3 ms·
Who said anything about the US or Wall Street? You're making the classic logic mistake of assuming because I said X, I also must be implying Y.
by adventured 11y ago
Who said anything about the US or Wall Street?
You're making the classic logic mistake of assuming because I said X, I also must be implying Y.
- coldtea 11y agoWhen one criticizes X (and only X), then -X which might be equally bad gets scot free. That's no logical error, it's a fact (that nothing is said of -X). So either one does an exhaustive critique of all classes of X, or his critique implicitly favors one of them (it's like if one's two kids do a similar bad thing and he only scolds one of them). My argument was just trying to bring some counter-balance (to have the -X items people consider as "opposite" to the class of X you criticized, judged too).
- meric 11y agoThe U.S. Economy is to a smaller extent a command economy due to central bank control of currency and interest rates, so it's not 'unlike the U.S..' If he'd talk about the U.S., it'd be 'like the U.S.'.