9 ms·
Labor board will let more workers bargain with their employer’s employer
- shawnee_ 11y agoThis is such a big win for the temporary / contingent workforce. The reality of the industry perpetuated by companies like Manpower, Kelly Services (Aerotek), Robert Half, Randstad, Adecco, etc. is rapacious and financially harmful to most workers. All the while being unnecessarily expensive (in my analysis) for the clients those workers are sent to. The cut that these companies take from the employees they outsource does not justify the cost they're charging the clients. 50 percent sometimes for doing nothing more than posting a craigslist ad and shoving a contract in the face of some poor, but earnest, immigrant or a down `n out tech worker. [edit typo]
- blisterpeanuts 11y agoHow are the temp companies harming "most workers"? How would you do things differently?
- dalke 11y agoWhile the news article didn't describe the percentage of people "harmed" by using a temp company, it did give examples including the Teamsters / Leadpoint / Browning-Ferris case, it described that it was a non-trivial fraction of people affected, and it explained the rule change for to do things differently. It also linked to the actual decision, at https://www.nlrb.gov/news-outreach/news-story/board-issues-decision-browning-ferris-industries https://www.nlrb.gov/news-outreach/news-story/board-issues-d... , so you can read the full details. That in turn says (emphasis mine): > Consistent with earlier Board decisions, as well as the common law, we will examine how control is manifested in a particular employment relationship. We reject those limiting requirements that the Board has imposed— without foundation in the statute or common law—after Browning-Ferris. We will no longer require that a joint employer not only possess the authority to control employees’ terms and conditions of employment, but also exercise that authority. What more information do you want on the topic, rather than shawnee_'s opinions? I ask because your questions here look like they are meant more to put shawnee_ on the spot than anything else, when shawnee_'s opinions are consistent with that of: > labor advocates and academics who have described an increasingly “fissured” economy, in which whole industries have been built on business models that offer workers few of the protections of a traditional employer relationship. Is it not more useful to look at the broader arguments already presented in the WaPo article?
- blisterpeanuts 11y agoI read the WaPo article and see no financial rationale for forcing this relationship between contractors and commercial organizations. And since when is it wrong to "put someone on the spot" by asking questions? The "increasingly fissured economy" argument is an old one but the solutions are not at all clear. Legislating more lawsuits, forcing contractors and temps into an employee relationship with 3rd parties -- this is a temporary favor to unions and wage-and-benefit advocates but doesn't solve the real problems which are the prohibitive cost basis of hiring full time employees in today's economy in the U.S. I would address the cost basis first, and make it less expensive to hire full timers, and then we'll see more hiring of full timers.
- dalke 11y agoThere's no financial rationale because the case didn't concern financial rationale. This is a question of how to interpret the existing National Labor Relations Act. Thus, your comments make no sense. Regarding "put someone on the spot"; you are veering close to "JAQing off" territory. The question you had were general ones addressed by the article, and here are many easily found sources that would give you the insight you are looking for. Your one line response to shawnee_ did not give any evidence that you understood the context, or cared to do your own research, it had a implicit assumption that a random HN should educate you, a full answer would have required multiple paragraphs, and would unlikely to be correct as HN readers tend to not be aware of labor law. Plus, shawnee_ was clearly expressing an opinion and not trying to make provable statements that can be backed up by the specifics you wanted. Following up as you did is hard to distinguish from sealioning.
- eli_gottlieb 11y ago>the real problems which are the prohibitive cost basis of hiring full time employees in today's economy in the U.S. [citation needed]. What's the above-salary overhead on hiring someone in the USA vs other countries vs the USA at other times when the labor market was tighter?
- spacecowboy_lon 11y agoThe short answer is bad employers of minimum wage McJobs fuck it up for the rest of us.
- blisterpeanuts 11y agoHow so? People complain, on others' behalf, about minwage jobs yet offer no particular solution other than: force the min wage up, causing inflation and unemployment. I'd love to see someone open a McDonalds-like fast food restaurant that paid $20 or $25 per hour, plus decent benefits, and make a profit. If it were possible to do, why can't anyone do it?
- spacecowboy_lon 11y agoIt works like this 1 Bad employers exploit a loop hole to fuck over poor people 2 It becomes a political issue "something must be done" 3 Laws are passed in haste that negatively effect contractors on $1000/day
- dalke 11y agoWhy do you say there's "no particular solution" when the NLRB did offer a particular solution, in the decision linked to by this WaPo article? Moreover, that solution concerns many issues besides wages, including "employment qualifications, work hours, breaks, productivity standards, staffing levels, work rules and performance, the speed of the lines, [and] dismissal." As I suggested elsewhere, it seems like the questions you have can easily be answered by the many articles on this topic, including the WaPo article and the primary references. You instead ask other commenters for answers to your questions, which is unlikely to get you far as most HN readers are 1) not here to educate you and 2) not knowledgeable about labor law and practices. As an example of one of the things which often come up in this discussion, McDonald's in Denmark pays $20/hour. See http://blogs.reuters.com/great-debate/2014/05/15/fight-for-15-try-21/ http://blogs.reuters.com/great-debate/2014/05/15/fight-for-1... or http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2014/05/15/global-mcdonalds-protests_n_5324938.html http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2014/05/15/global-mcdonalds-pr... or http://www.politifact.com/punditfact/statements/2014/sep/03/other-98/can-you-make-45000year-mcdonalds-denmark/ http://www.politifact.com/punditfact/statements/2014/sep/03/... as some of the many articles on the topic. And there are no minimum wage laws in Denmark. Can explain why it is that McDonald's can make a profit in Denmark while paying $20/hour, but (according to you) can't do so in the US?
- Spooky23 11y agoThe isolate the employment relationship from the supervisory relationship. So your boss isn't your boss. In a collective bargaining scenario, they provide a 2nd class workforce not subject to bargaining that weakens the union's bargaining position.
- wheaties 11y agoRobert Half... gave me an intelligence test and then told me, based on my score, they could only pay me 3/4th my thrn salary. Funny because I was already under the 20th percentile on the low end. Leeches.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- swalsh 11y agoI was working for a small temp company when I was just starting. I was hired to do some server work, but ended up developing a system to automate most of it. So my job became more developer. However I was still getting paid as a server admin (and the low end of that to boot). So I asked to get paid more appropriately. After asking they gave me a really small boost, pretty much what you'd expect just as an annual increase. So I went to my manager at the company, said I get paid pretty low here i'm going to think about looking for other opportunities. About an hour later, I had the boost I wanted.
- BJBBB 11y agoFor the low-skill stuff, treading dangerous ground. We had four part-time warehouse workers, each approx $11USD/hr.Did the mundane/grunt stuff. They were not poor employees, but they had no skills not easily replaceable, so managers gave little consideration to their joint demands for increased pay and benefits (not unreasonable requests). But the incremental difference of their demands did make it worthwhile for the boss man to block out several weeks of engineering time to automate. My employer now has ONE par-time warehouse worker. And the result of this was essentially zero stocking error, and I learned pyQT.
- hga 11y agoSo you're saying that the programmers like you and me, but who are cheering this decision on HN, are just coincidentally championing a trend that gets us more highly paid work and puts more of these people out of work? You can't say we suffer from false consciousness WRT to that working class!
- smackfu 11y agoI'm not exactly sure what the moral of this story is.
- sokoloff 11y agoI read it as, "There is some value created by the work someone does. When the value created is capped, and there are on-going demands from the workers to increase pay/benefits/other in excess of the value created, the employer has an incentive to seek a replacement good [in this case automation; in other cases, other employees]"
- s73v3r 11y agoSo you're saying your employer is a giant douche bag.
- BJBBB 11y agoNot certain if this employer is worse than any other small or mid-sized American business. The CEO pays competitively for STEM stuff, and probably at the low end of the scale of less skilled workers. The benefits are much better than similar for the industry sector - so much that we have asked to reduce perks some due to new tax and ACA regulations. Perspective. Company size was approx 125 in 2007, but under 50 today. And the annual volume has returned to 90% of what it was for 2007. Unlike some of our big competitors, the boss has re-invested the increased margin after the recovery in next-gen product dev and an annual bonus system. My employer, to my knowledge, does nothing illegal or immoral, and struggles with 'doing the right thing' vs ensuring company survival.
- pc2g4d 11y agoPerhaps there was a time when they were a necessary check against industrial abuses in an economy with few choices and little opportunity for education, but nowadays unions seem like little but a market distortion extorting (with government support, as from the NLRB) money from the general public and transferring it to special interest groups. Rather than special privileges for unions, I would prefer that workers negotiate contracts as individuals, but that the government or private philanthropy provide a massive subsidy to workers who wish to retrain and move from lower-wage to higher-wage industries.
- dalke 11y agoThe Taft–Hartley Act prohibits unions from carrying out 'jurisdictional strikes, wildcat strikes, solidarity or political strikes, secondary boycotts, secondary and mass picketing, closed shops, and monetary donations by unions to federal political campaigns' (quoting Wikipedia). This is a form of market distortion which takes money from one special interest group (labor) and moving it to another special interest group (employers). If you do not like market distorting laws then you should not like the Taft-Hartley Act, which weakens the power of the unions to maximize the market for the labor they represent. Yet somehow I think you believe that distorting the market in this fashion is correct. Regarding 'negotiate contracts as individuals', do you disagree with the concept of inequality of bargaining power? Quoting from the National Labor Relations Act, which is the relevant US law: > "The inequality of bargaining power between employees who do not possess full freedom of association or actual liberty of contract and employers who are organized in the corporate or other forms of ownership association substantially burdens and affects the flow of commerce, and tends to aggravate recurrent business depressions, by depressing wage rates and the purchasing power of wage earners in industry and by preventing the stabilization of competitive wage rates and working conditions within and between industries." If workers negotiate contracts as individuals, then they are at a disadvantage to employers who, quoting now from Adam Smith's "Wealth of Nations": > ".... being fewer in number, can combine much more easily; and the law, besides, authorizes, or at least does not prohibit their combinations, while it prohibits those of the workmen. We have no acts of parliament against combining to lower the price of work; but many against combining to raise it. In all such disputes the masters can hold out much longer. Finally, a massive government subsidy distorts the market in order that give some special interest groups (employers) free training for their workers. It's curious that you want market distortions that favor employers, but not those which favor labor.