3 ms·
Quoting out of context like that it sure seems pretty absurd. But I'm going to trust you understood GP's point? Any sane person wouldn't presume to thing for t
by andrepd 11y ago
Quoting out of context like that it sure seems pretty absurd. But I'm going to trust you understood GP's point?
Any sane person wouldn't presume to thing for themselves on the best course of action in treating their cancer, for instance. The same thing goes for nutrition and health.
- 5h 11y agoOf course, I understand the parent post's point & the hazards of quoting out of context, it's just an amusing fragment. Talking of context though, I think any individual is capable of thinking for themselves when it comes to how much water a day to drink.
- dekhn 11y agoAs the GP you're referring to: I'm a PhD scientist with deep knowledge in biology. I still wouldn't try to decide for myself on how to treat my own cancer; I can use my knowledge to evaluate what the experts tell me, but there are limits that even a knowledgeable scientist is susceptible to. Many people think otherwise: they second guess medical experts using their own engineering or scientific knowledge. Sometimes this "seems to work" but it's not clear that it does so in anything but an anecdotal way. Carefully controlled trials and meta-studies are much more effective.