8 ms·
FBI Files on Ray Bradbury (1959)
- arca_vorago 11y agoNo surprise here, the Hoover FBI gathered anything and everything it could, for reasons that are obvious to those who pay attention to this sort of thing. If Hoover were alive and at the FBI now I bet he would be blackmailing NSA leaders for access to their data while giddy as a schoolgirl about how much more dirt he has on people.
- m0v_eax 11y agoWhy are we so hostile to alternate forms of government. :( /U.S. citizen..
- imglorp 11y agoIt seems a natural consequence of any government: after it's installed its primary function shifts from serving the people to be to preserving itself. edit - If this is true, how could one design a government that naturally trends away from self preservation as an emergent phenomena?
- happyscrappy 11y agoWell that and the absolute total failure of communism in every instance.
- AnimalMuppet 11y ago> If this is true, how could one design a government that naturally trends away from self preservation as an emergent phenomena? You need something besides human beings to run the government. That's why we have the emphasis on limited government in the US - the founders understood human nature enough to realize that nobody could be given unchecked power.
- mindslight 11y agoYet they didn't understand systems enough to realize their models would easily precess and we'd end up with the unchecked behemoth we have today. But people are still blinded into believing the government is "limited", making it seem that the current state is manifest behavior rather than overt control.
- AnimalMuppet 11y agoI don't know about that. It took 200 years to get this far, which is actually a significant achievement.
- jerf 11y ago"Yet they didn't understand systems enough to realize their models would easily precess and we'd end up with the unchecked behemoth we have today." [citation needed] A review of the literature will produce a lot of skepticism dating all the way to the beginning (and a bit before) that this could work at all. It is completely ahistorical to believe that the Constitution was written, approved, and everybody involved considered it a perfect work that was certain to stand forever after without challenge. I tend to agree that they may not have forseen the exact ways in which their goals have been subverted, but then, even if they had, I'm not convinced it would have changed much. I mentally run historical simulations in my head (just to be clear about the exact level of reliability you should place in that), and even had, say, the commerce clause included a "No Seriously Only When The Commerce Is Literally Between States, You Should Never Use This For Anything That Is Even Remotely Plausibly Isolated To One State" clause, I don't expect it would have held for much longer. The historical pressures to violate that were strong, and the stronger you make the commerce clause, the only thing that you do is make it more likely that it would be wiped away with an actual amendment. People inevitably get the governments they create for themselves, with a 20-40 year delay on them.
- mindslight 11y agoAnything more than sitting in an anonymous room watching uh, water dry. It's easist to see by doing a rundown of the Bill of Rights and pondering the actual troubles you'd face if you asserted them. Badnarik's constitutional law videos illustrate the process in the context of government affiliates (eg driving/RMV) better than I ever could. Although you have to interpret what he is saying with the goal of finding out how we got to this point, rather than falling into thinking you just need to assert your rights "harder" to regain freedom. The same thing happens with the "private" sector - complexity grows and its effects on the individual remain unregulated because it does not conform to the simplitic base case of "the government" doing something, even when it has formed a de facto government. For example, a person can't exist without paying large rents, which necessitates they go contract for a "job". This then controls what they can do even when not working. Historically this inconsistency was resolved by private behavior staying private, but we're in a time of upset because pervasive communication has changed that. Government applies a hazy justification of "commerce" to regulate absolutely everything. And the constructive behavior of this third "commercial" realm certainly impacts fundamental individual rights. But rather than longstanding "constitutional" rights being applied to the commercial realm, even more complexity is generated as half-baked adaptations are created to address the singular issues of the day. Back to my example of employment, someone can't be fired for being gay but someone else can be fired for wearing a red sweater on Sunday. Everyone dreams of being free of this yoke (eg "FU money") and finds ways to push back in areas that really matter to them. But don't confuse carving out a niche for yourself with addressing the fundamental problem. Not everyone can be a winner, and the trend is for freedom to be further eroded as the world becomes flatter and winners and losers are more pronounced (eg the destruction of cottage industry). I'll forgive "the founders" for not seeing that complexity creates contradictions (especially as they preceeded the explosion of logic and computation that makes this fact painfully apparent), but their ideas should not be considered sacrosanct. Of course this same conclusion can be used to support taking even more rights, and in this climate any constitutional amendment certainly would be doing so. So my argument is to enlighten thoughts and change culture rather than any revising of the constitution.
- protonfish 11y agoFirst off, "we" aren't anything. This was at the height of the cold war vs. the USSR so it is strategic common sense that the government be on the lookout for spies and sympathizers.
- rhino369 11y agoRevolutions are horrific for the common person.
- logfromblammo 11y agoI'm rather hostile to the standard form of government. I certainly wouldn't be better disposed to one that has been tried in practice, and--likely without significance due to very low n and poor experimental controls--demonstrated to be worse by comparison.
- bobcostas55 11y agoIt blows my mind that intelligent people could still be part of the CPUSA in the 50s. It's not like they could play the "well the USSR isn't _real_ communism!" card - for decades the CP had been a blatant Stalin worship cult, controlled and used by the Soviets. We are talking 25 years after the Holodomor was publicized in the West! How could they possibly rationalize this in their minds... This guy wrote Fahrenheit 451 ffs, how could he square the ideas in that book with his support for that regime...
- justizin 11y ago> It blows my mind that intelligent people could still be part of the CPUSA in the 50s. The CPUSA is alive and well, and some intelligent people are probably members of it. Do you long for the times of McCarthyism? This is your actual reaction to this? OK. :)
- bobcostas55 11y ago>Do you long for the times of McCarthyism? McCarthy was a bit overzealous but honestly I don't see the issue with it. Imagine if North Korea had its own party in the US, a party that worshiped Kim Jong-Un, and NK was 100 times larger, and had tons of nukes, and murdered wayyy more people than it does, and had spies at the highest levels of US government. What would you think of the people who belonged to this party? Would you work with them? Trust them with positions of power, authority, or influence?
- angersock 11y agoWhat would you think of the people who belonged to this party? Would you work with them? Trust them with positions of power, authority, or influence? Well, it depends. Are they proposing things and doing a better job than the current turkeys? That's what actually matters--everything else is just branding.
- adekok 11y ago> McCarthy was a bit overzealous but honestly I don't see the issue with it. Some people are unable to learn from the lessons of others. Remind me to turn you in as a communist / whatever in the next round of inquisitions. The accusation doesn't need to be true. It just needs to be seen as "not an issue" by people like you.
- morisy 11y agoOriginal Article/Full file: https://www.muckrock.com/news/archives/2015/aug/24/ray-bradbury-fbi-file/ https://www.muckrock.com/news/archives/2015/aug/24/ray-bradb...