4 ms·
Are we all experts who are capable of thinking for ourselves ("thinking for ourselves" seems to equal: inspecting the primary literature, or review literature,
by dekhn 11y ago
Are we all experts who are capable of thinking for ourselves ("thinking for ourselves" seems to equal: inspecting the primary literature, or review literature, and coming to a conclusion)? No, we're not.
Thinking for yourself is untenable- we need scientists who are experts in analyzing data to provide specific suggestions, and disseminate those in the media. Unfortunately, there is little consequence to reporting false conclusions, or inaccurate health data, so I don't see any change forthcoming.
- mdpopescu 11y agoOut of curiosity, do you realize that the same thing can be said about religion? You don't know enough about it - definitely not as much as the people who specialize in it - so you should listen to your priest on the subject. Or politics: just pick a party and follow its lead, politics is a complex subject and you can't know as much as the professionals.
- andrepd 11y agoIt definitely is so. What authority do I have to talk about economics or law? Shouldn't I leave that to the people who do know what they are talking about? Kind of a central problem in democracy, if you think about it.
- dubya 11y agoProtestants, at least, have the idea of the "priesthood of all believers", meaning roughly that each person can have authority in doctrinal matters. So you should listen to your priest, but you don't have to accept that he's correct if God is telling you something different. Thus the billion different protestant denominations.
- zaphar 11y agoProtestants if you go back to their roots actually expected you to become an expert in scripture in order to recognize when your "priest" is wrong. But they didn't promote anything goes. It's more that you should learn and be able to apply scripture correctly. This didn't prevent the proliferation of denominations because of course different people would interpret a piece of scripture differently and get really worked up about it.
- yellowapple 11y agoThis is in contrast with Catholicism, where pretty much everything was conducted in Latin rather than local languages; the emphasis on layperson understanding of theology was a direct response to the trend of most followers having zero understanding or ability to understand the scriptures and sermons they were expected to follow. Of course, this also resulted in the more decentralized power structure relative to Catholicism's. Quite a bit of Protestant philosophy and tendency stems from immediate responses to a perceived-to-be corrupt and exclusive Catholic Church.
- richmarr 11y agoI'm sure you're right, but what domain of knowledge is religion expert in?
- savanaly 11y agoI would say that nutrition falls somewhere between religion - where the facts are all made up - and, say, math or physics where we're pretty damn sure the scientists aren't making all the facts up. But it definitely leans towards the scientific side where real facts can be known and people who devoted decades of their life to it have a tangible advantage over the layman when evaluating claims about it. I respect a theological scholar or priest's mastery of their religion in the same was as I would respect an ardent nerd's mastery of Tolkein's universe, which is to say it is real respect for studying at length a somewhat internally consistent system of mythology. But no matter how much more that nerd knows about mythology I wouldn't trust his word about how Middle Earth actually existed at some point in the earth's history. As for politics...well that's a huge can of worms isn't it? I would mention that it's not a politician's job to know about politics, but it's their job to get elected and accrue power. A better analogy for you to make might have been political scientist, in which case I would indeed trust their judgement over my own gut feel when it comes to questions about politics like why so-and-so won the election.
- 5h 11y ago> "Thinking for yourself is untenable" Well, that's the best thing I've read all day.
- paulojreis 11y agoIt might hurt to read that because it pinches on the untouchable tenets, I mean, who dares to admit not being a individual free-thinker? However, if you look behind the "smokes, you'll see he has a point. I proudly admit that I wouldn't think for myself on situations such as choosing a complex therapy. I know nothing about it; what would I do? Trust the Internet?
- arpa 11y agoWell the research has shown [too lazy to come up with a citation for that] that it is very beneficial for patients to be well informed and involved in the therapy process - with healthcare professional as an equal partner, not as a "god" in the matters of health. It's called "patient empowerment" and it's a big thing since 1994. And one of the best ways to inform the patient is a decision aid (which is ranging from fliers to IT systems with semantic webs with auto-updating medical evidence sources). This works, because you don't have to an expert on athletes' foot to manage your diabetes well, you just have to be an "expert" of your own case. And that, my friend, is the definition of individual free-thinker.
- paulojreis 11y ago> Well the research has shown [too lazy to come up with a citation for that] that it is very beneficial for patients to be well informed and involved in the therapy process That's an irrelevant point: You won't see me advocating against having the patients fully informed and making decisions, after being given "alternatives" and respective pros&cons by their physicians. But what I was discussing was the knee-jerk reaction to the "thinking for yourself is untenable" argument. > This works, because you don't have to an expert on athletes' foot to manage your diabetes well, you just have to be an "expert" of your own case. I would say it's very oblivious to think you're an expert on your case. It means your emotions are way too much present: the fact that something is terribly relevant to you doesn't imply that you're an "expert" in it. > And that, my friend, is the definition of individual free-thinker. Quite a strange definition. But OK: if that's a very important point for you to make, great. Just don't say that this is "thinking by yourself". You may have made the decision yourself, but the "thinking" part was on the physician all the time. He had the knowledge, he presented it to you, alongside the pros&cons, and he was there to warn you if you by chance made a wrong/worst decision.
- ChrisArgyle 11y agoPublishing misleading health studies wouldn't be so risk-free if your average American could easily distinguish a legitimate expert opinion from a media/commercial one. Unfortunately most Americans don't have access to a quality health education necessary to make that distinction.
- dekhn 11y agoI disagree. We have ample evidence that legitimate experts came to the wrong conclusion (for example, studies of the relationship of cholesterol to heart health). What we need to systematic meta-studies that are analyzed and published by geniuses (see the Cochrane Collaboration).