7 ms·
Cancer: Diet ‘cures’ are killing young people, say top oncologist
- jensen123 11y ago"You’ve got all these conspiracy theories that think we’re in cahoots with the drug companies and that’s why we advocate medicine." Yeah. Just a conspiracy theory. Nothing to it. Nothing at all. The pharmaceutical industry has no influence whatsoever. Some people might say that doctors make far more money from doing traditional medicine, than they would from offering dietary advice, but this too has absolutely nothing to do with it. Just another conspiracy theory.
- Texasian 11y agoIf alternative medicine worked, believe me, the pharmaceutical companies would be edging in on that space. If alternate medicine worked, it'd just be medicine.
- ZeroFries 11y agoWhy would they edge in on a space that doesn't make money? In other words, not every medicine is profitable (eg: commonly available herb).
- coldpie 11y agoThere's enough money in alternative medicine that they could fund and publish their own studies to prove it's effective. They haven't.
- fredkbloggs 11y agoDoesn't really seem like they need to. After all, drugs are heavily regulated, and they're not having any trouble selling an unregulated -- and unproven -- substance. Why invite trouble?
- spatulan 11y agoCommonly available herbs like tobacco? Nope, no way any business could make money through a commonly available herb
- DanBC 11y agoHave you seen the billions made by cranks and quacks? Just multi-vitamins is a billion dollar industry and apart from pregnancy or perhaps vitamin D most of the claims are bogus.
- murbard2 11y agoBecause they would sell you pineapple extract for ten times the price, and you'd buy it because it'd be covered by insurance. http://slatestarcodex.com/2014/06/15/fish-now-by-prescription/ http://slatestarcodex.com/2014/06/15/fish-now-by-prescriptio...
- tertius 11y agoAnd they would isolate the effective compounds making a more effective hybrid, claim IP and make a ton of money.
- torgoguys 11y ago>Why would they edge in on a space that doesn't make money? In other words, not every medicine is profitable (eg: commonly available herb). So the companies selling common herbs are doing so at a loss?
- graeham 11y agoImportant additional point - many markets (ie Europe) are cost-driven rather that revenue-driven (America). If alternative 'treatments' worked, there would be a larger push from the cost-driven markets.
- torgoguys 11y agoExactly. Alternative medicine is medicine that is either not proven to work or is "medicine" proven not to work. Should something be sufficiently proven to work, with an appropriate risk/cost/etc vs. benefit ratio, it becomes medicine.
- Karunamon 11y agoI think this ignores the process required to get something "proven to work". Something that involves years, millions of dollars, and an insane amount of bureaucracy. Just publishing a scientifically sound paper in ARXIV isn't enough.
- torgoguys 11y agoNot sure which angle you're taking on this. I could respond if you'd clarify. I'll take a guess though. If you are saying the bar is too high and such treatments will never get enough money to be sufficiently proven, well, then I'd point to the over 2 billion dollars we've poured down the drain funding alternative medicine studies via the National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health (formerly NCCAM). AFAIK Tom Harkin is the main guy who pushed through the creation of the agency and in the past has expressed disappointment (around 2009/2010?) that they haven't been able to demonstrate alternative medicine modalities as being effective. That hasn't led to any defunding of the agency though. It keeps trucking along, spending over $120 million dollars annually demonstrating that things we already have a good idea don't work...still don't work. > involves years, millions of dollars, and an insane amount of bureaucracy. Think about it--20 years, over $2 billion dollars. That's a lot of time and money. They should have results to show for it. Alternative medicine has this image of being "the little guy," and given it is less than 1% of dollars spent on healthcare in the US, it kind of is. However, that small percent is a small percent of a giant, giant, pool of money. While alternative medicine is small compared to medicine, that doesn't mean there isn't a lot of money put towards it.
- torgoguys 11y agoShould have typed "less than 2%." It is over 1%, about 1.5% with the definition NCCIH uses for what is included in alternative medicine.
- jerven 11y agoPharma is in that space. They don't advertise it but they love "alternative" medicine because profit margins are insane. 20 euros for 10 grams of sugar brilliant, and it doesn't even have to work :) What is not to love for the profit driven pharma.
- xlm1717 11y agoIt works... to make money.
- raverbashing 11y agoWell, there's another aspect Exercise, proper diet and losing weight helps with a lot of conditions (high blood pressure, blood sugar levels, sleep apnea, etc) But of course it's easier to prescribe the latest (and non-generic available pills).
- mikeash 11y agoDiet and exercise are great for prevention but not so great for cures. If you want to avoid getting cancer, then leading a healthy lifestyle is an excellent idea. If you actually have cancer, whether because you don't lead a healthy lifestyle or you did but just got unlucky anyway, then it's too late for diet and exercise. They might still help, but what you need at this point is treatment. Pharmaceutical companies may not do prevention so well, but this article is about what happens after prevention fails, at which point you need cures, and every pharma company out there is trying to be the next one to produce a big (and probably expensive) cure.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> Pharmaceutical companies may not do prevention so well, but this article is about what happens after prevention fails, at which point you need cures, and every pharma company out there is trying to be the next one to produce a big (and probably expensive) cure. Pharma companies are a lot bigger on treatments than cures (how much of this is that treatments are easier to find than cures, and how much of it is that cures eliminate their own market and thus make less business sense is a matter of debate.)
- fredkbloggs 11y ago> how much of this is that treatments are easier to find than cures, and how much of it is that cures eliminate their own market and thus make less business sense is a matter of debate Only in the sense that things aren't very easy to find when you aren't looking for them. Otherwise there really isn't much debate. Nothing brings home the bacon like chronic disease.
- 11y ago
- idlewords 11y agoMy experience with oncologists is that they are not in it for the money. There are much less stressful ways of raking in the big bucks in medicine than having to tell a significant proportion of your patients that they are going to die. Note also that if your theory were true, chemotherapy would always be the treatment of choice over radiation. Maybe you have another theory about Big Isotope you'd like to share?
- paul_milovanov 11y agoOncologists are probably right up there with surgeons regarding the toll of their work to their mental health.
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y ago> The pharmaceutical industry has no influence whatsoever. It's not true to say they have no influence. Pharmaceutical companies constantly try to entice doctors to prescribe specific medicines. But most mainstream medicine is backed by hard science. You can go out there and read the evidence. Trials are conducted and we know that, for example, chemotherapy can be effective in treating certain types of cancers, while, for example, Traditional Chinese Medicine is not. We know this because we've studied it, not because we've been bribed. The pharmaceutical industry lobby's power is worrying, it's true. But that doesn't mean that pharmaceuticals are full of shit. > Some people might say that doctors make far more money from doing traditional medicine, than they would from offering dietary advice Actually, "alternative medicine" is incredibly profitable. There's a number of large companies which make massive profits off this stuff. It's incredibly profitable because there's no research involved, no expensive ingredients to source, no testing necessary. You can stick anything you want in a pamphlet or a bottle, and sell it at any price, and people will buy it if you have good enough marketing. You were specifically talking about dietary advice, though. That's also profitable: many people make a very good living off quack dietary advice. People are willing to pay almost anything to get non-"traditional" medicine. Heck, it might be more profitable than prescribing medication, because the pharma company isn't taking a cut!
- steego 11y ago> Yeah. Just a conspiracy theory. Nothing to it. Nothing at all. The pharmaceutical industry has no influence whatsoever. We know the pharmaceutical industry has some influence on what treatments a doctor recommends. I don't think anybody is going to deny that. The part where it gets ridiculous is when people think the pharmaceutical industry has puppet master like control over the entire field of oncology, from research to individual doctors. Somehow, they've managed to manipulate our brightest minds from asking simple questions like, "Can sodium bicarbonate cure cancer?" I have family members who have refused cancer treatments based on these beliefs. One took cinnamon for his cancer and died last year. Another is convinced he's cured his own cancer taking sodium bicarbonate in lieu of early outpatient treatment. > Some people might say that doctors make far more money from doing traditional medicine, than they would from offering dietary advice, but this too has absolutely nothing to do with it. Just another conspiracy theory. This idea is utter shit. Every doctor I've ever gone to has emphasized good diet and exercise as the key to good health. No doctor omits dietary advice so you'll eat like shit and live a sedentary life for the sake of future profits. You could argue that they could/should do more to promote diet/exercise and I'd argue you're wasting your doctor's valuable time. You don't need someone with medical school to dispense advice on diet and exercise on a personal level. See a nutritionist for dietary advice or a physical therapist for an exercise regiment. If you really think diet is a key then you should lobby your representative to subsidize healthy foods and food programs rather than corn based products. If you think exercise is important, than bully your representative to push athletic incentives. For example, mandatory insurance discounts for people who can demonstrate a athletic proficiency on some type of scale. (Remember the athletic tests you took as a kid?) It constantly amazed me that the same people who insinuate hand wavy conspiracies that doctors have sold their integrity and your health and for a modest boost in salary don't even question the ethics of companies that make billions of dollars selling untested "alternative medicines" and "herbal supplements" even after they're caught lacing their products with natural amphetamines so their customers can legitimately claim they feel better.
- linkydinkandyou 11y agoNot just young people. There have been many reports of Steve Jobs not taking the best action for his cancer, preferring to try diet based alternatives first.
- tptacek 11y agoOne of the tricky things here is that there seems to be some promise to metabolic approaches to cancer therapy, at least for some rare cancers --- but because there is no regulatory or financial barrier to entry for people to devise "nutrition therapy" cancer regimes, it's a space that is absolutely overwhelmed by quackery. There is, for instance, some actual research generating interesting findings on ketogenic diets as an intervention for glioblastoma and astrocytoma. Unfortunately, "ketogenic diets" are also a mainstay of Mercola-ism, so it's hard to get good lay-reader summaries of what's going on.
- sarciszewski 11y agoI've been following http://www.ketotic.org http://www.ketotic.org for a while. I attempted the diet but found myself with severe cramps so I ceased. (I live in FL, it's hard to get enough potassium from just meat to offset the amount we sweat.)
- jeremyw 11y agoYes, it's unfortunate the quacks have muddied the waters for ketogenic therapies, but luckily there's enough tantalizing science coupled with a low barrier for self-experimentation (assuming one has a few months+ of relative health) that anyone can attempt it.
- paul_milovanov 11y ago"some promise" is very far from "anywhere close to phase I human trials", so, this is not quite that tricky :) I think a lot of good would come out of: (1) more awareness of Cochrane Collaboration (& donations to) (2) prosecutors and the likes of FDA aggressively pursuing people that lead others to reject life-saving treatment, esp. if conflict of interest is present (e.g book sales) (3) stretch -- teach high school kids basic research evaluation skills (do a search on Google Scholar, consider number of papers, sample sizes, journal quality, author credentials, citations and existence of metastudies). Some version of rough smoke-test for this kind of stuff can probably be automated.
- tptacek 11y ago
- ferrous_pyrite 11y agoEconomics play a large role. Countries with high medical costs tend to have more magical thinking that leads to overuse of "alternative" treatments with no scientific backing and that don't work. Why? It's hard to accept that one is taking an inferior solution due to economic constraint, so people fall into a sort of magical thinking/self-deception that leads them to reject modern medicine. In a society with expensive private health insurance and extremely high medical costs, it makes sense that people would resort to false cures. Of course, it's not always about money. See: Steve Jobs. It tends to take on a life of its own, after a certain point, because the mind-virus that might start due to inaccessibility of care lives on and spreads.
- nisa 11y agoCounter argument: Germany. Free and good public health care with additional private health care that is affordable. Esoteric thinking and homeopathic medicine are extremely common in educated and high income circles outside of STEM fields - basically the middle class loves this. Reasons that are often cited and that I've encountered are mostly due to more personal contact with the practitioner and some fear about big pharma. It's getting so out of hand that a lot of children are not vaccinated - e.g. Berlin Prenzelberg - a place where high income, high educated folks are a majority is a major problem spot. This is something different - at least in Western Europe.
- raverbashing 11y ago> Berlin Prenzelberg I think you mean Prenzlauer Berg (it's a neighborhood) But yeah, similar to the US
- drzaiusapelord 11y agoI've only been to Germany once and I noticed that I couldn't get painkillers I use in the US over the counter. Some are apparently prescription onlyc (at least in typical doses/bottle in the US), but of course homeopathic junk was on display and ready for sale. I suspect if they liberalized their laws then people would just buy Tylenol or whatever and not some herbal remedy. There's a real egg > chicken problem you're ignoring. edit: I was in a supermarket where selling drugs is illegal not a pharmacy, where it is legal. Still my point stands, if you're in pain you'll go with whats easier. Putting up barriers to access is a problem. Tylenol should be at the grocery store, not homeopathic junk. edit2: HN wont let me reply to some comments: I never understood this knee-jerk defense of the nanny state. Most nations don't have a problem with this, but Germany does and that encourages homeopathic nonsense in that culture, to the point of government funding of it. Lets stop making excuses for failed policymakers.
- downandout 11y agoThe most famous case of someone trying to use bunk science to heal their cancer was that of Steve Jobs. He wasn't that young, but like those mentioned in the article, he attempted to use diet and healing crystals to treat cancer that was entirely treatable when first discovered [1]. By the time he realized he was essentially killing himself by refusing treatment, the cancer had spread. [1] http://www.forbes.com/sites/alicegwalton/2011/10/24/steve-jobs-cancer-treatment-regrets/ http://www.forbes.com/sites/alicegwalton/2011/10/24/steve-jo...
- benihana 11y agoBob Marley as well.
- idlewords 11y agoThe five-year survival rate for neuroendocrine pancreatic tumors treated with surgery in the earliest stage is 61%. Jobs lived eight years after diagnosis despite postponing surgery. So I agree with you in spirit, but it's not accurate to say he had a treatable cancer that he allowed to kill him. (source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pancreatic_cancer#Outcomes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pancreatic_cancer#Outcomes)
- 6stringmerc 11y agoHm, I distinctly recall media coverage that there was consensus among several doctors that Jobs would've had the best treatment possible with the likely outcome of remission had he only engaged with the treatment protocol instead of relying on un-proven, hokey reasoning. Also I do recall Jobs ended up getting a new liver in 2009, so I'm pretty sure that prolonged his time on the planet by a pretty significant amount. I remember this because I looked into how he was able to get that liver...sort of like how he was being rebellious and clever to get a new Mercedes Benz every 6 months so legally he wouldn't need a license plate on his car, he managed to get himself on multiple lists and set up residency in a place that would be advantageous to get what he wanted...
- ethbro 11y agoBut at least take the 61% option + all your other remedies then? I'm assuming the 39% failure is "the cancer kills you" and not "the surgery or complications thereof kill you." I would assume the oncologist in OP has less of a problem with people also doing other stuff they believe helps them, vs not including "traditional" (aka scientific) medical procedures that statistically improve their chances of survival.
- n72 11y agoUgh, my girlfriend believes all this crap and to conciliate her I read a book on naturopathic medicine. It was a load of garbage. Who knows, the conclusions in the book may have been correct, however the author just made unfounded assertion after unfounded assertion. Anyway, anyone have any resources on gently trying to steer someone away from this type of thinking?
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y agoCourse in critical thinking? (Though it's very difficult to make people actually use this in decision-making.)
- hiou 11y agoThis is very anecdotal, but in my experience with the people in my life that fall for these cures are very, very concerned with themselves and typically lean toward needing excessive control of everything in their life. It appears to me to stem from an obsession with ones own self/well being that leads to this overthinking. I've had success with trying to steer them into the thinking that they'll probably be just fine and if not, it really isn't as huge of a deal since we're all going to die. On top of that getting sick has a whole lot to do with luck and genetics so they should try to accept that no matter what they do it isn't going to be up to them in most cases anyway. Lastly, I help them focus on the great people around them instead of continuing to dwell on whether or not they have optimum health. Of course, you can't just call them a selfish jerk, but instead try to guide them out of that loop of self obsession.
- user_0001 11y agoGood luck with that. Just nod and learn the phrase "yes dear"
- ethbro 11y agoI've found trying to teach statistics via dice is a good start for people without background. Learning by observing to separate "the last roll" from "my expectations concerning the next roll" is surprisingly powerful and enlightening once they can generalize that into one-off claims.
- 11y ago
- isaaaaah 11y agoTrust is the essence of things going crazy in this field. Who on earth can we trust these days? We dont even know if someone writing a comment on the internet isn't an agent of some company or government. So why should we trust in doctors selling chemotherapy and radiotherapy, while no one, until this day, has fully understood what cancer actually is, where it comes from and admitted that! The internet revealed most secrets about our own systems and how trust is being abused in almost every field. Pharmaindustries will never admit that the human body itself is the only thing in the universe that can heal our illnesses. Healing is a job our body does, not the medicine or a doctor. All drugs and docs can do is improve the conditions for our body to actually heal itself. In the worst case they will just chop that thing off causing you to be ill, and tell you that you've been healed. So why should we trust them anyway? I do not give alot about alternative techniques myself, since most of the time someone just wants to make money or fame with it, but i can see no difference in classical medicine these days. So i still visit a regular doctor, but i question his assumptions and double triple check what he is trying to make me do.
- DanBC 11y agoSome amount of mistrust of doctors is good. An important question to ask a doctor is "what happens if we do nothing? What happens if we do watchful waiting?" Doctors are human and they're subject to cognitive bias, so it's useful to check what they say against the science. But that means using reliable, reputable, sources (eg the Cochrane Collaborations) and not some guy on the Internet making money selling goji berries as a cure for all cancer.
- sandworm101 11y agoLol. I read the headline as 'diets cause cancer', that 'cures' for diets were causing cancer in young people. I expected something about diet pills. There is a great Perry Cox speech out there about a patient eating red peppers to cure cancer. Found it... "Dr. Cox: And now I have to take your laptop from you, as I've deemed you just too darn stupid to use it. You see, those bell peppers that you're munching, they aren't gonna do a truckload of jack against the cancer raging inside of your body. Of course, I've only been a doctor for some twenty years, and the person who wrote that Wikipedia entry also authored the Battlestar Galactica episode guide, so what the heck do I know? But if you feel like living, page me."
- fredkbloggs 11y agoIf physicians want people to stop buying into the conspiracy theories, they should start by ending their acceptance of free samples from the pharmaceutical industry. And while we're at it, they could stop displaying brochures from those companies in their offices, wearing the free lab coats, and so on. Or better yet, stop accepting sales calls from them altogether. And if they wanted this to be effective, they could push to make these ethical conditions part of the requirements for professional society membership and even state licensing. I am sympathetic with the frustrated physician whose patients refuse to accept that there are any benefits to drug treatments. I am also sympathetic with the patient who has spent his entire life hearing nothing but rosy assessments of drugs pumped out by the manufacturers even though many are completely ineffective and many others have been removed from the market because they proved unsafe. There are ways to improve this, but all three parties (as well as the FDA, in the US) are going to have to give. Drugmakers need to stop advertizing their products to patients and physicians. Physicians need to leverage their professional associations to ensure that they are properly informed about new drugs, from impartial sources. Patients need to insist that their physicians follow these guidelines and then trust them, or find a different physician that they can and will trust. And the FDA needs to be at once much more demanding: many drugs are approved despite little evidence, or unreliable evidence, of effectiveness; and much less so: the interminable process of approval needs to be cut way down, especially for drugs that have a narrow base of potential patients. Trust is gone, and needs to be repaired. You build or rebuild trust by being trustworthy, going far out of your way not only to show that you are worthy but to go well beyond what would otherwise be necessary. If you want patients to trust you, you need to do everything possible to earn it.
- jeo1234 11y agoIf you ran a pharma company and had a new drug which helped reversed alzheimer's, which methods would you use to promote it? Target the patients, hospital admin, government officials? Or would it make more sense to talk with people who are trained in that field and deal with the people who will be impacted the most? Yes there are many cases of people being over-prescribed, and drugs being approved with debatable benefits, but communication between pharma and doctors can be very helpful. Given proper oversight of course.
- Kluny 11y agoI'm not at all surprised at this based on my friends and I's experience with the medical profession. If we go in for anything more subtle than a broken leg, it's very difficult to get a busy doctor to pay attention to what you're telling them or send you for testing. It becomes so frustrating that you end up turning to the internet and trying things like food cures, just because it's all you can do. I'm gradually learning to be more assertive with the doctor, even going so far as to take my mom along for moral support (pretty embarrassed about that but sometimes that's what it takes). But I've given up plenty of times in the past when I had various kinds of muscle and tendon injuries that made it difficult to work. I usually ended up self treating with stretches, ice, expensive trips to physiotherapists and chiros, just on the wild guess that maybe they might be able to help when my doctor refuses to. I have no doubt that if I had any weird cancer-like symptoms I'd try to self-treat for a good long time before I bothered taking a day off work to see a doctor. Doctors suck.