms·
Hm. A monopoly doesn't have to worry about losing business nor employees to the competition. They can squeeze both for the last drop of blood. ATT was a monopo
by JoeAltmaier 11y ago
Hm. A monopoly doesn't have to worry about losing business nor employees to the competition. They can squeeze both for the last drop of blood.
ATT was a monopoly for years. They underpaid, charged for pathetic service, and were inefficient to the nth power. Maybe there was cash to be milked by individuals somewhere in all that. Probably executives. But I'm not sure the rank and file had it cushy.
- TeMPOraL 11y ago> Hm. A monopoly doesn't have to worry about losing business nor employees to the competition. They can squeeze both for the last drop of blood. But then again, they also don't have to worry about competition undercutting them. So it's more likely that they'll stop exploiting their employees at some point, if only because the CEO has conscience. But add in some fierce competition, and silly things like conscience have to go out of the window.
- lhc- 11y agoExcept the stockholders never gain a conscience, and the CEO is beholden to them, so there's no incentive to stop behaving like a sociopath and stop exploiting employees. Time and again evidence has shown that rich companies are never satisfied with being rich; they always want more.
- ethbro 11y agoExactly, but only for publicly listed companies. Private investors still want profit, but hopefully they'd be more interested (because of their larger stakes on average) in less rapacious approaches. Although, now that I think about it, the key metric here is probably growth. As long as a company is growing, if growth >> margin to be reclaimed by being an ass, growth wins. But when growth =< that margin... there's always going to be pressure (aka Google).
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoRight, sure, the competition part. But we have no real conclusion we can make about the monopoly part. They may be kind. They may not. And there's definitely still pressure on them to profit. So I'm thinking, not.
- TheOtherHobbes 11y ago>they'll stop exploiting their employees at some point So far as I know there is absolutely no evidence that this has ever happened. The evidence is all on the opposite side - monopolies become monsters to their workers, to their communities, to their political systems, and to their customers. The only people they don't become monsters to are their owners and shareholders. The most beneficial monopolies are Fordist, because they realise that you need to pay workers enough to grease the wheels of consumption. But the motivation there is still exploitative - it's just pragmatically exploitative, rather than ideologically exploitative.
- jimbokun 11y ago"Maybe there was cash to be milked by individuals somewhere in all that." Like Bell Labs.
- mbucc 11y agoThey created a ton. Transistors, solar cells, lasers, satellites, cell phones, LEDs, UNIX and C all came out of that monopoly. That's an unparalleled track record of technical innovation.
- abalashov 11y agoWith a great deal of government subsidies and grants. Left to own devices, private companies don't do theoretical, long-tail R&D, and you can see this in the fate of Bell Labs under the tutelage of Alcatel-Lucent. Its staff was cut 90% and their projects were subordinated to narrow, short-term commercial objectives with a 3-5 year go-to-market horizon. Such an environment does not churn out transistors, fibre optics and TCP/IP.