6 ms·
This is good. We need more of these things to happen so that we can get some power behind the anti-software-patent lobby. Software patents have to become too da
by cookiecaper 17y ago
This is good. We need more of these things to happen so that we can get some power behind the anti-software-patent lobby. Software patents have to become too dangerous to keep around, and that happens by things like this; right now, Microsoft and others use patents to lord over Linux and make vague threats about litigation. This is an important part of Microsoft's strategy, so software patents are important to them. But if more awesome things like making it illegal to sell Word and therefore Office happen, it'll be too dangerous to keep software patents around, MS will call up their cronies in Congress, and software patents will be out of commission in a year or less.
I hope all the patent trolls of the world open the floodgates on Microsoft, Apple, and the other behemoths in the computer industry so that we can finally put the issue to rest.
- NathanKP 17y agoAt the same time legitimate software patents can help to protect small software studios and startups. It is a double edged sword.
- josefresco 17y agoI'd say it's still a one-sided sword. The side that crushes real innovation (and brings on crap suits like this) is sharp as hell, the one the 'protects' small startups is pretty blunt.
- Vivtek 17y agoThey're far more often used as bludgeons to drain the defense coffers of small software studios and startups. By the time a patent is granted, that startup has moved on to something better - show me a single software patent that a competent programmer couldn't develop in a few weeks given the description. Not the patented mechanism (that's generally obvious and we all know it), just what the invention is supposed to solve. Software patents are an abuse of the patent system.
- wheels 17y ago> show me a single software patent that a competent programmer couldn't develop in a few weeks given the description. MP3.
- pyre 17y agoIIRC, MPEG Layer-III isn't a single patent. So it's a bit of a misnomer to say that 'MP3' is a patent that a competent programmer couldn't come up with on their own. On the other hand, I've heard some audio people say that MP3 wasn't necessarily anything 'new' to audio engineers/producers. It was just translating into software what people in the business already knew.
- wheels 17y agoIt certainly was new to audio engineers and producers. It wasn't wholly new to researchers in the field of psycho-acoustic compression, but then, there's rarely much that is new for the inner circle of researchers in a field.
- cookiecaper 17y agoI think that competent programmers with relevant training could develop good compression techniques for things like audio and video. In fact, that happens somewhat often.
- krakensden 17y agoRSA. But you're still correct.
- breck 17y ago> "legitimate software patents" I think the issue here is a lot of people don't think there is such a thing.
- wglb 17y agoThere are a few that think they are useful: http://www.paulgraham.com/softwarepatents.html http://www.paulgraham.com/softwarepatents.html
- flatline 17y agoProtection results in a racket as its ultimate end. I see small studios and startups doing just fine right now without patents, which are expensive and require a lot of specialized knowledge to apply for. Who is being protected from what by patents, exactly?
- krakensden 17y agoThis. The only people who can afford and want to lawyer up with patents are exactly the people who shouldn't have them. There are some rare exceptions, but continuing to punish the majority for their sake seems silly.
- kelnos 17y agoI suppose it depends on how you define "expensive," but they really aren't. I believe the application fee is on the order of a few thousand dollars (in the US only, of course; you can easily rack up a hefty fee if you need to apply in multiple jurisdictions). Doing the actual application and enumerating the claims isn't trivial, but I do know laypeople who have successfully applied for and been granted patents with minimal help from a lawyer (that's where patent applications can get expensive). EDIT: It's even less than I thought from the USPTO side; see http://www.uspto.gov/web/offices/ac/qs/ope/fee2009september15.htm#patapp http://www.uspto.gov/web/offices/ac/qs/ope/fee2009september1...
- wglb 17y agoOne author at http://www.tinaja.com/patnt01.asp http://www.tinaja.com/patnt01.asp feels that the break-even point for patents is $12 to $14 million.
- kelnos 17y agoThat's a little misleading. The article claims that the break-even point is $12-40mn in gross sales. That's a bit of a weird way to put it that doesn't really illuminate the actual cost of patenting something at all. Regardless, suggesting that it costs $12mn to patent something is ludicrous.
- kiba 17y agoIt is presumptuous to think that megacorporation have the foresight to predicts the "next big things" and react accordingly and fast enough. They might not even want to because it will cannibalize their existing business. There's a reason why small startup can run circles around bigger corporations all the time and it's not legal weaponry.
- cloudkj 17y agoI'd argue that, rather than banning software patents outright, the process by which these patents are approved should be put under high scrutiny and changed. For a lot of large companies, the approach really is similar to throwing everything against the wall and seeing what sticks. Having gone through the process recently, I'm amazed at how easy it is for an engineer to conceive an idea, pitch it to a few paralegals and lawyers, and get it written up to submit to the USPTO. IMHO, there's a big disconnect between the engineering minds that actually come up with legitimate patentable ideas and the IP attorneys that write and file the patents. Getting rid of software patents altogether is quite extreme. You need a mechanism in place to protect the property rights of individuals and corporations. When there's absolutely no sense of preservation of property - whether it be tangible or intangible - innovation and risk taking are going to suffer.
- steveklabnik 17y ago> Getting rid of software patents altogether is quite extreme. Really? I'd think that most people in software have the opinion that there should be no software patents at all. It's kind of silly, frankly.
- voidpointer 17y agoThe software companies themselves often argue that they don' really want software patents. However, the fact that other can file patents puts them into a position where they need to file patents themselves for protection. It's just a stupid arms race. Now and then, a patent troll with noting to lose shows up and shakes up the picture. You could call it a sort of IP terrorism :-)
- seldo 17y agoI think using the phrase "IP terrorist" rather than "patent troll" would make it much easier to sell to congress why these patents are a bad idea.
- steveklabnik 17y ago
- discojesus 17y agoawesome things like making it illegal to sell Word and therefore Office How about just making your open source alternative to Word and Office that much better and competing with them? * edit: downmodded without justification. Wonderful. Which just forces the quality of discussion on HN WAY down. Ironically, understanding that concept requires understanding incentives, which are the basis of patents in the first place :)
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- philwelch 17y agoI downmodded you because you demonstrated a total misunderstanding of cookiecaper's point, quoted him out of context, and made a totally irrelevant response. He wasn't making any kind of attack or criticism against Microsoft Word or Office, he was arguing that this kind of disruptive litigation will provide an impetus to lobby against software patents.
- ericb 17y agoThe problem with your just simply build your own open source competitor theory, aside from being a glib response, is that you are quite likely to be violating a patent Microsoft or someone else holds when you build said system. Complaining about downvoting is itself noise, which will generally only get you downvoted further.
- ghshephard 17y agodiscojesus - the ENTIRE point of patenting "Office/Excel/Spreashdeet/Word" processes and systems is to PREVENT open source alternatives to Word and Office. We're talking about _patents_, not copyrights here. Nobody is suggesting that Software Copyrights aren't perfectly valid and an important part of the industry - without even having to Poll, I'm going to guess that 90% of HN residents are strong proponents of Software Copyrights. The Free-Software proponents, even those on the GPL V3 bandwagon, _rely_ on Copyrights to further their aims and ambitions.
- noonespecial 17y agoWould it be possible (and IANAL so I've got no idea) to simply not make your products available in this whacked out district of east Texas? Just refuse to ship by mail or retail to any address in the district in order to make sure the trolls can't force you into this venue? It would be no small measure of poetic justice if in return for making themselves an enormous public nuisance and doing irreparable harm to the patent system, all of their residents had to drive a hundred miles every time they wanted an ipod. Edit: Moved from the thread about this that didn't take off. Edit: On downvote: I actually wasn't trying to make a snarky point etc. I really would like to know. Is it possible, if some venues just become too hostile, to simply not sell to them or is it an "anywhere in America = everywhere in America" kind of thing? In other words, is there any way at all to keep patent trolls from dragging you down to their funny little puppet court in nowhere-ville east Texas? Give me my -4, I'm cool with that, but could someone take a moment to answer?
- krschultz 17y agoFederal Court so afaik enforced nation wide.
- noonespecial 17y agoIndeed the results are enforced nation wide. The question is; why do trolls seem to always be able to force the venue to be this tiny court in Marshall Texas where all the cards seem stacked against the defendant? Is there any way to prevent this?
- dpatru 17y agoThe best way to get a bad law repealed is to enforce it strictly. --Abraham Lincoln
- algorias 17y agoWhat about collateral damage of such enforcement?
- lsb 17y agoMicrosoft will do everything in its power to make sure it can sell Office. They have tens of billions of dollars to ensure that this doesn't happen.
- andreyf 17y agoExcept this doesn't apply here in the least. Microsoft has a lot more to gain from strict patent enforcement than it has to lose. This is hardly a good reason for Microsoft to give up all of the effort they've put into their software patent portfolio.
- Retric 17y agoI don't think they have enforced a single patent and they have paid out ~1billion to patent trolls so I find it hard to believe patents are a net gain for them.
- Jach 17y agoI tend to agree, but I'm also concerned that the more often patents are held up in court, the harder it's going to be to get rid of them. I remain hopeful though that Congress will get lobbied to legislate an end to patents, and the Supreme Court is facing some very interesting cases and seem in favor of the Open crowd.