6 ms·
Roots? The reasons behind the design have all fallen by the wayside. The need to keep weight over the rear tires to increase traction was killed off long ago
by sandworm101 11y ago
Roots? The reasons behind the design have all fallen by the wayside.
The need to keep weight over the rear tires to increase traction was killed off long ago by increases in tire performance and the development of limited-slip differentials. Design and market changes have rendered the once functional shape purely aesthetic. Today's cars are neither fuel-efficient nor speed daemons. And the engines are water-cooled. So the aerodynamic shape has lost it's function. If it is holding true to its mechanical roots, those roots are long dead.
So what's left? From a mechanical point of view it is a rear-engine car fighting to become mid-engined without admitting the change. The shape's only function is aesthetic. Anyone claiming its shape or design layout is mechanically relevant comes off like those poodle owners who insist the silly haircuts are to keep the dog warm while swimming. If you like the look then you like the look. Don't try to justify your taste with engineering gobbledygook.
- aidenn0 11y agoSince you seem to know a lot about rear-engine cars, perhaps you can clear something up. I've often seen air-cooling listed along with what you did as benefiting more than water-cooling in a rear-engine layout, but that never made any sense to me. Is this a myth, or is there any sense to it?
- sandworm101 11y agoAn air-cooled engine willing to run at much hotter temperatures doesn't need, cannot use, a big drag-creating radiator at the front of the car. But once you put the engine in the back, there are all manner of advantages. You can get rid of the driveshaft (weight) lower the hood (visibility) and be more creative with shape (aero). For Porsche it was all about reducing drag. The original even had covered wheels. http://buildraceparty.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/06/Porsche_356_debuts_at_Le_Mans_first_race_1951.jpg http://buildraceparty.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/06/Porsche...
- bch 11y ago> An air-cooled engine willing to run at much hotter temperatures... Are they "willing to run at a higher temperature?" I feel you're begging the question, but I'd be delighted to be shown I'm wrong. The engine has cooling requirements, and they're met by careful ducting and a fan that the engine runs directly, or indirectly. VW Beetles and early buses ran a fan off a generator or alternator via a belt from the engine, and VW type 3 and 4 engines (and at least later, if not all air-cooled Porsche 911s, (and 912s?)) are run off the engine crank. The engine needs to be cooled, needs airflow (ask a knowledgeable BMW airhead motorcycle owner). So, "why not put then engine up front" could be answered with "we've contained all cooling requirements in the engine itself, so we put it where we want." As I read more about this there are lots of interesting considerations[0] but I don't see "willing to run at a higher temperature" as a consideration, yet. [0] "Internal combustion engine cooling" on @Wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internal_combustion_engine_cooling?wprov=sfia1 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internal_combustion_engine_coo... Edit: s/chilling/cooling/
- sandworm101 11y agoIf you want to get all definitional, then one might say the porsche/VW were also liquid-cooled. They had oil which did move some heat around. So the line is really whether or not the engine has a separate cooling loop, usually filled with water. There are a couple different temperatures to speak of. There is the overall engine temp, which may well be very similar to a modern engine. But there is also the temperature of the cylinder walls deep inside. An air-cooled engine relies on metal to conduct heat away from the heart of the engine. A water-cooled engine puts a pipe of cold water right alongside the cylinders to physically move heat away. So the internals of an air-cooled engine go through a much wider temperature range during normal operation. With differential metals that means gaps... gaps between the cylinder wall and the piston. That in turn means increased wear and emission-related problems. An air-cooled engine is willing to suffer these issues for the advantage of decreased weight and complexity. An air-cooled engine not willing to suffer this internal heating would be a very slow and heavy engine. Having a hotter cylinder wall can also impact choice of fuels (need higher octane) and compression ratios (need less) as the hot walls might ignite things before the spark.
- brc 11y agoYou eliminate weight and complexity by using air cooling. No water pumps, radiators, expansion tanks and ~6-10 L of coolant. The water pumps use power from the engine, the casting of the water jackets results in a heavier engine, and the radiator and coolant all add weight. In the case of a rear engined car, eliminating water cooling helps even more because of the need to transport the coolant all the way to the front and back again. Mind you, Porsche eventually accepted this compromise, and to be fair, they were already doing it for oil lines.
- bliti 11y agoAbsolutely. Porsche's own Cayman shows what the 911 should be (although in a bit smaller package). But purists demand the 911 to only be updated, not re-designed. It is their halo car and won't change it. Still, even though the design is now obsolete, the cars are still wonderful. One can jump from 911s of various eras and notice the improvements. If you drive a 930 (911 Turbo from 1975 to 1989 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Porsche_930 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Porsche_930) and then drive a 993 Turbo (911 Turbo from 1996 to 1998 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Porsche_993 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Porsche_993) you can feel the difference. The 930 is crude and unforgiving. With turbo lag measured in seconds. I remember counting to three before the turbo kicked in and slammed me into the seat back. Driving it requires cojones because the rear of the car will go around if you lift or break mid-corner. Its not a car for the faint of heart. Now, the 993 Turbo is a tamed sheep when compared to the 930. It features a coil spring suspension in the rear that absorbs bumps much better than the torsion bar version found on the 930. The 993 Turbo is a four wheel drive vehicle. The system does wonders for its driving dynamics. You still shouldn't lift or brake mid-corner, but now the car is more forgiving since the front tires are desperately trying to carve into the road. I've personally taken corners at around 90MPH on a 993 Turbo (racetrack driving) and the car inspires confidence. If you are looking to buy a Porsche make sure to figure out what you want to do with it. if you are just going baby it and admire it with a beverage of your choice in hand then any version is fine. If you plan to drive it on a daily basis then a newer model is required (the A/C on the air cooled versions down right sucks). Performance driving? Anything from the 1999 and forward will do because its a much better chassis. Racing? Get yourself whatever GT3 (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Porsche_911_GT3 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Porsche_911_GT3) you can afford. All of the above? Then buy a newer model. Turbo or no turbo, that is the question. Turbo models require more maintenance and leak more oil than regular ones (all Porsches leak oil). The power delivery depends on the year you buy, but on newer models its pretty good. The problem with the turbo is that you can easily add in more power by raising the boost (increasing the amount of air being forced into the engine). But this requires the amount of fuel to be increased as well. You can safely increase boost by a couple of pounds, but once you want to really get serious, multiple upgrades must be made. Including the transmission, clutch, wheels, and lots of support equipment. Its not unheard of to spend about twenty thousand dollars on simple upgrades. A friend has about two hundred thousand on his (800HP beast of a car). It all depends on how deep your pockets are.
- brisance 11y agoAgreed. Another factor for the transition to water-cooled was because horsepower sells cars. Put simply it's thermodynamics: there's only so much heat an air-cooled engine can dissipate before it self-destructs.
- ChuckMcM 11y agoTrue (heat kills engines) but of course heat is a function of efficiency, how much of the energy in the gasoline is converted into mechanical energy versus the amount of energy consumed. So more efficient engines heat can deliver the same horse power with less heat, or more horse power with the same heat.
- bradleyland 11y agoThat's true, but there are hard limits to the heat conversion efficiency of an otto-cycle internal combustion engine [1]. Given two engines, both optimally designed to approach those limits, air-cooling is not as practical or as efficient as water-cooling. This means that for a given displacement, you'll hit the boundaries of air-cooling before you will water-cooling. If you want to continue to increase your power for a given displacement, you have to find a way to dissipate the wasted heat energy. That leads you to water-cooling. It's not that water cooling is that much more efficient, but that it scales more easily. With air-cooling, you have limited space around the cylinders for cooling fins. The head is particularly problematic because of the valve gear. With water-cooling, you can increase the dimensions of the radiator in three dimensions to improve heat dissipation capabilities. 1: http://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/98966/maximum-theoretical-efficiency-of-internal-combustion-engine http://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/98966/maximum-the...
- chrisbennet 11y agoTo expand on that a little: The air cooled heads could not dissipate enough heat to support a 4 valve per cylinder configuration and the noise and pollution goals could not be met with air cooling.
- brc 11y agoSorry, but this is wrong. An air-cooled (technically oil cooled) car has no problem with the transfer of heat. Porsche themselves ran the 917/10k with a flat-12 air cooled twin turbo engine that could make 1000hp reliably. The transition to water cooling in the 911 was done for noise and emissions purposes primarily. A side benefit for them was the ability to buy off-the-shelf HVAC componentry and not have to engineer a heating system based on exhaust heat exchange. It's very easy to get equivalent horsepower out of an air-cooled engine than the current water cooled models. There are plenty of air-cooled turbos pushing 600hp, and the Singer Vehicle Design 911 engines are producing 400 hp based on the original air-cooled 911 engine.
- brudgers 11y agoThe rear engine design of the 911 is still competitive in motor sports [1], as is somewhat befitting of the designation as a sports car. As noted in the article, the weight distribution gives the car a distinct set of cornering characteristics and experienced drivers are often able to employ them to competitive advantage. Physics is not a technology, just physics. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2015_European_Le_Mans_Series_season#LM_GTE_2 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2015_European_Le_Mans_Series_s...
- magila 11y agoThe thing you have to remember about LMGTE is that, like most modern GT series, it is heavily governed by Balance of Performance regulations. Cars are handicapped so that there is relative parity between all of the models competing. This means a car being competitive doesn't necessarily prove the design's superiority. The situation with rear engined Porsches is similar to the one with FWD touring cars. Sure with enough work you can make it perform admirably, but if you were starting from a clean slate you would never deliberately design a race car that way because you'd just be making things harder on yourself than you need to.
- brudgers 11y agoFrom F1 to the 24 hours of Lemons, all racing series are heavily regulated to make things interesting until someone crosses the line first. Even Green Monster had to have wheels not wings strapped to Art Alfons' turbojet.
- Gmo 11y agoNitpick : It's not Lemons, it is Le Mans, named after the place where the circuit is. Or was it an intentional word play ? Then woosh.
- chronolitus 11y agohttps://www.24hoursoflemons.com/ https://www.24hoursoflemons.com/
- brc 11y agoIt also provides a smaller frontal cross section, the flat-six engine provides a lower centre of gravity, and the packaging allows a 2+2 layout when most of the competitors (front, front-mid and mid-engined) are only 2 seaters. The reasons for the rear engine was not primarily to increase traction - it provided simplicity, lightweight and better packaging. The simplicity and lightweight have fallen by the wayside but the packaging still remains. The 911 remains a car which is practical to use as a daily driver.
- bradleyland 11y agoThe debate over whether mid-engine is superior to rear-engine is not an open and shut case. Although proponents of either camp would have you believe otherwise. The advantages of mid-engine are en vogue, so I won't repeat them here, but here are some advantages to a rear-engine car that are often dismissed: Under acceleration, a rear-engine car has an almost absurd traction advantage over any other engine packaging configuration. For example, under acceleration, the 911 has a 74% rear bias, where the Cayman has a 67% bias. Under braking, a rear-engine car has better weight distribution as well. Again, the 911 has a front rear distribution of 58/42 versus 64/36 for the Cayman. I'm not nearly well versed enough in vehicle handling dynamics to hammer out a full-blown debate, but I have read very compelling arguments from both sides of the debate. I transisioned from the "mid-engine is the only compelling packaging format" camp to the "maybe the rear-engine format isn't completely insane" camp.
- LoSboccacc 11y agothen again that's only relevant if you insist in using an absurdly sub optimal traction configuration. longitudinal weight distribution is completely irrelevant for 4wd cars, where none of the listed advantages matter and all the disadvantages with handling do yes, 4wd system absorb some additional power but that's largely irrelevant because: - they can be active and only engage when needed - they absorb some fixed amount of power that become marginal for a very high powered engine - you're at wheel traction limit most of the time anyway at low speed, so absorbing power doesn't really matter - at high speed power absorbed by a 4wd system is largely dwarfed by drag
- andor 11y agolongitudinal weight distribution is completely irrelevant for 4wd cars, where none of the listed advantages matter and all the disadvantages with handling do Four-wheel-drive doesn't help when braking. Less weight on the front wheels (and thus more braking power on the rear) should make cars less likely to understeer.
- LoSboccacc 11y ago